Wednesday, October 28th 2026

Valve Won't "Be Gatekeepers" by Banning AI Games, As "AI Slop" Complaints Grow

Valve has a growing AI problem on its storefront, and it's not only that game developers are using AI, which is a point of contention for many gamers but not necessarily the biggest concern for developers. Instead, game developers are increasingly reporting that their games are being cloned by developers using AI to clone games from short demos or PR materials ahead of the original game's launch. There has also been an outcry over the number of low-effort AI-generated or AI-assisted games bringing down the overall quality of Steam Next Fest. As reported by Inven, during a recent panel at the Steam Indie Connect developer event, Valve's Tom Giardino and Marc Wilkinson addressed some of these concerns by developers.
Tom Giardino via InvenWe don't want to be gatekeepers telling developers which tools they should or shouldn't use...Rather than relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to keep growing your game by adding features, personality, and creativity that stem from your own perspective
Giardino's, and seemingly Valve's, stance on AI game cloning is rather lax in the sense that it appears to mostly leave it up to developers to combat those clones by being more competitive. He explains that game clones have always existed, as has chasing trendy concepts and game mechanics during events like Next Fest, even if AI has made these issues more prevalent by making games easier to clone. He advised that developers take a two-pronged approach to dealing with those clones, first building a community and an identity for their game via an online presence, community engagement and building trust. The second step in combating game clones is for developers to continuously improve their games.

When asked about instances of extortion faced by developers, in which bad actors cloned a game and threatened the developer with releasing it before the original if money wasn't paid to the extortionist, Giardino expressed concern, stating that this was the first time he had heard of such a case, but encouraged developers to report those cases to Valve.
If you report such cases to us, we want to look into them further and help in whatever way we can.
When directly asked about low-quality games flooding Steam Next Fest, which can result in games getting lost in the noise, Marc Wilkinson explained that recommendation system for Next Fest is based on randomized visibility for the first two days, with the following days being based on personalized recommendations. He goes on to explain that the random exposure was put in place in order to ensure fairness and avoid larger developers taking advantage of the recommendation system. That said, he also acknowledged that Valve is working on addressing Steam's game visibility issue, but that it's challenging, because each studio has a different standard for success; where a small indie developer might be over the moon about 10,000 new wishlists during Next Fest, 10× that amount might still fall short for someone like EA or Ubisoft.
We recognize that the trade-off is some low-quality games get exposed. We are fully aware of the situation, and a significant number of people are thinking about how to solve this problem.
Source: Inven Global
Add your own comment

26 Comments on Valve Won't "Be Gatekeepers" by Banning AI Games, As "AI Slop" Complaints Grow

#1
ZoneDymo
of course thhey dont want that, that cost time AND money.
Look at how they are just allowing everything on there platform these days, tis a complete mess.

Its one of hte reasons why I so heavily dislike this favourable position Valve gets from PC gamers, like they are angels.....
Boss bought an insane yacht and the place that builds said yachts but no no no, you are treated fairly as consumers im sure.....
Posted on Reply
#2
TheinsanegamerN
ZoneDymoof course thhey dont want that, that cost time AND money.
Look at how they are just allowing everything on there platform these days, tis a complete mess.

Its one of hte reasons why I so heavily dislike this favourable position Valve gets from PC gamers, like they are angels.....
Boss bought an insane yacht and the place that builds said yachts but no no no, you are treated fairly as consumers im sure.....
Why are you upset they wont ban games that use AI? What is the real world difference between using AI to make your game and typing your code out on a Windows computer?

AI is a tool, that is quite useful for development. Valve gets a good reputation because they treat their customers well. Not banning a dev tool doesnt change that.
Posted on Reply
#3
aktpu
Valve doesn't care quality or originality, gaben just wants another yacht. News at eleven
Posted on Reply
#4
thestryker6
Hopefully nobody expects Valve to do anything curation or moderation wise. They've been no different than any other money above all company since forever. In this case they know most game buyers won't care and most developers don't have any alternative to Steam. Slop clones won't have any effect on the games where most of their revenue comes from which is all that really matters.
Posted on Reply
#5
Isaak
Oh no, there's low effort slop games... yeah? There always have been though? Just ignore them. Why are you crying to daddy gaben about it?
Posted on Reply
#6
Hecate91
There is a difference between AI being a developer tool, and developers being encouraged to AI slop code their games like what Epic is doing.
Valve allows tons of awful games on the platform, allowing AI slop isn't any different, but what puts them above the competition is allowing reviews and discussions so you have a way of knowing before you buy a game.
Posted on Reply
#7
Fatloader
TheinsanegamerNWhy are you upset they wont ban games that use AI? What is the real world difference between using AI to make your game and typing your code out on a Windows computer?

AI is a tool, that is quite useful for development. Valve gets a good reputation because they treat their customers well. Not banning a dev tool doesnt change that.
The difference is that one is made by a lazy basement dwelling cave monster and the other is made by someone willing to put time, effort, and love into a great game. AI can be used to push out a finished game faster or assist an overburdened game dev, but in reality people just use it to lay off good employees or to automate their source of income.

Also don't forget that programming is a job too and both them and artists are loosing jobs over this.
Posted on Reply
#8
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
TheinsanegamerNWhy are you upset they wont ban games that use AI? What is the real world difference between using AI to make your game and typing your code out on a Windows computer?

AI is a tool, that is quite useful for development. Valve gets a good reputation because they treat their customers well. Not banning a dev tool doesnt change that.
I think there's a disconnect between AI the coding tool professionals use and AI the slopfactory that produces shit no sane human would ever associate with/AI the thing rich people are trying to sell as literally civilization threatening. One of those is what AI/LLMs is actually good for, and the other is a way for the obscenely rich to get even richer at the expanse of literally everyone. Personally I think the reaction is well deserved. Someone somewhere made the point that even if AI have good use cases, and it does, it's not worth it.
Posted on Reply
#9
DeathtoGnomes
I am on the fence about AI in gaming, if it produces a terrible game, its a terrible game. I used to read a lot of books so currently I am on a visual novel kick and some scenes are AI but that doesnt deter from it having a immersive story.
Posted on Reply
#10
stablecoin50
Of course they will, just like Steam, all it takes is a feminist mob to find something they dislike and they will remove it
Posted on Reply
#11
aktpu
stablecoin50Of course they will, just like Steam, all it takes is a feminist mob to find something they dislike and they will remove it
Like what?
Posted on Reply
#12
vlad.coolish
1. Don’t consider generative LLMs to be AI :cool:
2. The main problem is that Steam has been flooded with low-quality games (I think everyone remembers the wave of banana clickers). And clones. For example, Vampire Survivors and Balatro, as soon as these games became popular, dozens of low-quality clones started popping up literally within a month.
3. Generative LLMs make the Scheiße-creation even faster. As a result = the ratio of games to crap has shifted from 1:10 to 1:100.
4. Because of this, I’ve stopped buying any games on Steam released after 2024 (except for a couple of well-known franchises) :rolleyes:
Posted on Reply
#13
FierceRed
stablecoin50Of course they will, just like Steam, all it takes is a feminist mob to find something they dislike and they will remove it
aktpuLike what?
History lesson time boys! Gather round, gather round.

What @stablecoin50 is talking about @aktpu is the incident in 2025 when an Australian advocacy group called Collective Shout - after achieving a victory with 1 game - lobbied to have several other sexually themed adult video games banned from being sold. You can read the TPU forum coverage on it here.

Now, usually such an effort doesn't get even a footnote in history due to freedom of speech yadda yadda, but what made this incident eyebrow raising was the group targeted payment processors who then - allegedly out of fear of mob scrutiny and repercussion - enforced penalties on digital storefronts as a proxy of the advocacy group to the point the digital storefronts stopped selling the games.

In other words, no legal cases were fought and lost, nor moral arguments conducted and won. Just a small lobbying group on a crusade with their finger on the pulse of the cultural zeitgeist, bullying an agent far more powerful than themselves to then bully on their behalf against also large and powerful storefronts to achieve the tiny lobby's goals. Freedom of speech ignored... allegedly.

(Before other TPU denizens jump on my dick, my views on this incident are and remain private. I write the above to colourfully commentate on a point in history, not to change anyone's mind nor reopen a debate. So stop typing Jacob. I see you.)

Given that there are alternative ways to get and support those games, that the lobby's tactic worked was the eyebrow raising part. It made such a dent that GOG and adult game developers got together and gave away the FreedomToBuy bundle for free in protest and to spread the philosophical message and legal stance of the other side.

Store guidelines changed, sandbags were filled and stacked, and nothing of note has happened since. Ever since that canary died however, communities have been sharpening their torches and dipping their pitchforks in tar in preparation for next time.

Now back to the News item.
Tom Giardino via InvenWe don't want to be gatekeepers telling developers which tools they should or shouldn't use...Rather than relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to keep growing your game by adding features, personality, and creativity that stem from your own perspective
Another based winning take from based Valve.

IMHO AI is a tool. People who dislike it are A) talking about a form of it that is already obsolete and has been exceeded and B) cannot wave their magic Jedi hand and stop humanity from eating, sleeping, having sex nor innovating.

In general, people keep talking past each other without realizing it. They're not objecting to the wheel, they're objecting to the wheel being used by raiders to roll Cannon up to the village so cannonballs can be fired that will kill an innocent farm girl.

How a tool is used is not Valve's responsibility to police - within reason - and the bounds of that reason will be decided in a courtroom, not a boardroom.
Why people are so quick to abandon the Rule of Law to dive headfirst into Cyberpunk 2077 dystopia will never cease to amaze.
vlad.coolish2. The main problem is that Steam has been flooded with low-quality games (I think everyone remembers the wave of banana clickers). And clones. For example, Vampire Survivors and Balatro, as soon as these games became popular, dozens of low-quality clones started popping up literally within a month.
3. Generative LLMs make the Scheiße-creation even faster. As a result = the ratio of games to crap has shifted from 1:10 to 1:100.
4. Because of this, I’ve stopped buying any games on Steam released after 2024 (except for a couple of well-known franchises) :rolleyes:
2 and 3:
You mean the bad actor behaviour that will quickly fall to non-relevance in a Market and must be suffered by humanity to get to the other more positive side of any innovation?

People forget that Steam Greenlight faced some of the same harsh feedback about fake games and spam... and "solving" it lead to the very quality control and discoverability problems we tend with today.

That the ratios have increased is nothing new and will be, air quotes, "solved" in time.

4:
That is an unfortunate consequence for all of the developers who deserve your patronage, but you're free to withdraw it for any reason as you have chosen to do. I hope you'll change your mind about game purchases one day. I hear Onimusha is really good, and I look forward to supporting Kena Scars of Kosmora later.
Posted on Reply
#14
remixedcat
Frickcivilization threatening
AI is not civilization threatening. They are paying people to claim it's more powerful than it really is so they can have their multi-trillion dollar IPOs and look good to investors.

They want it regulated so they can be the ones writing the regs and they can kneecap the competition. That's all it is is market hype for profit. AI won't kill us.
Posted on Reply
#15
Athena
When directly asked about low-quality games flooding Steam Next Fest, which can result in games getting lost in the noise
while true, there are a lots of low-quality games out on steam way before the "hate anything made with AI" crowd got vocal

Steam is in business to sell things, and each submission, they get $, we don't want Steam being a nanny on what is good and what isn't, and what was made with the help of AI and how much help the dev had, it can get super complicated really quick

so, how do you solve games getting lost in Next Fest?
I don't think there is a good, way, you can have a review board of sorts, but, that gets difficult, each person could have their own agenda, and they may reject games they THINK was AI done, when it wasn't

if you go solely on peer review, then bots can "vote" for duds to game the system, so anything that Valve can do, there will be ways to counter what that was, and on and on it goes
Posted on Reply
#16
freeagent
remixedcatAI won't kill us.


What a relief :cool:
Posted on Reply
#17
remixedcat
freeagent

What a relief :cool:
AI itself won't. It's not sentient, it doesn't "know" anything. It's merely a tool and I wish people would start having a sane thought about it all. Y'all are falling into traps set by the execs themselves.

AI might suggest things but it's up to humans to ACT on it.
Posted on Reply
#18
freeagent
remixedcatAI itself won't. It's not sentient, it doesn't "know" anything. It's merely a tool and I wish people would start having a sane thought about it all. Y'all are falling into traps set by the execs themselves.
I just really like the Terminator series, and I use it whenever I can :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#19
Bigshrimp
I have to say that not taking a side, is actually taking a side. It's easier for them to be shameless than actually care about doing something about the issue with AI infecting everything.
remixedcatAI is not civilization threatening. They are paying people to claim it's more powerful than it really is so they can have their multi-trillion dollar IPOs and look good to investors.

They want it regulated so they can be the ones writing the regs and they can kneecap the competition. That's all it is is market hype for profit. AI won't kill us.
AI is killing us in a different way. The more dependent people become with AI, the more it will hallow out critical thinking, research, and intelligence. It's offloading people's decision making and how their cognitive ability functions. On those aforementioned points, I consider that civilization threatening, especially over time and how it's used.

Also, the data centers being built are for multi-purpose systems they are developing and plan to implement, like CBDCs, more surveillance, military applications, and so much more.
Posted on Reply
#20
remixedcat
Bigshrimpoffloading people's decision making
In moderation.... those that learn to handle to properly will be allright. Those that use it as a security blanket and let it take them over will crumble and die when they no longer have access to it. Those that learned to moderate will flourish.
Bigshrimplike CBDCs, more surveillance, military applications,
This is the part I do not like.
Posted on Reply
#21
ISSEnterprise
I think Valve just need to polish the steam refund policy. As consumer, be cautious about the new game without much reviews from the gaming media (Of course the media could be wrong). Also don't buy lots of games from the store like candies. If you purchased a new one, played it for a while and request refund if you believe it is unworthy for the money.
Posted on Reply
#22
BoxCutter
ZoneDymoof course thhey dont want that, that cost time AND money.
Look at how they are just allowing everything on there platform these days, tis a complete mess.

Its one of hte reasons why I so heavily dislike this favourable position Valve gets from PC gamers, like they are angels.....
Boss bought an insane yacht and the place that builds said yachts but no no no, you are treated fairly as consumers im sure.....
It's not even these days, it's like since 2014, Valve is the OG slop company it was just human made slop.
Posted on Reply
#23
Tess
"Really tough problems to solve!" (???)

I don't see hardly any problems at all.
  • We vote with our wallets - that is just how it works.
  • Extortion is illegal and prosecutable under current law.
  • Who decides what a "low quality" game is?
    I would have thought Vampire Slayer was ultra low quality but it became very popular and what's the one where you're a drug dealer with the kindergarten level graphics? I almost fell out of my chair laughing when I saw how bad that was but people loved it - to them it wasn't "low quality" at all.
  • Day-one or pre-release clones? OK, slight problem here. Maybe change how the originals are marketed and hyped (don't show so much)? Maybe valve could add a category or a tag... Prerelease Clone, Clone Caution, etc.
And, it's not like AAA studios are prevented from using AI themselves - for whatever reasons. Including what they've always done: steel popular game mechanics from other studios! etcetera.

Valve's choice to "not make a choice" is of course the right choice! Do you want to choose your overlord or just not have an overlord?
Posted on Reply
#24
bhumesh
I think the bigger issue here is not really whether a game uses AI, but how much effort and creativity actually go into making it. AI can be a useful tool for developers, just like any other software, but it shouldn't become an excuse to push out unfinished or low-quality games.

At the same time, banning every game that uses AI doesn't seem like the right solution either. There are developers who might use it for certain tasks while still putting a lot of work into the gameplay, design, and overall experience.

For me, the real concern is Steam's discoverability. When there are already so many games being released, finding something genuinely worth playing is becoming harder. If AI makes that problem worse, then Valve definitely needs to improve how games are reviewed, categorized, and recommended.

Ultimately, players should be able to judge a game based on its quality, not just whether AI was involved in making it.
Posted on Reply
#25
iosonolucaio
There's no easy way to ban ai-slop games, it's the same problem with android shovelware and Unity/UnrealEngine asset-flipped games. This has been a problem since the introduction (and then disbanding) of Steam Greenlight. Who decides what's a good or a bad game? I remember when shovelware was easily shown on the store page while Hollow Knight was still waiting approval.
PC Gaming Wiki has an AI level indicator for all games from 0 (almost no AI) to 5 (Full AI) - check here www.pcgamingwiki.com/wiki/PCGamingWiki:Editing_guide/AI_usage
Most people won't care about this, but for some that care about games made withou AI, a filter on the Store or the search bar would be useful.

I don't know if they're doing this, but they should at least have all games be scanned with antimalware software to ban cryptominers and other dangerous games that have been sold on the store.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 17th, 2026 13:51 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts