Thursday, August 7th 2025

Intel to Drop 16x MSAA with Xe3 "Celestial," Says XeSS and TAA Make Legacy AA Methods Obsolete

Intel has signalled that it will drop support for 16x MSAA with its upcoming Xe3 "Celestial" graphics architecture. The architecture will support MSAA, but at 2x, 4x, and 8x. MSAA x16 support will be reserved for certain models of Xe3 GPUs, presumably the higher end discrete GPUs, however the lower-end chips and iGPU solutions are set to lose it. Intel Graphics engineer Kenneth Grauke made a commit to Intel's Iris Gallium3D and ANV Vulkan driver, and announced in his note: "16x MSAA isn't supported at all on certain Xe3 variants, and on its way out on the rest. Most vendors choose not to support it, and many apps offer more modern multisampling and upscaling techniques these days. Only 2/4/8x are supported going forward."

Intel's rationale behind retiring MSAA checks out, as nearly every modern game supports TAA, and most games support at least one upscaling technology, such as DLSS, FSR, or Intel's own XeSS. Intel has a growing collection of games that have implemented XeSS and the newer XeSS 2 technology, which features an AI ML-based upscaling model. Upscaler super-sampling methods tend to do a good job at antialiasing, with whatever minimal performance cost made up for with upscaling. Even native-resolution modes, such as DLAA see negligible performance costs compared to MSAA. GPU manufacturers would still want to retain MSAA for its utility in older gaming titles and 3D productivity apps.
Sources: Phoronix, VideoCardz
Add your own comment

61 Comments on Intel to Drop 16x MSAA with Xe3 "Celestial," Says XeSS and TAA Make Legacy AA Methods Obsolete

#1
Onasi
Not an issue, there is no rational reason for using 16xMSAA on any modern resolution anyway and if you ABSOLUTELY want peak AA on some older game you might as well use many SSAA options out there.
Posted on Reply
#2
AusWolf
I didn't even know 16x MSAA existed. :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#3
Macro Device
Me, an internet schizophrenic: *dreams of 65536x antialiasing*

Intel: "We read your thoughts and while we don't necessarily agree with the number 65536, we will honour your idea. In our own way of course."
Posted on Reply
#4
Feyd
TAA is useless crap and XeSS is almost as bad. Removing MSAA is wrong move. I wish games would go back to it or preferably to SSAA. Sadly direction they are going now is blurry mess and it's getting worse every year.
Posted on Reply
#5
rv8000
What an article/post title :roll:

Never knew MSAA 16x was ever an option, but anyone claiming TAA is superior to anything needs to check themselves out.
Posted on Reply
#6
Space Lynx
Astronaut
never seen MSAA x16 supported in any game, don't even know wtf is going on with this article.
Posted on Reply
#7
PixelTech
Space Lynxnever seen MSAA x16 supported in any game, don't even know wtf is going on with this article.
I believe it was available in CS:GO.
Posted on Reply
#8
Dwarden
if this means no MSAA 2x, 4x, 8x too then this card is DOA (dead on arrival)
(yes i'm aware the news says they dropping just 16x MSAA but start with one end with all)

even by removing MSAA 16x it clearly shows that companies cease to innovate

generally it's funny that stuff like Anisotropic Filtering got stuck too instead of improving

i expected for example Elliptical Anisotropic Filtering on GPU to replace 16x AF
graphics.cs.aueb.gr/graphics/docs/papers/I3D11_EllipticalFiltering_draft.pdf

all we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
Posted on Reply
#9
AusWolf
Dwardenif this means no MSAA 2x, 4x, 8x too then this card is DOA (dead on arrival)
(yes i'm aware the news says they dropping just 16x MSAA but start with one end with all)

even by removing MSAA 16x it clearly shows that companies cease to innovate

generally it's funny that stuff like Anisotropic Filtering got stuck too instead of improving

i expected for example Elliptical Anisotropic Filtering on GPU to replace 16x AF
graphics.cs.aueb.gr/graphics/docs/papers/I3D11_EllipticalFiltering_draft.pdf

all we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
Don't worry about not being able to tell characters apart in the blurry mess that's supposed to be your game - at least the shadow of the spoon on that table in the corner looks 1% better. :roll:
Posted on Reply
#10
Panther_Seraphin
Dropping 16x MSAA isnt too bad but I hope it doesnt start the ball rolling down the hill that by say Exorcist/Erudite/Evoker they then start dropping 8x and 4x cause "reasons"
Posted on Reply
#11
Craptacular
Dwardenif this means no MSAA 2x, 4x, 8x too then this card is DOA (dead on arrival)
(yes i'm aware the news says they dropping just 16x MSAA but start with one end with all)

even by removing MSAA 16x it clearly shows that companies cease to innovate

generally it's funny that stuff like Anisotropic Filtering got stuck too instead of improving

i expected for example Elliptical Anisotropic Filtering on GPU to replace 16x AF
graphics.cs.aueb.gr/graphics/docs/papers/I3D11_EllipticalFiltering_draft.pdf

all we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
And fake MSRPs!
Posted on Reply
#12
ZoneDymo
Dwardenif this means no MSAA 2x, 4x, 8x too then this card is DOA (dead on arrival)
(yes i'm aware the news says they dropping just 16x MSAA but start with one end with all)

even by removing MSAA 16x it clearly shows that companies cease to innovate

generally it's funny that stuff like Anisotropic Filtering got stuck too instead of improving

i expected for example Elliptical Anisotropic Filtering on GPU to replace 16x AF
graphics.cs.aueb.gr/graphics/docs/papers/I3D11_EllipticalFiltering_draft.pdf

all we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
This is just a silly post, you even acknowledge how silly the first remark is yourself.
Its like people being against homosexual marriage because "whats next? a man marrying a chair?!!?!"

Everyone will stop supporting MSAA at some point, its an ancient tech, its crazy you specifically mention "Cease to innovate" when sticking to old tech is exactly that....
Posted on Reply
#13
rv8000
Panther_SeraphinDropping 16x MSAA isnt too bad but I hope it doesnt start the ball rolling down the hill that by say Exorcist/Erudite/Evoker they then start dropping 8x and 4x cause "reasons"
We’ve sort of already gone down this route though. The majority of new games get TAA, then if you’re lucky you get a second option in FXAA. Forcing MSAA or other methods typically dont work via driver/cp.

Good example is Helldivers 2, I painfully play with AA off as anything else in game significantly reduces visual quality.
Posted on Reply
#14
Space Lynx
Astronaut
ZoneDymoEveryone will stop supporting MSAA at some point, its an ancient tech, its crazy you specifically mention "Cease to innovate" when sticking to old tech is exactly that....
umm, some of us want to play older games from time to time...
Posted on Reply
#15
thepath
Does dropping 16x support reduce the die size and cost of the GPU ?? If it does not then there is no reason to remove it even if it useless for 99% of people.
Posted on Reply
#17
TumbleGeorge
Dwardenall we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
But for real money...for more real money. :(
Posted on Reply
#18
Testsubject01
Space Lynxumm, some of us want to play older games from time to time...
Not just that, lots of TAA and similar modern solutions are unfortunately not tuned well. Can't see aliasing, if the image is sufficiently blurry / grainy, right? :rolleyes:
While MSAA is old, it does deliver good results in a lot of use cases.
Posted on Reply
#19
QuietBob
Being very sensitive to aliasing, I am a huge fan of MSAA. For me it's a mandatory feature in everything I play, because I can see those jaggies even in 4K.

As a big fan of old/er games, I'm lucky that most of them support this technique to make up for the lower poly count and less complex level design. If a particular title doesn't support MSAA natively, it can usually be forced in the driver for those classic games. And it often produces better results than the in-game implementation. This is how I typically game -- 8xEQ is equivalent to 16x:



I know that modern game engines have forgone MSAA, but I don't play contemporary AAA titles.
Posted on Reply
#20
Event Horizon
In other words, nothing is going to change in any noticeable way. Those low end iGPUs weren't going to be powerful enough for x16 anyway. If they get rid of x4 MSAA on discrete GPUs then I'll have a problem with it.
Posted on Reply
#21
jackbluray
Dwardenif this means no MSAA 2x, 4x, 8x too then this card is DOA (dead on arrival)
(yes i'm aware the news says they dropping just 16x MSAA but start with one end with all)

even by removing MSAA 16x it clearly shows that companies cease to innovate

generally it's funny that stuff like Anisotropic Filtering got stuck too instead of improving

i expected for example Elliptical Anisotropic Filtering on GPU to replace 16x AF
graphics.cs.aueb.gr/graphics/docs/papers/I3D11_EllipticalFiltering_draft.pdf

all we getting those days is fake frames, fake AA, fake blur, fake something else
and fake 3d because 3d games are displayed on 2d display. All is fake in 3d game rendering. Rasterisation use fake solution to display most of elements like reflection and shadow. etc
Posted on Reply
#22
TumbleGeorge
Event HorizonThose low end iGPUs
What! If Intel don't stop making discrete graphics, Celestial will be used not only in iGPUs.
Posted on Reply
#23
Event Horizon
TumbleGeorgeWhat! If Intel don't stop making discrete graphics, Celestial will be used not only in iGPUs.
Did you read the body of the OP? They're maintaining x16 MSAA support on the higher end discrete GPUs.
MSAA x16 support will be reserved for certain models of Xe3 GPUs, presumably the higher end discrete GPUs
Posted on Reply
#24
AusWolf
ZoneDymoThis is just a silly post, you even acknowledge how silly the first remark is yourself.
Its like people being against homosexual marriage because "whats next? a man marrying a chair?!!?!"

Everyone will stop supporting MSAA at some point, its an ancient tech, its crazy you specifically mention "Cease to innovate" when sticking to old tech is exactly that....
Old tech that is
1. A lot better than new tech, and
2. Is supported by old games, most of which are just as good, or even better than new games.

Old doesn't always mean worse, quite the contrary these days.
Posted on Reply
#25
Easo
I think I have seen it literally once over 20+ years (mom, does that mean I am old??).
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 22nd, 2026 07:05 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts