Thursday, August 7th 2025

Intel to Drop 16x MSAA with Xe3 "Celestial," Says XeSS and TAA Make Legacy AA Methods Obsolete

Intel has signalled that it will drop support for 16x MSAA with its upcoming Xe3 "Celestial" graphics architecture. The architecture will support MSAA, but at 2x, 4x, and 8x. MSAA x16 support will be reserved for certain models of Xe3 GPUs, presumably the higher end discrete GPUs, however the lower-end chips and iGPU solutions are set to lose it. Intel Graphics engineer Kenneth Grauke made a commit to Intel's Iris Gallium3D and ANV Vulkan driver, and announced in his note: "16x MSAA isn't supported at all on certain Xe3 variants, and on its way out on the rest. Most vendors choose not to support it, and many apps offer more modern multisampling and upscaling techniques these days. Only 2/4/8x are supported going forward."

Intel's rationale behind retiring MSAA checks out, as nearly every modern game supports TAA, and most games support at least one upscaling technology, such as DLSS, FSR, or Intel's own XeSS. Intel has a growing collection of games that have implemented XeSS and the newer XeSS 2 technology, which features an AI ML-based upscaling model. Upscaler super-sampling methods tend to do a good job at antialiasing, with whatever minimal performance cost made up for with upscaling. Even native-resolution modes, such as DLAA see negligible performance costs compared to MSAA. GPU manufacturers would still want to retain MSAA for its utility in older gaming titles and 3D productivity apps.
Sources: Phoronix, VideoCardz
Add your own comment

61 Comments on Intel to Drop 16x MSAA with Xe3 "Celestial," Says XeSS and TAA Make Legacy AA Methods Obsolete

#26
Onasi
EasoI think I have seen it literally once over 20+ years (mom, does that mean I am old??).
You could technically force it via whatever your vendor of choice GPU control panel, but yeah, almost no games provided it out of the box as an option since the improvements visually compared to 8x are negligible at a higher performance cost (to the point where you might as well just use supersampling).
Posted on Reply
#27
_roman_
i think we should leave sexual preferences out of a graphic card topic PLEASE. post of zonedymo
Posted on Reply
#28
TumbleGeorge
Event HorizonDid you read the body of the OP?
Yes, just your post last sentence which I commented sounds on my language like you lost any hope. Not sure that Intel will make so hard product positioning as written in this article. This is just rumor for me.
Posted on Reply
#29
Visible Noise
FeydTAA is useless crap and XeSS is almost as bad. Removing MSAA is wrong move. I wish games would go back to it or preferably to SSAA. Sadly direction they are going now is blurry mess and it's getting worse every year.
You know MSAA only works on triangle edges, and doesn’t work on transparency, right? Making it useless for shader based rendering.
Posted on Reply
#30
TheDeeGee
But how do i use DLSS in my early 2000 boxed copies then?
Posted on Reply
#31
Onasi
Visible NoiseYou know MSAA only works on triangle edges, and doesn’t work on transparency, right? Making it useless for shader based rendering.
You can SORT OF make it work on transparencies by rendering stuff like alphas with an offset and AAing it (that is what the Transparency setting for AA in NVCP does), but it’s really performance heavy and, from my understanding, works only under forward rendering. Which, contrary to popular belief, is still theoretically possible on modern engines - UE4 (and I assume 5, but don’t quote me on that) do have a forward rendering configuration as an option, though good luck finding any games running THAT. Realistically, it’s a DX9/10 era games setting.
Posted on Reply
#32
windwhirl
FeydRemoving MSAA is wrong move.
They're not removing MSAA. They're dropping only the 16x MSAA.

I haven't played every game on Earth, but I'm pretty sure is fairly rare for most games to offer beyond 4x or 8x.

Also, do not mistake with Anisotropic filtering, that is very commonly offered as an option going up to 16x in almost any game that has an AF setting.
Posted on Reply
#33
TheinsanegamerN
windwhirlThey're not removing MSAA. They're dropping only the 16x MSAA.

I haven't played every game on Earth, but I'm pretty sure is fairly rare for most games to offer beyond 4x or 8x.

Also, do not mistake with Anisotropic filtering, that is very commonly offered as an option going up to 16x in almost any game that has an AF setting.
Slippery Slopes are not fallacies, they are in fact very real. First its 16xmsaa, then its all MSAA, then its going to be DX9, or open GL.

Especially since Intel is not in a great financial spot right now.
Posted on Reply
#34
noel_fs
ive only used x16 msaa in one game in my whole life and its a really well performing and old game where i could just use it for fun
Posted on Reply
#36
AusWolf
TheinsanegamerNSlippery Slopes are not fallacies, they are in fact very real. First its 16xmsaa, then its all MSAA, then its going to be DX9, or open GL.

Especially since Intel is not in a great financial spot right now.
DirectX 9 is already unsupported by hardware since Alchemist, I think - it only works through a translation layer in the driver.
Posted on Reply
#37
ghazi
All this temporal post-processing crap is just that, crap. Playing older games that look sharp really shines a light on the blur. Trees in the distance look better in Crysis than Alan Wake 2. Seriously! We need real AA to make a comeback.
Posted on Reply
#38
qlum
TheinsanegamerNSlippery Slopes are not fallacies, they are in fact very real. First its 16xmsaa, then its all MSAA, then its going to be DX9, or open GL.

Especially since Intel is not in a great financial spot right now.
Actually for those intel arc does not natively support directx pre 11 and uses a translation layer the same can be done for opengl with zink, this is performant enough. dxvk on linux is really no worse than the native drivers so really not much of a loss there.

I am pretty sure AMD and Nvidia will drop native opengl and directx support at some point.
Posted on Reply
#39
Feyd
windwhirlThey're not removing MSAA. They're dropping only the 16x MSAA.

I haven't played every game on Earth, but I'm pretty sure is fairly rare for most games to offer beyond 4x or 8x.

Also, do not mistake with Anisotropic filtering, that is very commonly offered as an option going up to 16x in almost any game that has an AF setting.
Yes as the TheinsanegamerN said that's just a start. And no matter how rare some games do have it and replacing it with SSAA through DSR or something similar isn't always possible (not to mention not many or at all VGAs have power for something like 4x SSAA on 4k resolution).
Posted on Reply
#40
Vayra86
AusWolfDon't worry about not being able to tell characters apart in the blurry mess that's supposed to be your game - at least the shadow of the spoon on that table in the corner looks 1% better. :roll:
AMD: 'We'll just open source that shadow render and you'll get it soon (tm)'
Nvidia: 'Today we introduce Nvidia SpoonWorks, with x32 higher spoon shadow render performance, only on Nvidia RTX'

Intel: 'There is no spoon'
TheinsanegamerNSlippery Slopes are not fallacies, they are in fact very real. First its 16xmsaa, then its all MSAA, then its going to be DX9, or open GL.

Especially since Intel is not in a great financial spot right now.
Yeah I'm sure they'll start removing APIs next, I mean clearly MSAA x16 is the start of it all and tomorrow we'll get Skynet. :roll:
You're not far off though... they already are not natively supporting most legacy stuff on their GPUs since day one.
Posted on Reply
#41
wEeViLz
ZoneDymoThis is just a silly post, you even acknowledge how silly the first remark is yourself.
Its like people being against homosexual marriage because "whats next? a man marrying a chair?!!?!"
Why do you hate my chair?
Posted on Reply
#42
windwhirl
FeydYes as the TheinsanegamerN said that's just a start. And no matter how rare some games do have it and replacing it with SSAA through DSR or something similar isn't always possible (not to mention not many or at all VGAs have power for something like 4x SSAA on 4k resolution).
Nobody said anything about MSAA being dropped fully, you are just trying to start a FUD train.

Besides, it's not like MSAA doesn't have its issues and inadequacies. It's an old concept by now.

Regardless, I still feel there was little reason to care for x16 MSAA. Like, if you're doing x16 instead of just x8 or x4, you could probably drop down from x16 to a lower intensity option and instead crank up something else that would be more useful.
Posted on Reply
#43
dyonoctis
Dwardenall we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
3D Blur has always been fake, and monitor tech is also trying really hard to make screen-induced blur a thing of the past.
Posted on Reply
#44
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
AusWolfDirectX 9 is already unsupported by hardware since Alchemist, I think - it only works through a translation layer in the driver.
That was ONLY on Alchemist and meteor lake afaik. Not subsequent releases. Tap spoke about this in an interview iirc.
Posted on Reply
#45
Rightness_1
Will this not break compatibility with some games, especially older ones? Not sure if this is a move Intel should make when it has no market share and a need to grow the GPU division... But then Intel does seem to be in a death spiral and stupidly selling off parts it really shouldn't, but I think a lot of us saw this when they appointed a CEO with deep ties to China.

Also, as many have stated, this is worrying because it could well be the start of removing features that break older games in the future.

I would suspect that Intel might be doing this because they are well known for their incompetence in their software and driver teams, and this may well be to do with Intel trying to simplify development that their driver team struggles with, due to incompetence, poor hiring practices and bad management.
Posted on Reply
#46
Onasi
Rightness_1I would suspect that Intel might be doing this because they are well known for their incompetence in their software and driver teams, and this may well be to do with Intel trying to simplify development that their driver team struggles with, due to incompetence, poor hiring practices and bad management.
Their driver team for GPUs is not incompetent. The issues that Arc had stemmed from a very real-life issue - the majority of lead development on those drivers was done by Intel Russia and when the… geopolitical issues… hit the company had to spend time relocating and readjusting the team. It is what it is.
Posted on Reply
#47
Feyd
windwhirlNobody said anything about MSAA being dropped fully, you are just trying to start a FUD train.

Besides, it's not like MSAA doesn't have its issues and inadequacies. It's an old concept by now.

Regardless, I still feel there was little reason to care for x16 MSAA. Like, if you're doing x16 instead of just x8 or x4, you could probably drop down from x16 to a lower intensity option and instead crank up something else that would be more useful.
No but it always starts like this.

While MSAA isn't perfect it is miles ahead of any "modern" AA method since it doesn't blur whole image only edges. Only AA which is better from image quality point of view is SSAA which is even older than MSAA. So I don't see your point since no new tech compares to that from image quality point of view.

Games I play with 16x MSAA have nothing else to crank up so it's either that or nothing and not every game works with DSR so no other way around (yes I know about control panel AA options but that usually does nothing or breaks the game). Still I rather have image with jagged edges rather than blurry crap which is normal in games these days.
Posted on Reply
#48
soder
nagemeBest AA: Matrox Parhelia. :)
web.archive.org/web/20170221211150/https://www.anandtech.com/show/911/7

(AnandTech's main site / article archive now gone?!)
Yep, they shut it down last week, and redirects to the forum. All 30 yrs articles gone.
The entire site has been archived, but its in a convoluted difficult InternetArchive format. That no ordinary human being knows how to process and browse. Reddit datahoarder has some threads about futile attempts to use some of those semi-broken toolsets, but with very little progress.

For anyone interested, here is the whole siterip: archive.fart.website/archivebot/viewer/job/20240901213047bvqa8
its 70 GB, and no-one knows how to extract it to a browseable format :(
Posted on Reply
#49
windwhirl
soderThat no ordinary human being knows how to process and browse.
If you have the URL, you can just query the article in Internet Archive's Wayback Machine and read it like back then. But you need to have the old URL stored somewhere. That automatically means all people using Chrome and Chrome-variants won't have anything unless they visited the pages in the last few months, since Chrome just purges history that's beyond a certain amount of time and it's not configurable. Firefox users might have their URLs still stored if they didn't exceed the database limit or if they increased the database limit in their configuration page (which is my case).

Still, for most users, the more achievable thing to do is to just go to web.archive.org/web/*/anandtech.com/show* and use the filter on the right to try to find whichever article is needed. Though, it will only filter by whatever is in the URL, it won't search inside the pages, so some patience is definitely needed.
Posted on Reply
#50
Scrizz
lol all the Intel haters out here spreading all this FUD.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 22nd, 2026 07:17 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts