Sunday, August 25th 2019
Intel Says AMD Did a Great Job (with Ryzen 3000), But Intel CPUs are Still Better
It is no secret that AMD has made a huge success with its long awaited "Zen" CPUs and returned to PC market stronger than ever. Intel however has neglected AMD's presence and only recently admitted what an impact AMD made. At this year's Gamescon, Intel started a new campaign against AMD with a point that Intel's CPUs are still better performers with "real world benchmarks" backing that claim.
"A year ago when we introduced the i9 9900K," says Intel's Troy Severson, "it was dubbed the fastest gaming CPU in the world. And I can honestly say nothing's changed. It's still the fastest gaming CPU in the world. I think you've heard a lot of press from the competition recently, but when we go out and actually do the real-world testing, not the synthetic benchmarks, but doing real-world testing of how these games perform on our platform, we stack the 9900K against the Ryzen 9 3900X. They're running a 12-core part and we're running an eight-core," he adds. "I'll be very honest, very blunt, say, hey, they've done a great job closing the gap, but we still have the highest performing CPUs in the industry for gaming, and we're going to maintain that edge."Here Intel describes that AMD wins in synthetic workloads, while its CPUs win in a real world usage scenarios for applications like Microsoft Office, Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and more. While they claim to posses better overall productivity performance, Intel also claims few other trophies in areas like gaming, where Core i7-9700K "is on par or better" than AMD Ryzen 9 3900X across many games tested.In our own testing, we found the claim about gaming performance to be true where Intel's Core i7-9700K did perform better than Ryzen 9 3900X. However when it comes to overall performance results that also includes many other tasks besides gaming, like productivity and science, the case is not proven.
Sources:
PCGamesN, WCCFTech
"A year ago when we introduced the i9 9900K," says Intel's Troy Severson, "it was dubbed the fastest gaming CPU in the world. And I can honestly say nothing's changed. It's still the fastest gaming CPU in the world. I think you've heard a lot of press from the competition recently, but when we go out and actually do the real-world testing, not the synthetic benchmarks, but doing real-world testing of how these games perform on our platform, we stack the 9900K against the Ryzen 9 3900X. They're running a 12-core part and we're running an eight-core," he adds. "I'll be very honest, very blunt, say, hey, they've done a great job closing the gap, but we still have the highest performing CPUs in the industry for gaming, and we're going to maintain that edge."Here Intel describes that AMD wins in synthetic workloads, while its CPUs win in a real world usage scenarios for applications like Microsoft Office, Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and more. While they claim to posses better overall productivity performance, Intel also claims few other trophies in areas like gaming, where Core i7-9700K "is on par or better" than AMD Ryzen 9 3900X across many games tested.In our own testing, we found the claim about gaming performance to be true where Intel's Core i7-9700K did perform better than Ryzen 9 3900X. However when it comes to overall performance results that also includes many other tasks besides gaming, like productivity and science, the case is not proven.






114 Comments on Intel Says AMD Did a Great Job (with Ryzen 3000), But Intel CPUs are Still Better
The only thing Intel needs to do is STOP having a Temper-Tantrum.
Not the 1st one either lmao.
I still don't understand why they keep insisting single thread is important, how about build single core 6GHz base 7Ghz boost CPU to prove their point ?
And these "gaming CPU" again...*sigh.I know it's their marketing material,but i fell kinda misleading. People with average knowledge on a budget still think $400 CPU is all you need for gaming rather than $400 GPU.
I shouldn't scold them anymore, after all gaming is all they had left, after lost in data center, servers, desktop and (soon) high end desktop productivity, not to mention Snapdragon 8cx also knocking on their ULV portables :D
"
Funny they didn't mention Security anywhere except in the fine print in their graphics which states" Benchmarks may not have been run with all current available security patches."
I wonder if they still win benches with all updates installed? "
In terms of gaming, Sure Intel is fast and we all know why (it is not an IPC cause Ryzen 2 has better than Intel's) so it is game code execution. Ask yourself this question. Is 4k gaming a future or 720p/1080p 240Hz? For me 4k cause it looks awesome and I think games and most of people here will agree with me. This is the way technology advancement should pursuit. The other thing is, while Ryzen is slower on lower resolutions in one game, in 4k, with the same game it is faster than Intel counterpart is. Just drawing a bigger picture here and leave conclusions for you people.
The fact that intel struggles to make processors with more cores (in a price point affordable for most people) means, Intel's starting to lose ground and fast. 10nm Isn't working as it should (we don’t know if it ever will go to a desktop market), 5Ghz and up for CPUs is overrated, more cores are needed cause it has been proven that die shrinks won't bring boosts in frequency any more but degradation. AMD did it right with the core number because that is the only way you can boost performance. (Developers!! BUCKLY UP AND USE IT!!!) I can bet, 10 years from now (or even 5) AMD will be the top dog if this keeps up and Intel will be throwing shit on AMD saying, I'm a king of gaming, Real live benchmarks and crap like that. It would've been way more productive for Intel to swallow pride, buckle up and start with an idea how to make future products better and counter AMD or else Intel will perish with its pride and cheap schemes. For me this is pathetic and since Intel is playing this card, means they've got nothing to offer nor an idea even. The 10th gen CPUs proves it badly.
CPU's these days pretty much are equal, they do their task fast and if you need more you buy a bigger / faster model, simple as that. There could be some gains in selecting the memory and which NVME ssd, but both platform will show the same performance at some point.
Whoever brought up that the two (high res / high refresh) are to be mutually exclusive or that the pursuit of one, can, does, or should go at the expense of another needs to get his head examined. And you, too, if you really think this is the case. This has absolutely nothing to do with the 'Intel gaming lead' or 'code optimized for Intel'.
Precisely the better threaded engines for gaming are also capable of pushing higher FPS. This is not about Ryzen versus Core. Its about shifting away from the dependance on single threaded applications. Did AMD really push that forward? Or is it just the general trend that we're now finally ready for it? Its the latter; consoles & mobile devices carry a higher core count, we have better APIs available (API development also instigated by consoles btw), so you will see the same development in gaming on (performance) PCs. Its just that simple, its about the common denominator. In the same vein, now that higher counts than quad are getting mainstream and consoles already had 6+ cores available, we see those being used in our 'gaming' CPUs.
Now think back, despite quad cores being the norm for a decade on PC, prior to PS4, games simply did not scale beyond a single thread. And even if your OSD did say they used more, you didn't gain much FPS from it.
Intel did what it did because there was no market to grab. Besides, their HEDT segment already offered six cores for ages, but nobody jumped on those either. There was never a demand, another writing on the wall was AMD's bulldozer exactly; '8' core CPUs with no workload to shine at, while being pretty bad at the workloads most people did use. AMD stacked a few royal failures in that regard which put them on the bench for a long time.
Your idea that 'pursuit of technology' is in ANY way going towards gaming wrt to the Zen architecture... jesus man. These are datacenter/server CPUs first and foremost, the rest is bonus. And again, the same goes for Intel. They can yell about their gaming dominance but that was also just given to them because they dominated the market for a while, and they had their sweet time to fine tune things for the MSDT segment - much like you see with Ryzen 3000 right now (and lo and behold, the gap is shrinking fast for 'consumer workloads'...).
Let's not overinflate things, before it reads like another Intel press release.
Please stop comparing 3 different markets and lets focus on PC please. Mobile and console are a different story here. Two bad you've missed that.Intel did what it did because it was convenient not because there was no market for it. First you need to have something to play with and then you can improve upon it. You get 2 core and you focus development on this. Intel was never pushing cores but frequency and developers were following that trend. Just now, 2 years back the trend has changed. Not frequency but cores matter and developers are, just now, starting to use this resources. First resources you can build upon, then software and developers support not all the way around. Sure it did offer 6c but for what price? Developers see the market trend and it wasn't desktop 6c/12t for everyone but high-end overpriced product for exclusive users and you are saying developers would focus on that niche product to develop their own software for this? AMD bulldozer was 8c but it lacked performance. I knew you'd bring that one up but this is nowhere near where Intel was back then and no game developer would use more cores and threads utilization for a product that doesn't have the performance.Where the hell did I say that pursuit of technology is going towards gaming and zen arch?This is related to the 4k gaming which in my eyes is the way to go (because it does look great and detail level is outstanding) instead focusing on 720p with 500FPS and that also is important to this particular thread when Intel brags about performance of their CPUs compared to AMD. True but I dont care about that cause for me this is not the way to go. That's mine opinion and stop twisting what I said cause it really sucks.Then don't. Just simply disagree and move on. You dont have to read it but maybe others would
www.techpowerup.com/review/nvidia-geforce-rtx-2080-ti-founders-edition/
Thanks for pointing this out but I was using the 4k gaming for different purpose than attacking 2080Ti's performance.
No I don't think the 2080 Ti will continue to fare so well in future games but then there's probably a 7nm 3080 Ti next year that will.
As I always say, 4K gaming is for the people willing to pay for it and there are very few of them from what I've seen. 4K at extremely high FPS are probably very, very few but it can be done if you're willing to pay for it.
Anyway that's not the point and this thread is for something else please guys, I don't want to argue about what res people prefer or if 2080 Ti can push 100 in games. That is not what I wanted to point out here.
For a decade we were stuck at 4c8t. And yet, games did not scale beyond 1 or 2 threads anyway. Found the reason behind that yet? Because that is proof that the movement to higher core counts for gaming is extremely late to the party, we've had quads for ages now and games are only recently truly catching up to that - and still many haven't.
Convenient / no market... aren't they the same? Its not convenient to make parts you don't sell.
You can be all up in arms about what I've said but its not strange and 'making my point', its an observation on what you think happened the last decade, and I think you're wearing the wrong glasses looking back. We need the hardware before we get the software that will fully use it, and then we also need 'the performance', after all if nobody asks for 200 FPS gaming, it won't be built. And the better threading of games on the CPU coincides NOT with Zen, but with the console releases.
The result of better threading then, is that we're no longer tied to single core processing power and thát in turn enables high refresh/FPS gaming. 4K is not even a player in the story here, you can run that on a potato CPU, what does it even do in a Zen topic one might ask... Its no secret that a CPU will do fine as long as its not the part bottlenecking you. There is no 'pursuit' to be had for CPUs to enable 4K gaming.
So, back to my final line in last post: let's not overinflate what happened here with Zen's release, because that is the gist of your story. As if AMD 'enabled' something for gamers. They didn't, and the higher core counts were coming regardless. They gave us back healthy competition and that's all it is.
Puget Systems gets the same scoring with Neatbench 5.
www.pugetsystems.com/labs/articles/First-Look-at-AMD-Ryzen-3rd-Gen-CPUs-for-Video-Editing-1522/#NeatVideoNeatBench5BenchmarkResults
Did a quick run on my desktop.
Though Synthetic benchmarks do have there place, so long as no CPU's are being favoured.Intel took design shortcuts to squeeze out more performance and got caught with all the security vulnerabilities.
Basically Intel's Security Vulnerabilities should be Front Page News and should be talked about as much as possible. The security patches disable features which people made purchasing decisions on. By patching there CPU's, they are False Advertising.