Friday, July 17th 2020

Windows 10 Scheduler Aware of "Lakefield" Hybrid Topologies, Benchmarked

A performance review of the Intel Core i5-L16G7 "Lakefield" Hybrid processor (powering a Samsung Galaxy S notebook) was recently published by Golem.de, which provides an in-depth look at Intel's ambitious new processor design that sets in motion the two new philosophies Intel will build its future processors on - packaging modularity provided by innovative new chip packaging technologies such as Foveros; and Hybrid processing, where there are two sets of CPU cores with vastly different microarchitectures and significantly different performance/Watt curves that let the processor respond to different kinds of workloads while keeping power-draw low. This concept was commercially proliferated first by Arm, with its big.LITTLE topology that took to the market around 2013. The "Lakefield" i5-L16G7 combines a high-performance "Sunny Cove" CPU core with four smaller "Tremont" cores, and Gen11 iGPU.

The Golem.de report reveals that Windows 10 thread scheduler is aware of the hybrid multi-core topology of "Lakefield," and that it is able to classify workloads at a very advanced level so the right kind of core is in use at any given time. The "Sunny Cove" core is called upon when interactive vast serial processing loads are in demand. This could even be something like launching applications, new tabs in a multi-process web-browser, or less-parallelized media encoding. The four "Tremont" cores keep the machine "cruising," handling much of the operational workload of an application, and is also better tuned to cope with highly parallelized workloads. This is similar to a hybrid automobile, where the combustion engine provides tractive effort from 0 kph, while the electric motor sustains a cruising speed.
The Core i5-L16G7 has a rated SDP (scenario driven power) rating of 7 W. The package PL1 value is 7 W, too. Intel also gave the chip a PL2 value of 9.5 W, and a Tau value of 28 seconds. Some notebook vendors, however, are expected to set PL1 at 5 W. Raising it to 7 W will only be possible through a UEFI firmware update. Throughout Golem's testing, they observed that the "Sunny Cove" core kicks in during interactive workloads that require burst performance from the CPU, with the core typically clocked at 2.50 GHz, occasionally hitting 2.90 GHz. The smaller "Tremont" cores are typically clocked at 1.90 GHz during workloads, and can boost up to 2.70 GHz.

Perhaps the biggest dividend of topology-awareness by Windows OS scheduler is with the core rotation policy. By default, the Windows scheduler spreads a single-threaded workload across multiple cores (in sequence). AMD had to work with Microsoft to make Windows aware of the topology of its multi-CCX Ryzen processors, so workloads aren't spread between two CCX's if they don't have to. Similarly with "Lakefield," core rotation is localized to the "Tremont" cores.

Golem outlined the performance equation between the single "Sunny Cove" core and the four "Tremont" cores. A single "Sunny Cove" core has anywhere between 25-65% higher performance than a single "Tremont" core. On the other hand, the entire block of 4 "Tremont" cores offer 2x the performance of a single "Sunny Cove" core. This lends the two core blocks very different performance and power characteristics.
The Core i5-L16G7 tests consistently ahead of the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8xC 8-core (4 big+4LITTLE) processor that has the same 7 W TDP. Golem tested the processor across 25 tests, comparing it with i7-1065G7 ICL-U 15 W, an i5-10210U "Comet Lake-U" 15 W processor, and a Pentium Silver N5000 SoC that has just "Tremont" cores. Raising the power limits appears to increase performance of the i5-L16G7 by anywhere between 40-60%.
Much of what Intel learns from "Lakefield" will be implemented in future client-segment architectures such as "Meteor Lake," which will combine larger hybrid CPU core arrays to achieve high core counts. The i5-L16G7 allows notebook designers to make ultra portable devices with the power envelope of Snapdragon, but with the benefits of x86.

Find more benchmark results and commentary in the source link below.
Source: Golem.de
Add your own comment

35 Comments on Windows 10 Scheduler Aware of "Lakefield" Hybrid Topologies, Benchmarked

#26
londiste
InVasManiI've long felt a bigLITTLE approach will yield some of the easiest general improvements which could then be scaled and and intermixed a bit to suit certain consumers requirements. I still really feel FPGA's could be the best all around solution outside of combining a variety of ASIC's to really specifically maximize and prioritize a handful of the individuals use cases.
FPGA and ASIC have a different purpose. FPGA compared to ASIC is power inefficient, has lower clocks and cannot do some things (like analog circuitry). It is good for prototyping and low-volume production or very specific use cases. For most normal users, both desktop as well as enterprise, mass-manufactured ASICs are a better way to go.
Chrispy_AMD's offical cTDP values for a 4800U are 10-25W, and those official figures guarantee the 1.8GHz base clock assuming adequate cooling is provided. If your 4800U doesn't achieve 1.8GHz at 10W, RMA it because it's out of spec, ergo faulty.
This is incorrect. Official spec clearly states 1.8GHz and 15W. cTDP will affect clock speeds and 1.8GHz is absolutely not guaranteed at 10W.
Posted on Reply
#27
watzupken
AssimilatorFinally, tests that are actually useful because they're against a competitor part designed for the same low-power scenario!

And the results are very impressive considering this is a first-gen attempt. At only ~71% of the 8CX's power (5W vs 7W) Lakefield is faster in all non-synthetic benchmarks, despite having a 3-core deficit.

In short, Windows-on-ARM just died, along with Qualcomm's ambitions for ultra-portables in the x86 space. Conversely, Microsoft now has a reason to try their hand at Windows Phone again.

This is the most exciting and most important thing to happen in the CPU industry since Ryzen.
Success or not, it depends on how fast Intel is running/ improving this. I feel it should not come as a surprise that Intel chips are faster when running Windows OS and apps, which is almost like a home ground for Intel chips anyway. However, ARM improves on their SOCs year on year, and we can already see how close they are to closing in on Intel. So I would feel it is premature to say that Windows on ARM just died.

I feel people buying a laptop with an ARM or Lakefield processor is unlikely to consider performance as a priority. Between the 2, the performance delta is not ground breaking for most users to experience during light usage, which is likely going to be the use case for this class of laptop. Rather, battery life is the main consideration which ARM based SOCs still hold an advantage.

In my opinion, another Windows phone (even if viable from a hardware standpoint) may be too late at this stage since the market is already very saturated.
Posted on Reply
#28
Chrispy_
londisteThis is incorrect. Official spec clearly states 1.8GHz and 15W. cTDP will affect clock speeds and 1.8GHz is absolutely not guaranteed at 10W.
Rather than argue and speculate, here's a 10W 4700U exceeding its base clock and actually boosting to 2GHz on a 10W limit.
I cannot find a 4800U review yet, but on the assumption that is better-binned silicon it should be better, not worse.

As more anecdotal evidence, my ancient 1st-gen 2700U boosts above its base clock by around 150MHz even when configured down to its minimum 12W cTDP.
Posted on Reply
#29
londiste
Cool if that is the case.
Still does not change my point about spec.
Posted on Reply
#30
Chrispy_
londisteCool if that is the case.
Still does not change my point about spec.
Until I get my hands on one, I can't be sure, but based on my experience with 2000U and 3000U series, the 1.8GHz base clock may actually be the minimum P-state - as in the CPU cannot even run slower than that because the next state is "core parked".

If 1.8GHz is minimum P-state, the only time you'll see lower clocks than that is when you aren't running an all-core load and the CPU is shifting the threads around the cores to distribute heat better. The lower clocks you see will be an average between the active minimum P-state clock, and zero for a parked core. For example, in AMD uProf I can see clocks 300MHz lower on all 8 logical cores than the minimum when running just three threads, but if I change to an all-core load the clock rises to at least the base clock.

To the best of my knowledge, Renoir will follow the same rules as 1st Gen Ryzen, and if you read the cTDP whitepapers you'll see that the reason 1st-Gen's cTDP only goes down to 12W is because at this point it cannot maintain 8 active threads. I have the ability to set it lower using RyzenAdj but that just means it's going to throttle so hard it will be forced to park cores. In the context of this article discussing Lakefield's hybrid topologies, it almost doesn't matter what clockspeed the lowest active P-state is, so long as all cores are active at the stated cTDP. The whole argument is nearly a moot point anyway, because Intel's definition of TDP is very different to AMD's definition of TDP and there's no shortage of mainstream Youtubers independently demonstrating that Intel's TDP figures are even further away from real-world power consumption values than AMD's (which are quite clearly restricted and controllable via most BIOS options and/or Ryzen Master).
Posted on Reply
#31
slehmann
yeeeemanI really do miss old times when review outlets were less biased and fanboyism was not even in discussion. I remember AT articles written by Anand, that were just as detailed for a via shitty CPU or the best Intel or AMD cpu.
Nowadays, people are full of hate. If Intel has had a rough time now, everyone is wishing their death. If Intel then comes and tries to create an interesting product everyone say it is shit and boring. If AMD would have come out with something similar, everyone would be praising it for how good it is. Dear people, remove the hate/love and try to see objectively what each company is doing. AMD has good products, I agree. But AMD also has bad products, very bad actually. Likewise for Intel, for Nvidia, etc. So lets learn to judge each situation separately and not introduce the same stupid hate on each product launch.
This product is a very interesting piece of design, silicon, power delivery, uArch, software, firmware, etc. It has some specific constraints that require a lot of effort, for example the very small package, like ARM SoCs. Stop being so ignorant and try to read every single piece of news with a clear mind. Intel will still launch great products in the future, don't get bogged into this 14nm+++++ hate. They didn't want to push it for so long, but making mistakes in the fab business is very costly and as we saw a multi year affair to fix. We should appreciate what AMD has done, but stop being so polarized and appreciate also what the competition does, because it might just be a good product.

Yeah, another big difference is that they are in two different leagues altogheter in terms of package sizes, power requirements, PCB minimum size, etc. Intel also can drop their i7 15W CPUs to 4.5W (which they actually do for a very long time), but Lakefield is not about beating bechmarks, it is about packaging, big-little in x86 space, die stacking, etc.
I totally agree with the "no hate" viewpoint here. We should praise competition and enjoy every great product no matter which company launches it.
But i think Intel deserves at least some of the current backlash cause of the way they treated security in their latest iterations of CPUs (Meltdown, ... the ME flaws ...).
Some people risk everything (want to be a journalist in China/Turkey/North Korea/Poland/Hungary ... at the moment?) for publishing truth and should be able to rely on their tech.
Posted on Reply
#32
Crackong
yeeeemanSame price as the ARM version.
That doesn't mean it isn't i7 prices
They are both expensive.
Posted on Reply
#35
londiste
RCP is normally useless in a way that OEM gets a much better deal :)
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 19th, 2026 19:06 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts