Monday, August 3rd 2026

Microsoft Denies New Tracking Service in Windows 11

Over the weekend, social media drama took a turn when the community accused Microsoft of running a new background tracking service on Windows 11. However, the company officially denies this. The whole event started on July 31st when a user on X noticed a new background service called "Windows Health and Optimized Experiences" that starts automatically every time the system is booted. This background service monitors the CPU's thermals and reportedly sends data every 15 minutes. However, this feature is not actually new and is used for diagnostics. According to Microsoft VP Scott Hanselman, when Windows 11 detects slow or sluggish behavior, it can record performance traces that can be sent to Microsoft via the Feedback Hub.

The service is not standalone telemetry but is initiated by Windows 11 itself, saving these files under "%SystemRoot%\Temp\DiagOutputDir\Whesvc." These files are stored locally, but there is an option to send them back to Microsoft for diagnostics and to improve future experiences using the Feedback Hub. Contrary to the fear-inducing post, this data-sending service is optional if the user chooses to submit a report. Additionally, Microsoft did not suddenly introduce this feature to Windows 11, as it has existed for over a year, having been included in the Windows 11 Canary build introduced in May 2025.
Finally, it is worth pointing out that while this claim was misleading, Microsoft has previously introduced background tracking services with each new Windows version. However, these days the company is focusing on getting the Windows 11 operating system to function properly with 8 GB of RAM, delivering better performance, and improving the core experience, without adding new AI or telemetry services to the operating system that powers hundreds of millions of devices.
Source: Scott Hanselman on X
Add your own comment

27 Comments on Microsoft Denies New Tracking Service in Windows 11

#1
tsunami2311
serivice been there for months, I also have it disabled and CTFmon that was recent found to be keylog every keystroke
Posted on Reply
#2
windwhirl
tsunami2311serivice been there for months, I also have it disabled and CTFmon that was recent found to be keylog every keystroke
CTFmon is a language-related service
Posted on Reply
#3
_roman_
the core definiton of spyware, data is collected and send with an unknown payload

i was not informed, therefore it is malware. e.g. notification window with consent, opt in for such.

somewhere else it was stated that microsoft fingerprints ever windows 11 pro installation during installation, this is done wiht the iso.

they no new track service is false, there are track services anyway inside, if not proof me otherwise. I can not proof they exists and no one can give me strong proof that they do not exists.

just in case when you wonder where it is

roman@Wheat_Nas /mnt/windows/Users/Default $ mc

roman@Wheat_Nas /mnt/windows/Windows/Temp/DiagOutputDir $ pwd
/mnt/windows/Windows/Temp/DiagOutputDir

you may replace mnt windows with c:
Posted on Reply
#4
lexluthermiester
On this matter, microsoft is correct. The service in question is part of the user feedback system and is completely optional. It's also easily disabled/removed. Mr Scott Hanselman needs to do more homework before making such statements. Though, I applaud the effort to keep a watchful eye and throw out the public alert. He only needed to look into it further before making the statement.
tsunami2311serivice been there for months, I also have it disabled and CTFmon that was recent found to be keylog every keystroke
windwhirlCTFmon is a language-related service
Windwhirl is correct. CTFmon is not a telemetry service and does not transmit anything to microsoft.
_roman_i was not informed, therefore it is malware. e.g. notification window with consent, opt in for such.
Um, you too need to do more research. The logs in question are ONLY transmitted with a feedback report, which has to be started and made manually BY YOU, the user. This is not a part of the automatic telemetry system built into Windows.
_roman_somewhere else it was stated that microsoft fingerprints ever windows 11 pro installation during installation, this is done wiht the iso.
That(GDID) is a function not related to this article.
_roman_they no new track service is false, there are track services anyway inside, if not proof me otherwise. I can not proof they exists and no one can give me strong proof that they do not exists.
Oh just stop, you're getting silly.


Keep in mind folks, these corrections are coming from MR Fricken Paranoid(me).
Posted on Reply
#5
ymdhis
Title is misleading, they confirmed that it's been there for a while, only denied that it's "new".
Posted on Reply
#6
AleksandarK
News Editor
ymdhisTitle is misleading, they confirmed that it's been there for a while, only denied that it's "new".
It is not a tracking service, it is not a new service either. It is a diagnostic service mislabeled as a tracking service.
Posted on Reply
#7
Easo
And clearly the sky is falling again.
/s
Posted on Reply
#9
chrcoluk
Telemetry or not they need to stop with all these background services and tasks, its way more than other OS does like Linux out of the box.
Posted on Reply
#10
Mack4285
Can it get worse than that GDID that MS uses to track every Windows 11 machine on the internet, even through VPN? That alone should be enough for everyone to jump ship, imo.
Posted on Reply
#11
Fluke
Is there an overview that shows what kind of analytics/spyware services can be safely discarded?
I used Privacy Sexy for that purpose, but the maintainer has vanished into thin air.
Posted on Reply
#12
Tomorrow
What about CrossDeviceResume?

Introduced silently via monthly security update.
No uninstall option in settings or even via PowerShell.
Ignores Off toggle in settings (Apps > Resume).
Ignores Group Policy settings.
Ignores Registry flags to disable it.
Autostarts at every restart.
Restarts if process is killed in Task Manager.

Behaves like literal malware. The only way to disable it is to manually rename these files and live with the "cannot execute" error at every start:
"C:\Windows\SystemApps\MicrosoftWindows.Client.CBS_cw5n1h2txyewy"
CrossDeviceResume.exe
CrossDeviceResumeView.dll

www.elevenforum.com/t/enable-or-disable-resume-app-from-device-and-continue-on-windows-11-pc.29671/
Posted on Reply
#13
notoperable
Windows = true SaaS ;) aka Spyware as a System = Data value extraction planetwide operation siphoning
what everyone does every time- when will people finally understand that simple truth, Windows is a data extraction operation and not an operating system ...

Windows service description should be a copy writing category of it own, no other company can write in so many words nothing of
any factual value or information. However, no one can beat the number 1. in system troubleshooting logging:

"something went wrong" - this is obfuscation end stage- the final boss level, only m$ can deliver such valuable error message

Since 2020 Windows background services doubled in amount, today its I guess around ~ 220, and those are not drivers, those are
some masterfully described something. You can actually disable 75% of those, and Windows will work, as long as you can live without the M$ Store, but who needs that anyways?
Posted on Reply
#14
AusWolf
So they're not tracking you. They just want you to be the beta tester of a product that you already paid for. Great! :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#15
lexluthermiester
AusWolfSo they're not tracking you.
Not with this service, no. They have other services for that..
Posted on Reply
#16
zenlessyank
My PC is easy to track. Just put a stick pin on the map and leave it. I'm too old for LAN parties.
Posted on Reply
#17
tsunami2311
windwhirlCTFmon is a language-related service
Original that is what is was for, it is much more then that at this point you can defualt behavior of CTFmon at this point has cpu spikes anytime you typing and click cause it log it, you either disable or regedit a change to stop log and there for cpu spikes every time you typing, and leave it running cause disabling breaks search in startmenu
Posted on Reply
#18
lexluthermiester
tsunami2311Original that is what is was for, it is much more then that at this point you can defualt behavior of CTFmon at this point has cpu spikes anytime you typing and click cause it log it, you either disable or regedit a change to stop log and there for cpu spikes every time you typing, and leave it running cause disabling breaks search in startmenu
There is a difference between keystroke monitoring(because how would we use a keyboard otherwise) and keystroke logging. Understanding the difference in both function and applied use-case brings context awareness.
Posted on Reply
#19
notoperable
lexluthermiesterThere is a difference between keystroke monitoring(because how would we use keyboard otherwise) and keystroke logging. Understanding the difference in both function and applied use-case brings context awareness.
There you got it, for Us, the Users, there is a clear distinction - to M$, there is none :-)
Posted on Reply
#20
lexluthermiester
notoperableThere you got it, for Us, the Users, there is a clear distinction - to M$, there is none :-)
From a legal liability standpoint, yes there is. microsoft has NO choice but to be very careful what Windows logs and transmits phones home. EULA or not, they can not escape standing legal statute where certain levels of confidentiality are concerned.

Tracking user computing behaviour is one thing, tracking what people type is completely another.
Posted on Reply
#21
notoperable
lexluthermiesterFrom a legal liability standpoint, yes there is. microsoft has NO choice but to be very careful what Windows logs and transmits phones home. EULA or not, they can not escape standing legal statute where certain levels of confidentiality are concerned.

Tracking user computing behaviour is one thing, tracking what people type is completely another.
M$ is the undisputed master of obfuscation, you can pick every single packet that Windows sends to Redmond through Wireshark and decrypt TLS on the fly with frida injection into lsass.exe - but, a lot of times the payload is encrypted as well, or/and contains a lot of weird data you cant make sense of without any references to what is it you see. I cant tell, I guess you cant either- but trusting with anything M$ is not in my script. So I agree with the legal parts, but I wouldn't be surprised slightly if "anonymized" telemetry is nothing more then a oxymoron. Not to mention that timestamps make the anonymize parts a joke, a 10 years old with rudimentary skills can overlay data points and pull conclusions that there is 0 doubt about identifying a single person in their data - correlating it is a no brainer
Posted on Reply
#22
AusWolf
notoperableM$ is the undisputed master of obfuscation, you can pick every single packet that Windows sends to Redmond through Wireshark and decrypt TLS on the fly with frida injection into lsass.exe - but, a lot of times the payload is encrypted as well, or/and contains a lot of weird data you cant make sense of without any references to what is it you see. I cant tell, I guess you cant either- but trusting with anything M$ is not in my script. So I agree with the legal parts, but I wouldn't be surprised slightly if "anonymized" telemetry is nothing more then a oxymoron. Not to mention that timestamps make the anonymize parts a joke, a 10 years old with rudimentary skills can overlay data points and pull conclusions that there is 0 doubt about identifying a single person in their data - correlating it is a no brainer
Good point. Sending data that identifies you as a person, and sending data that combined with other data makes it possible to identify you as a person are just a legal loophole away from each other, I suppose.
Posted on Reply
#23
lexluthermiester
notoperableM$ is the undisputed master of obfuscation, you can pick every single packet that Windows sends to Redmond through Wireshark and decrypt TLS on the fly with frida injection into lsass.exe - but, a lot of times the payload is encrypted as well, or/and contains a lot of weird data you cant make sense of without any references to what is it you see. I cant tell, I guess you cant either- but trusting with anything M$ is not in my script. So I agree with the legal parts, but I wouldn't be surprised slightly if "anonymized" telemetry is nothing more then a oxymoron. Not to mention that timestamps make the anonymize parts a joke, a 10 years old with rudimentary skills can overlay data points and pull conclusions that there is 0 doubt about identifying a single person in their data - correlating it is a no brainer
Sorry, but there are some area's microsoft is not allowed to touch.
Posted on Reply
#24
Dukenukemx
lexluthermiesterSorry, but there are some area's microsoft is not allowed to touch.
Phrasing. You know he's been to that island.
Posted on Reply
#25
notoperable
Microsoft business ROI contains lawbreaking as a calculated risk factor since 1995, so whenever you think they don't touch is usually under the hood a whole different game. From all Corporations M$ is the slimy, sleazy, and mos greedy by design. Everything is monetized and extracted, User on owned hardware is a tenant, with lot of effort to eject that user nowadays and put him on continuous drainage by lifelong subscription. If you don't own the hardware, all gloves are off and M$ will have a hay day.
AusWolfGood point. Sending data that identifies you as a person, and sending data that combined with other data makes it possible to identify you as a person are just a legal loophole away from each other, I suppose.
Exactly, the privacy is a complete illusion with so many data points continuously being extracted. Correlation with a timestamp and you can identify any single Person on the planet by correlation, your drive directory structures, their serial numbers, motherboard uuid cpu, all of this is under the umbrella of mandatory telemetry. M$ hijacked this word, since spyware does not sound that nice, telemetry is water-downed marketing word. Does M$ do it? I cant tell, but they don't show any samples, those they show though - is already a red flag. What M$ actually does in terms of storage and processing of the telemetry data - largely unknown, or framed as by small print in matter of interpretation style. Data viewer can show you some. Its the tip oft an iceberg, 90% of the rest you don't see or know about. Don't take my word on it, see for yourself. Data viewer app is one click install, and check what is send. Its insane. They anonymize it to get away with the law loophole - a 7 year old can correlate that in 3 min to point a single person. M$ lately was caught red handed by providing a unique hash that survives reinstall etc. and they gave it to FBI or something in a hacker case.

Do a simple test, install Wireshark, and press any key on your keyboard or start interacting with your mouse on a Windows 11 installation already trimmed by common privacy tools- those skim just the surface, surprise, Windows calls home immediatly, constantly, the moment you push the WIN button actually you see instantly a TCP/IP request being made.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 21st, 2026 22:00 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts