Sunday, August 25th 2019
Intel Says AMD Did a Great Job (with Ryzen 3000), But Intel CPUs are Still Better
It is no secret that AMD has made a huge success with its long awaited "Zen" CPUs and returned to PC market stronger than ever. Intel however has neglected AMD's presence and only recently admitted what an impact AMD made. At this year's Gamescon, Intel started a new campaign against AMD with a point that Intel's CPUs are still better performers with "real world benchmarks" backing that claim.
"A year ago when we introduced the i9 9900K," says Intel's Troy Severson, "it was dubbed the fastest gaming CPU in the world. And I can honestly say nothing's changed. It's still the fastest gaming CPU in the world. I think you've heard a lot of press from the competition recently, but when we go out and actually do the real-world testing, not the synthetic benchmarks, but doing real-world testing of how these games perform on our platform, we stack the 9900K against the Ryzen 9 3900X. They're running a 12-core part and we're running an eight-core," he adds. "I'll be very honest, very blunt, say, hey, they've done a great job closing the gap, but we still have the highest performing CPUs in the industry for gaming, and we're going to maintain that edge."Here Intel describes that AMD wins in synthetic workloads, while its CPUs win in a real world usage scenarios for applications like Microsoft Office, Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and more. While they claim to posses better overall productivity performance, Intel also claims few other trophies in areas like gaming, where Core i7-9700K "is on par or better" than AMD Ryzen 9 3900X across many games tested.In our own testing, we found the claim about gaming performance to be true where Intel's Core i7-9700K did perform better than Ryzen 9 3900X. However when it comes to overall performance results that also includes many other tasks besides gaming, like productivity and science, the case is not proven.
Sources:
PCGamesN, WCCFTech
"A year ago when we introduced the i9 9900K," says Intel's Troy Severson, "it was dubbed the fastest gaming CPU in the world. And I can honestly say nothing's changed. It's still the fastest gaming CPU in the world. I think you've heard a lot of press from the competition recently, but when we go out and actually do the real-world testing, not the synthetic benchmarks, but doing real-world testing of how these games perform on our platform, we stack the 9900K against the Ryzen 9 3900X. They're running a 12-core part and we're running an eight-core," he adds. "I'll be very honest, very blunt, say, hey, they've done a great job closing the gap, but we still have the highest performing CPUs in the industry for gaming, and we're going to maintain that edge."Here Intel describes that AMD wins in synthetic workloads, while its CPUs win in a real world usage scenarios for applications like Microsoft Office, Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and more. While they claim to posses better overall productivity performance, Intel also claims few other trophies in areas like gaming, where Core i7-9700K "is on par or better" than AMD Ryzen 9 3900X across many games tested.In our own testing, we found the claim about gaming performance to be true where Intel's Core i7-9700K did perform better than Ryzen 9 3900X. However when it comes to overall performance results that also includes many other tasks besides gaming, like productivity and science, the case is not proven.






114 Comments on Intel Says AMD Did a Great Job (with Ryzen 3000), But Intel CPUs are Still Better
As before Intel will only drop price as a last resort.
Their 9700K and 9900K are at least 20-30% overpriced at the moment.
Problem is that AMD will not push Intel too hard on pricing at the moment because they also want to make good money.
What i hear from Sweden's biggest computer retailer is that AMD are about to make a big splash on Black Friday this year to own most of the cpu sales.
AMD will give Intel a hard time before X-MAS to screw with their 10000 series cpu release on CES.
The more customers AMD can take from Intel before X-MAS the harder it will be for Intel to gain momentum with their 10000 series cpu, it will be extra hard going in to low sale season Q1 2020 to pull of any major sales figures with their new 10000 series cpu series.
If Intel's sales are really bad before X-MAS it could lead to overstock of Intel 9000 series cpu's forcing Intel to push back 10000 Series to Q2 2020 to have time to clear 9000 series stock.
Been doing quite a lot of R&D on the lab TR platform. I must say although AMD is providing top notch hardware per dollar, their software support leaves a lot to be desired. It takes software and hardware support to make a good ecosystem.
This is just for professional use. I have yet to move to TR for gaming so I cannot say regarding the gaming part.
Well that may be changing soon, but to blame AMD for that is an interesting approach :)
Intel? - are we going to fault them for having the dominant position in the market?
Developers? - of course they are going to optimize for Intel over AMD. Again, this is where market share comes in.
Also he is taking about support directly from Intel and AMD not just developers. Intel has a much bigger support system for their clients than AMD does. I rember seeing posts on the interwebs when the first Epyc CPU's were launched talking about how major corporations were looking to buy AMD, but decided against it because AMD either didn't have the ability to or didn't want to let the customers get time with engineers and or architects.
To phrase it better: when specific programming error occurs that are not listed in AMD's technical whitebook, contacting AMD tech support is useless. As their support have 0 support for developers. Most of the time users are left to trail and error all by themselves.
So what do i want. Hmm 8 Intels cores or 12 AMD cores for the same price or how about 16 Intels cores for about twice as much money for what an 3950X will cost.
Thanks but no thanks intel. Intel might win in most games but not by that much and besides that AMD wins in almost every thing else. All from price to performance and raw power to power consuption. Just see with Intels comet lake with up to 125 watt for just base clock and amd 16 cores is just 105 watt with 6 core more.
I can easy live with losing 1-15 % gaming performance over to get twice the cores over I9 9900K for not so much more money and to half the price of I9 9960X. 3950X is really the best all around CPU for those that want a gaming CPU that still pack a punch in workstation and converting load. So 3950X is my CPU of choise. Intel can keep there 14 NM+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ or how many they are up to now:kookoo:
This one goes to intel: This Is So Sad Alexa Play Despacito
There is this thing called real life, in which absolute majority does not have the TOP product, but a more mainstream one. And there AMD wins and you lose. It is just that simple.
Go glue your 10nm together instead...
just a turbo thing? Why do you have to restart every timer before enabling\disabling it? Why cant it be done in windows?
sidenote ... when will they push a microcode patch to patch the patch they patched to disable OC on K CPU on Win10 ... because i am still waiting .... i set the OC to 4.4ghz but it never goes above 3.9ghz, well, at last it doesn't BSOD anymore because of that tho ...
"Intel Says AMD Did a Great Job (with Ryzen 3000), But Intel CPUs are Still Better...for gaming"