Wednesday, October 7th 2026

Gears of War: E-Day Launches to Modest Reviews and 31,500 Peak Steam Players

Gears of War: E-Day, the origin story of the long-running Gears of War franchise, launched on Steam, Xbox, and Game Pass, and, although Microsoft has been building hype for the new Gears game for several months leading up to launch day, the game's launch performance on Steam is less than stellar. According to SteamDB, E-Day peaked at a somewhat underwhelming 31,517 concurrent players on Steam, although there's a strong chance much of its player base is playing the game via Game Pass or on the Xbox Series consoles. To be fair, the game launched in the middle of the week, so we may see an upward trend in player counts over launch weekend.

Reviews for Gears of War: E-Day have also been lukewarm, with Steam's Review rating reporting that only 74% of reviews on the platform are positive. On its own, that score isn't terrible, but the negative reviews seem to stem from issues with stability and gameplay and the plot. Some of the reviews complained about frequent crashes on PC, while many long-time fans seem to have had issues with what they refer to a misleading marketing that advertised a return to old characters from the series, only for those characters to be replaced early on. There are also complaints about the multiplayer gameplay missing features, like custom lobbies and meat shields.
Sources: Steam, SteamDB
Add your own comment

44 Comments on Gears of War: E-Day Launches to Modest Reviews and 31,500 Peak Steam Players

#26
londiste
Vayra86Oh you mean that service that's undergoing heavy restructuring because it has not turned a profit over the last decade despite billions of investment, that one??
Yes, I mean that one. First-party games like GoW get good amount of sales and usage on Xbox platform, both because AFAIK it is again one of these crossplatform games where buying it on Xbox gives it to you both on PC as well as Xbox. And Game Pass, as much as it can be a loss leader, gives you access to GoW on day 1 for slightly reasonable sum (20£$€?). As the post before yours nicely explained - if you want to go through campaign then you can do it in a month for a much lower cost.

Steam might be the dominant platform for PC gaming but that dominance isn't quite that pronounced for this type of releases.
Posted on Reply
#27
kikimaru024
Inverted PolarityModest reviews my ass.

The game is a perfect example of "modern gaming". Insufferable character that is unlikeable in every way, made to be the center of the story. Main characters that you actually want to see (and that were put front and center in advertising) take a back seat to the insufferable character. On top of that, the game runs very poorly even on top of the line hardware.

Just read the negative Steam reviews to get a sense of what is going on.

It's a game not even worth sailing the high seas for.
I read the negative reviews

It just sounds like they don't like women & wanted to see their Dom x Marcus fanfics to come to life instead.
Posted on Reply
#28
FierceRed
kikimaru024I read the negative reviews

It just sounds like they don't like women & wanted to see their Dom x Marcus fanfics to come to life instead.
EVERYONE wanted to see their Dom x Marcus fanfics come to life. Dom x Marcus are the Gears of Wars franchise.

Isn't Rush Hour about Jackie Chan and Chris Rock? Isn't Lethal Weapon about Mel Gibson and Danny Glover? Isn't Bad Boys about Martin Lawrence and Will Smith?

Give the people what they want.
oxrufiioxo...but if you can't handle a women telling you what to do you won't like it.
Didn't we all have mothers?? :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#29
oxrufiioxo
z1tuYou despise indie games, wtf?
Just a personal preference, I've never played a single indie I liked unless you count Expedition 33. Recent ones I've tried are Hades, Dead cells, and stardew valley.

I find it generally impressive what they accomplish with a small team though.

Just not my cup of tea. Although with every year less and less games are made that I enjoy in general.

Despise is too strong a word, I hear about how great a specific indie game is try and and go wtf is this $#!+....
FierceRedDidn't we all have mothers?? :laugh:
Apparently a lot of online dude bros have a terrible relationship with their moms and it shows lol.
Posted on Reply
#30
HazeHazeHaze
DAPUNISHERI have not played it. Could you elucidate on some of the regressions? All I see is the chuds melting down because characters clearly ripped off from Vasquez in Aliens and the captain from starship troopers, are in the game. Talk about low T. The other reviews I have seen are glazing it for the same reasons. A review that breaks down game play mechanics, story, and continuity would be welcomed.
The game is really good. Long time gears fan since the original 06.

Idk why people are obsessed with a supporting character. She is not the focus of the story, Marcus and Dom are. She's just part of bravo squad and a solid character. You can tell most people are just regurgitating some influencer and have not played the game

Campaign might be the best campaign yet. Starts off really well and draws you in (I think mags had like 5 lines in act 1). Act 2 is the slowest act but picks back up after that. There is kinda an open world and it slows the pace down. The linear levels are some of the best set pieces I ever played.

The graphics are top notch, I'm playing on PC with a 4070 and have to use frame gen. The input delay is minimal in this game with it on. I'm getting 140 fps with it on at 1440p and feels super smooth and responsive. I usually can feel delay with frame gen, but it is not noticable for me with eday. I have no idea how it looks or plays on series S or series X. The coalition has already released a performance patch that provided a 10% increase overall. Gears 5 was a bit rough when it launched but now one of the smoothest games out.

I have never been big on horde and I find horde siege entertaining but a bit boring. I don't really want to grind out my parts and levels, but some people really seem to like it.

Versus has been a blast. Ranked is coming next week. There are some mechanics missing (meat shields, made tags, chainsaw fuels), and stuff that needs work. But the core combat is fluid. Movement is the biggest change and took a bit to get used to. But it's the best gears has ever felt. The new movement mechanics have a higher skill cap that previous gears. There's nothing more satisfying in gaming than chunking someone with the gnasher. Only 6 maps right now, but they are all great. I expect new maps shortly. The playlist is limited but will open up as the season progresses and ranked is launched. Also weekly rotating game modes.

Overall I would give it a 8.5/10 in its current state. The game play and story are top nutch. A few bugs and some performance issues to iron out and it's easily a 9.5/10.
Posted on Reply
#31
DAPUNISHER
AusWolfWhy is launch day so important with a game?
Not every game. But with franchises like Halo and Gears i.e. killer apps for the OG and 360 it is a different dynamic than a indie or AA game catching fire over time because of great viral marketing and user reviews. Pre-orders and initial sales are usually a good indicator of whether the game will be a hit or not. As they get a lot more hype and advertising. With an estimated 30 million+ game pass users and a similar number of XBOX series console owners, Steam is probably not the best indicator of sales or player counts.

Corpos love recurring monthly income. So getting people to pay for GP premium or buy it from them directly, is much more important than Steam sales where a significant portion of the proceeds are taken as fees.
Posted on Reply
#32
Gooigi's Ex
Woooooow. So much forced hate on a game. Crazy…but I forget sometimes where I’m at…

Anyways, played the game, including the beta and had a great time especially with friends. The controls were actually pretty good. I mainly used keyboard and mouse but I used a Xbox Controller and it was pretty good as well. Like that you can freely jump and move around compared to the much older games(wouldn’t say Gears 5 is a much older game yet…) hate the run physics and yeah it looks pretty but has some bugs running around.

Enjoyed Horde mode and the PVP despite the forced hatred.
Posted on Reply
#33
DAPUNISHER
Gratitude for the reviews.

As an OG Gears head myself, I will definitely put this on my wishlist for my family to buy me this Xmas. Like most, I am hard to buy for, so it makes it easy on them.
Posted on Reply
#34
AusWolf
DAPUNISHERNot every game. But with franchises like Halo and Gears i.e. killer apps for the OG and 360 it is a different dynamic than a indie or AA game catching fire over time because of great viral marketing and user reviews. Pre-orders and initial sales are usually a good indicator of whether the game will be a hit or not. As they get a lot more hype and advertising. With an estimated 30 million+ game pass users and a similar number of XBOX series console owners, Steam is probably not the best indicator of sales or player counts.

Corpos love recurring monthly income. So getting people to pay for GP premium or buy it from them directly, is much more important than Steam sales where a significant portion of the proceeds are taken as fees.
Pre-orders only exist because people are stupid.
Posted on Reply
#35
DAPUNISHER
AusWolfPre-orders only exist because people are stupid.
That's not wrong mostly. I did preorder the OG back in 06 with my bro and friends, and we all played co-op the second it went live. Some games know the target audience and hit the bullseye. Gears was Cliffy B and the gang so we had zero doubts it was going to be a banger.
Posted on Reply
#36
TechLurker
friocasaI guess it was too late to cancel/change it, so they hide in the trailers some stuff/characters
Wouldn't be surprising; Sony began cancelling most of the live-service games in development except the ones furthest along that they betted on becoming a sleeper hit. So we get crap like Fairgame$, Concord, Marathon, and Horizon Hunters Gathering. Concord's already been shut down and probably made a tax write-off.

And look at what's being done to salvage them in a last-gasp attempt:

Marathon - Being turned into a Destiny-lite to try and widen the audience, while swearing they will keep the extraction shooter element core that only the sweats love. Is becoming desperate enough that rumors coming from insiders is that they might try to retcon Marathon's background to tie into Destiny.

Fairgame$ - The character designs changed from the initial concept into more generic raiders, the game's atmosphere pulled back into more of a Payday clone with Extraction Shooter elements instead of Fortnite Payday, and the new game slogans are more just about running a heist or attempting to steal from the stealers instead of "steal from the rich".

Horizon Hunters Gathering - Reception and initial playtesting so negative that insiders report that Sony is basically overhauling the entire premise, possibly into an offline game.
friocasaMore layoffs are coming, which is great, but the issue now is what to do with the franchise, and who can be trusted for the next game
Asha will probably end up doing to Gears of War what she did with Halo; give it to another studio and just let them reset/reboot the franchise without any ties to prior characters; just the universe and core elements and see if a game from a fresh angle can salvage the series. It would be hilarious but unsurprising if she gave it to Activision too, and Activision giving it to one of their sub-studio team; maybe High Moon Studios, given their work on the well-reviewed Transformers War for Cybertron game and having also done work for Destiny 2.
AusWolfPre-orders only exist because people are stupid.
Pre-Orders once had a legitimate purpose; to secure your physical copy before the local game store or early internet store ran out of their initial allocation and would need to wait a week or two for the next shipment. And Pre-Order bonuses used to be worth it; a physical booklet with art and extra lore details or behind-the-scenes commentary from the devs, a physical audio CD, some physical exclusive collectible that showed you were a hardcore fan, and/or even exclusive in-game content that would never be available to anyone else after, as thanks for supporting the game Day-1.

Nowadays, Preorders are only if you want the digital extras, which is a far cry from the preorders of old. Now it's just 3 layers of Preorders; Base, Deluxe, and Collector's, and the only differences are the extra extras each tier gets over base. And most come with the fine print that the exclusives will later become available as regular DLC or unlocks in-game after the exclusivity period ends.
Posted on Reply
#37
AusWolf
TechLurkerPre-Orders once had a legitimate purpose; to secure your physical copy before the local game store or early internet store ran out of their initial allocation and would need to wait a week or two for the next shipment. And Pre-Order bonuses used to be worth it; a physical booklet with art and extra lore details or behind-the-scenes commentary from the devs, a physical audio CD, some physical exclusive collectible that showed you were a hardcore fan, and/or even exclusive in-game content that would never be available to anyone else after, as thanks for supporting the game Day-1.
Very true. I did pre-order The Witcher 3 collector's edition which came with a T-shirt, a wolf medallion, a Geralt fighting the griffin statue, and a hard cover art book, all in a massive box signed by every developer of the game.

What do you get nowadays? An extra weapon skin? A pdf art book? Pff...
Posted on Reply
#38
Vayra86
londisteYes, I mean that one. First-party games like GoW get good amount of sales and usage on Xbox platform, both because AFAIK it is again one of these crossplatform games where buying it on Xbox gives it to you both on PC as well as Xbox. And Game Pass, as much as it can be a loss leader, gives you access to GoW on day 1 for slightly reasonable sum (20£$€?). As the post before yours nicely explained - if you want to go through campaign then you can do it in a month for a much lower cost.

Steam might be the dominant platform for PC gaming but that dominance isn't quite that pronounced for this type of releases.
Yeah and imagine this, even with all those perks (the vast majority is really 'whatever land', I mean if you have either an Xbox or PC, what are you gonna do, compare them side by side? They're both fixed devices in the same house :D) they still can't turn a profit on this fantastic service :) That's how monstrously many sales they make.

What really happens is this: Microsoft makes at best 20 bucks off their triple A killer app because everyone will just sub it for a month and move on. Its not like the game requires more time to be seen. Microsoft is just hoping you forget to cancel that sub, its the good old subscription tactic we've seen since paper magazines, and it really doesn't work, hasn't worked, and will never truly work unless you're a bottom tier customer with no brain. And there's ever less of those, because people can use the internet now.

So, TL DR, YES, it really does matter what number of actual Steam sales the game gets. Games people will be coming back to on the PC are virtually NEVER bought through Microsoft and the people that do are generally just oblivious of the implications, while the price conscious customers just sub Pass for as little time as they can - and those ARE NOT sales of the game.
Posted on Reply
#39
wolf
Better Than Native
Gooigi's ExSo much forced hate on a game
Not just games, but shows, movies, hardware, experiences... Just about anything.

Like I get were living through some strange times, and for sure some.. Shall we say 'products' are absolute garbage nobody should be scammed into buying, but being negative is so cheap and easy and yet so tiring to see when it's so repetitive, predictable, often done for validation and about every, single, damn, thing on repeat.

This game seems like a genuinely good time, keen to play when I'm back from vacation.
Posted on Reply
#40
Vayra86
wolfNot just games, but shows, movies, hardware, experiences... Just about anything.

Like I get were living through some strange times, and for sure some.. Shall we say 'products' are absolute garbage nobody should be scammed into buying, but being negative is so cheap and easy and yet so tiring to see when it's so repetitive, predictable, often done for validation and about every, single, damn, thing on repeat.

This game seems like a genuinely good time, keen to play when I'm back from vacation.
I think its a matter of perception (like most things... but ok) and experience.

There is a point of no return when it comes to mainstream media shit. There is a moment people get fed up with the braindead peer-pressure infused 'pop culture' and everything that is connected to it. I'm solid past that point, just can't stand it, it represents everything that's wrong with our society and its systems, and it shows in the final product too, its hard to unsee. So yes, it applies to a vast range of content these days. Luckily, there is also a vast range of alternative content that suffers far less to not at all from said 'triple A' culture. Does that mean I can't have a good time playing, say, Gears of War E-commerce day? Perhaps I can. The real question is, do I want to keep funding this cluster, and is it really worth it? The answer is a resounding no.

At the same time you can see the real world reacts; Microsoft being in the state it is in now, is entirely because of the above sentiment being more broadly shared among gamers and in entertainment in a broad sense. So, if it needed any further confirmation: Yes, we are done with the old. In with the new. Younger generations and independent minds are making far better content now, and generally do it because of, and in, a radically better environment and motivation.

I just want to underline: the people 'against' are not wrong. They are right. The rest is just a bit slower to adjust - the market is speaking clearly at this point.
Posted on Reply
#41
wolf
Better Than Native
Vayra86I just want to underline: the people 'against' are not wrong. They are right.
Only a sith deals in absolutes.
Posted on Reply
#42
AusWolf
Vayra86I think its a matter of perception (like most things... but ok) and experience.

There is a point of no return when it comes to mainstream media shit. There is a moment people get fed up with the braindead peer-pressure infused 'pop culture' and everything that is connected to it. I'm solid past that point, just can't stand it, it represents everything that's wrong with our society and its systems, and it shows in the final product too, its hard to unsee. So yes, it applies to a vast range of content these days. Luckily, there is also a vast range of alternative content that suffers far less to not at all from said 'triple A' culture. Does that mean I can't have a good time playing, say, Gears of War E-commerce day? Perhaps I can. The real question is, do I want to keep funding this cluster, and is it really worth it? The answer is a resounding no.

At the same time you can see the real world reacts; Microsoft being in the state it is in now, is entirely because of the above sentiment being more broadly shared among gamers and in entertainment in a broad sense. So, if it needed any further confirmation: Yes, we are done with the old. In with the new. Younger generations and independent minds are making far better content now, and generally do it because of, and in, a radically better environment and motivation.

I just want to underline: the people 'against' are not wrong. They are right. The rest is just a bit slower to adjust - the market is speaking clearly at this point.
I think this is a far more complex issue than some try to represent it.

First, most of mainstream media being shit is without question. There are standards to story writing, character formation, CGI, everything. This is not up to opinion. The real question is what we do with it. Here are the options as I see it:
1. We can just not consume. Then we just get hammered the message that this is what we're getting whether we like it or not as a response from the studios. Some people will keep consuming anyway, which keeps the boat afloat, so all we've achieved at this point is that we became hermits with an extensive DVD collection. Bravo!
2. We can complain about it. That just brands us toxic, argumentative, misogynistic a-holes who "hate everything" - which is not true, but it's far more convenient than making an effort to see what our complaints are actually about, whether there's any element of truth in them or not. Any kind of criticism is met with an even greater amount of toxic positivity. So again, we've achieved nothing.
3. I'm open for suggestions what to write here. I'm at a loss. :(
Posted on Reply
#43
Vayra86
AusWolfI think this is a far more complex issue than some try to represent it.

First, most of mainstream media being shit is without question. There are standards to story writing, character formation, CGI, everything. This is not up to opinion. The real question is what we do with it. Here are the options as I see it:
1. We can just not consume. Then we just get hammered the message that this is what we're getting whether we like it or not as a response from the studios. Some people will keep consuming anyway, which keeps the boat afloat, so all we've achieved at this point is that we became hermits with an extensive DVD collection. Bravo!
2. We can complain about it. That just brands us toxic, argumentative, misogynistic a-holes who "hate everything" - which is not true, but it's far more convenient than making an effort to see what our complaints are actually about, whether there's any element of truth in them or not. Any kind of criticism is met with an even greater amount of toxic positivity. So again, we've achieved nothing.
3. I'm open for suggestions what to write here. I'm at a loss. :(
Just look at music; its still highly varied and numerous styles exist besides mainstream pop. Gaming is no different - just keep promoting and doing what you like best and let others discover it too. Thats the solution.
Posted on Reply
#44
lambda
Let's try to keep the discussion to the game itself.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 06:53 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts