Tuesday, September 22nd 2026

Microsoft Surveys Insiders About Physical Discs for Next-Gen Xbox Console

Microsoft is reportedly surveying gamers about the importance of physical disc media for its next-generation Xbox console. According to findings from Power Up Gaming, Microsoft is conducting this survey through the Xbox Insider Hub application, where a select group of Xbox Insiders are asked about their stance on various topics. Microsoft will later use this feedback to analyze and make decisions. One question asks whether the console should allow users to install games from physical discs, with response options including "Not Necessary," "Nice to Have," and "Must Have."

Considering that Microsoft recently launched its disc-to-digital program, an initiative to promote a digital-only future for Xbox consoles, the viability of physical media is now up for debate. With disc-to-digital, players can insert their game discs into the console to convert them into digital licenses. When the disc is scanned, Microsoft uses the unique key to create a digital license, which prevents the disc from being activated on third-party consoles and stops it from being rented, borrowed, or sold to others.
Just a few weeks ago, Microsoft claimed that the Xbox Disc to Digital program is part of its "broader commitment to game preservation." The program essentially serves as a test run for the Helix console, which is expected to launch with full backward compatibility, despite not having a physical disc drive. Ubisoft has recently joined the program quietly. However, for companies like Sony, physical discs still drive a significant portion of revenue for exclusive titles. Therefore, Microsoft's survey might be about including physical disc media in Project Helix, or at least in some versions of it.
Source: Power Up Gaming
Add your own comment

19 Comments on Microsoft Surveys Insiders About Physical Discs for Next-Gen Xbox Console

#1
FR3D1
Ninja Cat
AleksandarKwhere a select group of Xbox Insiders
The situation is as clear as a glass of Apollinaris:
from an economic standpoint, a physical medium must absolutely be avoided and has had to be for quite some time.

Regards,
Fred
Posted on Reply
#2
Athena
I still don't see a reason for discs, they can easily be replaced by thumbdrives if people want something to hold, think of it like cartridges from the 8-bit days, and they do make read-only devices
Posted on Reply
#3
Steevo
Make it a USB option, alleviate issues by allowing USB Blu-ray drives to be plugged in and connected and to play older games and win the hearts of the gaming and modding community.

It’s a PC with PC hardware, focus on banning online cheaters and sell subscriptions to those who want digital access to libraries of older games, or to those who want to host a private server offsite.

There is absolutely a way to make money and to sell a console at cost and to keep the cost low.
Posted on Reply
#4
claylomax
I'm still confused about the reaction of some people to this; don't the discs just have a key a not game files?
There are always first day patches and more updates later on, so it's not like you can use the disc and play like 20 years ago.
Posted on Reply
#5
TheDeeGee
AthenaI still don't see a reason for discs, they can easily be replaced by thumbdrives if people want something to hold, think of it like cartridges from the 8-bit days, and they do make read-only devices
Yep, my Windows 10 copy came on a thumbdrive as well.
Posted on Reply
#6
Chane
The question doesn't indicate that they'll keep making physical games. They'll stop pressing discs if Sony does. It only asks if being able to install games from discs is a must have. Which I would say yes, because you're not going to be playing a game straight from the disc anyway. They all have to be installed now regardless of if you want to or not and the disc to digital program requires a disc drive. Unless they offer a mail in program.
claylomaxI'm still confused about the reaction of some people to this; don't the discs just have a key a not game files?
There are always first day patches and more updates later on, so it's not like you can use the disc and play like 20 years ago.
Some discs carry the game in a stubbed form, some just enough to initiate the web install and some carry the full game. When they (Xbox, Sony and Nintendo) started shipping stubbed games and requiring installs instead of being played directly from disc/card I switched to all digital. The discs/cards just became inconvenient at that point for me.
Posted on Reply
#7
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
AthenaI still don't see a reason for discs, they can easily be replaced by thumbdrives if people want something to hold, think of it like cartridges from the 8-bit days, and they do make read-only devices
That isn’t the option being given though. It’s either have them or do not, not “have physical media in a different format”.
Posted on Reply
#8
_roman_
Where there any game released which were finsihed on day one in year 2025?

I suspect the nintendo switch, but else?
Posted on Reply
#9
HeadRusch1
I can't *wait* to see what they will want to charge for the special "Collectors Edition w/ Disc"........and the minute this happens those Factories that can still create the discs and then the mass-burner houses are going to just ratchet up the cost because they won't be selling volume anymore, these will be shorter, bespoke runs.....UNLESS every game comes on disc. That would, arguably, be impressive.....but I can't imagine they would price the disc version the same as the digital download in 2027+.
Posted on Reply
#10
chrcoluk
As usual all the good polls are not to all insiders, I have no sign of this poll.

Probably only selected alpha insiders.
Posted on Reply
#11
YaruSP
AthenaI still don't see a reason for discs, they can easily be replaced by thumbdrives if people want something to hold, think of it like cartridges from the 8-bit days, and they do make read-only devices
Thumbdrives are a lot more expensive than disks for the same amount of data hold because they use flash.

This is one of the reasons why not many publishers opt for Switch 2 cartridges, they are insanely expensive to make even in non flash shortage scenarios.

That said if they can make it at affordable price, physical collectors won't have an issue. It's not about disks per say as much as it's about relying on having the data locally and not having the game license tied to an account.
_roman_Where there any game released which were finsihed on day one in year 2025?

I suspect the nintendo switch, but else?
Most games work and are playable on disk on release. Not relying on account link (digital games) or servers (digital games, and game key cards on NS2) is a big plus.
ChaneThe question doesn't indicate that they'll keep making physical games. They'll stop pressing discs if Sony does. It only asks if being able to install games from discs is a must have. Which I would say yes, because you're not going to be playing a game straight from the disc anyway. They all have to be installed now regardless of if you want to or not and the disc to digital program requires a disc drive. Unless they offer a mail in program.


Some discs carry the game in a stubbed form, some just enough to initiate the web install and some carry the full game. When they (Xbox, Sony and Nintendo) started shipping stubbed games and requiring installs instead of being played directly from disc/card I switched to all digital. The discs/cards just became inconvenient at that point for me.
Nintendo first party games don't require installs (other than Pokemon, which they do not fully own). They're playable directly from media.
Posted on Reply
#12
twistedpair
A physical disc let's you own the game. A digital purchase locks you to that account, and potentially even that console type it was purchased for. The answer to resistance free digital only is simple, concede that the license I purchase is my own irrevocable access to said medium. I can loan it out, resell it, donate it, permenantly transfer it, whatever I want. Until then, you can pry my physical media from my cold dead hand.
Posted on Reply
#13
lycan666
Ive always said we need physical media, becoming too reliant to online means that people could lose out if their internet cuts out or if there's a problem on the providers end, at least with physical media your options remain open. I'll always choose consoles with physical options and if they become obsolete then I'll just go back to consoles that allow disks/physical media
Posted on Reply
#14
d1p3n
For me it's this- would you rather own a home or rent a home for the same exact cost, with all else being equal? A physical disc sells for the same price as digital, but there is intrinsic value in the disc. I can sell the disc, trade it in, or let someone borrow it for a fee perhaps. I can buy a game for 70 bucks and beat it in a week or get tired of it and still recoup some of the cost for a future game. Digital medium doesn't allow that. Unless there was going to be a discount for digital games at the point of sale, why, as a consumer, would I want to pay physical disc prices, yet end up with less control over my purchase? If they want to go all-digital, they need to create some sort of storefront functionality for trading and selling these licenses. Otherwise, we as consumers are getting shafted by these mega corps charging us the same 70.00 price, and giving us lesser options under the disguise of "convenience." There are plenty of games not worth 70.00 at launch. But sometimes perusing around Gamestop or a local Walmart, you may see that exact game a fews month later at a steep discount in which you may feel it's worth buying now. When everything is digital, there is no competition for sales. Playstation and Xbox can sell their games at full cost many months down the line because there is no alternative option for gamers. More options for gamers benefits us. Less options for gamers benefits these corps. I root for the little man. #keepthediscs
Posted on Reply
#15
Corvo86
AthenaI still don't see a reason for discs, they can easily be replaced by thumbdrives if people want something to hold, think of it like cartridges from the 8-bit days, and they do make read-only devices
Assassins Creed Shadows £41 physical and £69.99 digital.
Star Wars Outlaws £21.85 physical and £69.99 digital.
Blood of dawnwalker is £52 physical and £59.99 digital.
Outer worlds 2 is £44 physical and £59.99 digital.
Pragmata £43 physical and £49.99 digital.
Resident Evil Requiem £44.95 physical and £64.99 digital.
Lego Batman legacy of the Dark Knight £44.99 physical and £59.99 digital.
Ghost of Tsushima directors cut £34.95 physical and £59.99 digital.
Baldurs gate 3 £52.19 physical and £57.99 digital.
Street Fighter 6 £21 physical and £34.99 digital.
Fable £54.99 physical and £59.99 digital.
Silent Hill F £59.99 physical and £69.99 digital.
Metal Gear Solid master collection vol 2 £42.99 physical and £44.99 digital
Ghost of Yotei £54.83 physical and £69.99 digital
If you were to buy all of these games you would pay £612.78 for physical and £842.85 for digital

Its been a month since I checked these prices so they may have changed but the point still stands

When they get rid of physical discs then the ONLY place to buy a playstation game is through their store at whatever price they decide. There will be no more price competition and the savings they get from not printing discs and shipping to stores will not get passes on to the customer

They are also testing out dynamic pricing where they will be able to charge different people different prices. So if they think they will be able to get a bit more mkney from you they will charge you more
Posted on Reply
#16
Athena
Corvo86Assassins Creed Shadows £41 physical and £69.99 digital.
Star Wars Outlaws £21.85 physical and £69.99 digital.
Blood of dawnwalker is £52 physical and £59.99 digital.
Outer worlds 2 is £44 physical and £59.99 digital.
Pragmata £43 physical and £49.99 digital.
Resident Evil Requiem £44.95 physical and £64.99 digital.
Lego Batman legacy of the Dark Knight £44.99 physical and £59.99 digital.
Ghost of Tsushima directors cut £34.95 physical and £59.99 digital.
Baldurs gate 3 £52.19 physical and £57.99 digital.
Street Fighter 6 £21 physical and £34.99 digital.
Fable £54.99 physical and £59.99 digital.
Silent Hill F £59.99 physical and £69.99 digital.
Metal Gear Solid master collection vol 2 £42.99 physical and £44.99 digital
Ghost of Yotei £54.83 physical and £69.99 digital
If you were to buy all of these games you would pay £612.78 for physical and £842.85 for digital

Its been a month since I checked these prices so they may have changed but the point still stands

When they get rid of physical discs then the ONLY place to buy a playstation game is through their store at whatever price they decide. There will be no more price competition and the savings they get from not printing discs and shipping to stores will not get passes on to the customer

They are also testing out dynamic pricing where they will be able to charge different people different prices. So if they think they will be able to get a bit more mkney from you they will charge you more
I was curious and I just checked the first two titles and I saw this...




So, doesn't that depend on where or when you buy it?

Like the stuff on the PS5 store might be MSRP and other places have it for cheaper? Though in this case, the Playstation store has a sale for Assassin's creed

That's usually how it works... (I don't shop for PS5/Xbox games)
Posted on Reply
#17
Dr. Dro
twistedpairA physical disc let's you own the game. A digital purchase locks you to that account, and potentially even that console type it was purchased for. The answer to resistance free digital only is simple, concede that the license I purchase is my own irrevocable access to said medium. I can loan it out, resell it, donate it, permenantly transfer it, whatever I want. Until then, you can pry my physical media from my cold dead hand.
This is easily disproven by the fact you need to follow several steps to be authorized to play your physical game. You may own the plastic, but you do not own the software contained within, nor can you use the software as you please due to digital rights management. DRM is the enemy, not digital distribution.
Posted on Reply
#18
Corvo86
AthenaI was curious and I just checked the first two titles and I saw this...




So, doesn't that depend on where or when you buy it?

Like the stuff on the PS5 store might be MSRP and other places have it for cheaper? Though in this case, the Playstation store has a sale for Assassin's creed

That's usually how it works... (I don't shop for PS5/Xbox games)
Thats a sale though. When the sale ends it goes back up in price.

When the physical price drops it stays there as they want rid of the older games so they have space for the newer ones

Thats not a problem for digital

Also digital should be cheaper anyway as they have no production cost for printing discs or storage and delivery costs but they kept the prices the same.

I get the convenience of digital but the prices are a rip off

I also rechecked the prices. On amazon AC Shadows is £39.99 and the UK PS store its £69.99 and on the Irish store where I would buy digital games its €79.99

You can see why I would not want the end of physical games as an option
Posted on Reply
#19
twistedpair
Dr. DroThis is easily disproven by the fact you need to follow several steps to be authorized to play your physical game. You may own the plastic, but you do not own the software contained within, nor can you use the software as you please due to digital rights management. DRM is the enemy, not digital distribution.
You're wrong. Just because you need to install or update or create an account on the publisher's system, that's just normal bullshit. The authorization for the title resides on the disc for 99% of the games. That disc which I own and can sell, loan, or trade AS I SEE FIT. The authorization FOLLOWS THE DISC. The exception might be something with a subscription like ESO or something that you get a cd key with and once you use it to create your account you're done, again that's the exception not the rule. If you can't see that as a major difference I don't know what to tell you.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 12th, 2026 04:40 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts