Wednesday, March 11th 2026

Valve Issues Scathing Public Response to New York Attorney General's Loot Box Lawsuit

The New York state attorney general, Letitia James, recently announced that she was taking Valve to court over what she called "quintessential gambling" via loot boxes in games like Counter-Strike, Team Fortress, and Dota, stating that these loot boxes target children and adolescents, and that they put children at risk of becoming addicted to gambling when they reach adulthood. On March 11, Valve published a response to this lawsuit in a dedicated Steam Support page, stating that it does not believe the mystery boxes violate any New York state laws, defending its loot box economy by likening it to real-world blind boxes, and criticizing the attorney general for taking Valve to court while turning a blind eye to the aforementioned real-world examples.

Valve says that it had previously met with the attorney general and explained that these mystery box systems are widely used "not just in video games but in the tangible world as well," likening loot boxes to real-world products like baseball cards, Magic: The Gathering cards, Pokémon cards, and even Labubus. Valve adds that "players don't have to open mystery boxes to play Valve games," and it insists that most gamers never do. According to the gaming giant, it has been cooperating with the NY attorney general's investigation and has shut down a number of accounts found to be using loot box cosmetics on gambling sites, citing that it has closed over a million accounts for this reason. Building on its example of baseball cards, Valve criticizes the NY attorney general taking issue with the fact that the in-game items are tradable and transferrable, suggesting that if trading physical goods, like baseball cards, isn't prohibited, neither should trading in-game cosmetics be.
Apparently Valve was offered the opportunity to make a deal, but it felt as though the "type of commitments the NYAG demanded from Valve went far beyond what existing New York law requires and even beyond New York itself," adding that "it may have been easier and cheaper for Valve to make a deal with the NYAG, but we believed the type of deal that would satisfy the NYAG would have been bad for users and other game developers, and impacted our ability to innovate in game design." Valve goes on to clarify that it will comply with whatever laws are passed in New York regarding loot boxes, but mentions that none have yet been passed, despite the issue having been raised before. It also takes issue with some of the anti-gaming rhetoric and comments made by the attorney general, calling them "a mischaracterization we've all heard before," and mentioning that studies have proven that there is no link between media and real-world violence.

Valve's full statement reads as follows:
Dear New York customers of Counter-Strike 2, Dota 2, and Team Fortress 2:

You may have seen the New York Attorney General recently filed a lawsuit against Valve claiming mystery boxes (like crates, cases, and chests) in some of our games violate New York gambling laws. We don't believe that they do, and were disappointed to see the NYAG make that claim after working to educate them about our virtual items and mystery boxes since they first reached out to us in early 2023. We rarely talk about litigation, but we felt we should explain the situation to you.

We shared with the NYAG that these types of boxes in our games are widely used, not just in video games but in the tangible world as well, where generations have grown up opening baseball card packs and blind boxes and bags, and then trading and selling the items they receive. On the physical side, popular products used in this way include baseball cards, Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, and Labubu. In the game space, digital packs similar to our boxes date back to 2004 and are in widespread use. Players don't have to open mystery boxes to play Valve games. In fact, most of you don't open any boxes at all and just play the games—because the items in the boxes are purely cosmetic, there is no disadvantage to a player not spending money.

In the process of cooperating with the NYAG's investigation, we shared with them our efforts over many years to shut down accounts found to be using Valve game items on gambling sites in violation of the Steam Subscriber Agreement. We also shared with them our efforts to combat fraud and theft of users' items and our extraordinary measures to stop gambling sites from taking advantage of Steam accounts and Valve game items. Valve does not cooperate with gambling sites. To date we've locked over one million Steam accounts that were being misused by third parties in connection with gambling, fraud, and theft. We've also shipped features (like trade reversal and trade cooldown) to discourage gambling sites' ability to operate and protect Steam users from fraud. And we forbid any gambling-related business to participate in or sponsor tournaments for our games.

We have serious concerns with many of the alterations the NYAG claims are necessary to make to our games. First, the NYAG seems to believe boxes and their contents should not be transferable. They appear to assume digital mystery boxes and items in our games are different from tangible items like baseball card packs (which contain random cards), and to take issue with the fact that users have the ability to transfer the items they receive through Steam Trading or user-to-user sales on the Community Market. We think the transferability of a digital game item is good for consumers—it gives a user the ability to sell or trade an old or unwanted item for something else, in the same way an owner can sell or trade a tangible item like a Pokemon or baseball card. NYAG proposes to take away users' ability to transfer their digital items from Valve games. Transferability is a right we believe should not be taken away, and we refuse to do that.

The NYAG also proposed to gather additional information (beyond what we normally collect in the course of processing payments) about each game user on the off-chance someone in New York was anonymizing their location to appear outside of New York, such as by using a VPN. This would have involved implementing invasive technologies for every user worldwide. Similarly, the NYAG demanded that Valve collect more personal data about our users to do additional age verification—even though most payment methods used by New York Steam users already have age verification built-in. Valve knows our users care about the security of their personal information, and we believe it's in our and their interest to only collect the information necessary to operate the business and comply with law.

We respect New York's right to determine the laws governing behavior in the state. We will of course comply if the New York legislature passes laws governing mystery boxes—something it has not done despite considering the issue a few times. Such laws would be the result of a public process, presumably with input from the industry and New York gamers. The type of commitments the NYAG demanded from Valve went far beyond what existing New York law requires and even beyond New York itself. It may have been easier and cheaper for Valve to make a deal with the NYAG, but we believed the type of deal that would satisfy the NYAG would have been bad for users and other game developers, and impacted our ability to innovate in game design.

In addition, although this case is about mystery boxes, we feel the need to address comments made by the NYAG about games, real world violence, and children. Those extraneous comments are a distraction and a mischaracterization we've all heard before. Numerous studies throughout the years have concluded there is no link between media (movies, TV, books, comics, music, and games) and real world violence. Indeed, many studies highlight the beneficial impact of games to users.

Ultimately, a court will decide whose position—ours or NYAG's—is correct. In the meantime, we wanted to make sure you were aware of the potential impact to users in New York and elsewhere.
Source: Valve
Add your own comment

35 Comments on Valve Issues Scathing Public Response to New York Attorney General's Loot Box Lawsuit

#1
theglaze
likening loot boxes to real-world products like baseball cards, Magic: The Gathering cards, Pokémon cards, and even Labubus
...yeah but those manufacturers don't facilitate a marketplace in which they get a % cut from every transaction.
Also, the end user 100% owns those things. I don't think Steam users are allowed to make that declaration on anything their in Steam account. It's "property-as-a-service" that can be revoked at any time.
The only reason why Valve has gotten away with the gambling and marketplace for so long, is because it pays/collects a nice tax to the government(s).
Posted on Reply
#2
AGlezB
theglaze...yeah but those manufacturers don't facilitate a marketplace in which they get a % cut from every transaction.
Most have their own online stores and they also organize conventions and tournaments which have the exact same effect and they also spend a lot on marketing. The only differences are reach and permanence and they would imitate Steam in a heartbeat if they could.
Posted on Reply
#3
evernessince
I like steam as much as the next person but Valve's CS loot boxes and trading of in game items in TF2 are pretty notorious. I'm not against gambling but Valve needs to do more to ensure children aren't the one's doing it. I don't see why Valve should be getting a cut of each sale too, just reminds me of the Diablo 3 auction house. Whole thing felt like a ponzi scheme as the drop rates were so horrid until many many patches.
Posted on Reply
#4
Squared
I can't imagine trying to be popular enough to win an elected office and also going after a company as well-liked as Valve.
Posted on Reply
#5
Chaitanya
NY has a long history of banning things but when it comes to Lootboxes cannot agree more about tactics used to lure kids into spending real money and hooking them wanting more.
Posted on Reply
#6
DeltaHawk001
theglaze...yeah but those manufacturers don't facilitate a marketplace in which they get a % cut from every transaction.
Also, the end user 100% owns those things. I don't think Steam users are allowed to make that declaration on anything their in Steam account. It's "property-as-a-service" that can be revoked at any time.
The only reason why Valve has gotten away with the gambling and marketplace for so long, is because it pays/collects a nice tax to the government(s).
This feels very "interesting" given that valve doesn't really revoke the in game cosmetics, and also that that wasn't the point of the original lawsuit. The point of the lawsuit is stupid, as it is to "protect children" but all of the games with loot boxes are rated M.
Posted on Reply
#7
gQx
they are not rebuking the idea that kids get addicted early to become potential gamblers as adults ruining their lives and others around them and eventually a waste/burden of a citizen to a country. they are just saying if we are doing something wrong punish us all or not punish us like saying world's not perfect and I'm not gonna let you start with my wrongdoings to fix it. Cause that would be more wrong, right? Valve lost all my sympathy here.
Posted on Reply
#8
TheinsanegamerN
Steam's marketplace has felt kind scummy from day 1. Valve has to take the L on this one.

But then so does NY. Children cant gamble with money, they dont have jobs. If kids are gambling, its because their parents are giving them money to do so. Nobody wants to hold parents responsible though. NY also legalized sportsbetting, which is destroying millions of lives as we speak. Had Valve paid a gambling tax to NY, this lawsuit wouldnt exist.
Posted on Reply
#9
AsRock
TPU addict
Get the feeling this is a lot more than about protecting kids and more about data and what you can and cannot sell.

Kids still can go the shop and buy baseball cards and pokemon cards ?, are they not form of "gambling too ?.

Remember they would card you for info for every thing if they could, like dam a lot of places you cannot buy cigarettes without being carded even if clearly over 40+ yo.
TheinsanegamerNSteam's marketplace has felt kind scummy from day 1. Valve has to take the L on this one.

But then so does NY. Children cant gamble with money, they dont have jobs. If kids are gambling, its because their parents are giving them money to do so. Nobody wants to hold parents responsible though. NY also legalized sportsbetting, which is destroying millions of lives as we speak. Had Valve paid a gambling tax to NY, this lawsuit wouldnt exist.
Seems more like a parent issue.


EDIT:
Posted on Reply
#10
Shihab
Ok then. Ban physical, mystery boxes…
Posted on Reply
#11
lexluthermiester
@ Valve
Seriously? Get over it and remove the loot box crap! It literal gambling and it's unlawful.
Posted on Reply
#12
user556
Part of the problem stems from when the transition from euphemistic use of addiction to being used as a legal fist to pound on companies. People no longer understand what addiction actually is. And that includes lawyers it seems.
Posted on Reply
#13
AusWolf
lexluthermiester@ Valve
Seriously? Get over it and remove the loot box crap! It literal gambling and it's unlawful.
Apparently it's not unlawful, just like physical trading cards aren't.

I kind of agree with both sides to be honest.
Posted on Reply
#14
aktpu
I hope Valve gets a full body slam from NY. It's about damn time
Posted on Reply
#15
Onasi
Valve is likely to win this, actually. People seething about how their boxes are gambling might be correct from the ethical standpoint (I agree that it is), but that’s not what the laws say. They aren’t bringing up Pokemon cards and such for no reason - those already went through similar and had been declared to not be gambling, so the precedent is set. Pretty much all legal experts I have seen weigh in on this agree that the AG has a weak case and this is just the continuation of her usual tactics of trying to go for big targets with loud PR cases and try and force a settlement.

Oh, and on the whole “muh children” front - can we maybe have their fucking parents take responsibility and NOT try and have Valve farm peoples data? Why is your child playing a 17/18+ rated game and using, presumably, your bank account to buy and open loot boxes? Like, how can Valve ensure on their end that this cannot happen, except for some VERY invasive things bordering on CCP control?

Frankly, this is very much the case of both sides not really being all that sympathetic, but I have far less patience for obvious government racket tactics and two-faced hypocrisy in this case, considering the NYS history with the issue. Including, you know, JUST APPROVING THREE NEW CASINOS.
Posted on Reply
#16
melkor_unlimited
TheinsanegamerNHad Valve paid a gambling tax to NY, this lawsuit wouldnt exist.
In the end ... its always about money.
Posted on Reply
#17
TheGeekn°72
cinemawareA store that killed off physical PC gaming with their ever-present DRM and takes mafia-like 30% cut from the devs is totally likeable, eh
omg, not this again... are you really gonna pretend xbox & PS aren't the biggest reasons why physical distribution got killed off? that and region-locked launches?
and nobody but a very, very few complain about the 30% Steam takes... because literally every other app store does!! like, that's kind of an industry standard?
and I don't see a problem with DRMs as long as the game is priced right and it doesn't impact performance because as literally everyone knows, piracy is a service problem
Posted on Reply
#18
user556
Steam doesn't require DRM. It's up to the individual publisher to decide.
Posted on Reply
#19
aktpu
TheGeekn°72are you really gonna pretend xbox & PS aren't the biggest reasons why physical distribution got killed off? that and region-locked launches?
PS5 isn't region locked and you can easily buy plenty of title on a physical media today for it? On other hand we Europeans had to wait days for ME3 when it was launched even on pc
Posted on Reply
#20
happytohear
Valve obviously wants to keep that trading volume; business decision/interest. Doesn't help Valve being seen in a better light. As a capitalist company they don't care who has access to gambling as long as the profits outweigh the cost.
And the statement make me feels like Valve is ok with gambling AND loot boxes. Whataboutism is part of their toolbox.
IMO virtual loot boxes with artificial supply, nearly 100% profit margin, instant access in a closed system by Valve are not the same as physical goods and should be treated differently. And removing gambling would not worsen Steam as a service (to me at least).

Labubus is a whole different stupid trend though. UGH
Posted on Reply
#21
AusWolf
It boggles my mind how many of you think that capitalist corporatism, law, and ethics have anything to do with each other. As long as what Valve offers is legal, they're in the right here...

...says someone who completely disagrees with lootboxes on an ethical level.
OnasiOh, and on the whole “muh children” front - can we maybe have their fucking parents take responsibility and NOT try and have Valve farm peoples data? Why is your child playing a 17/18+ rated game and using, presumably, your bank account to buy and open loot boxes? Like, how can Valve ensure on their end that this cannot happen, except for some VERY invasive things bordering on CCP control?
This 100%! It's not Valve's responsibility to raise your children, but yours alone.
Posted on Reply
#23
neatfeatguy
AsRockKids still can go the shop and buy baseball cards and pokemon cards ?, are they not form of "gambling too ?.
Surprisingly I did see a dad buying some baseball card packs for his kid a few months back when I was checking out at Target. It was 4 packs and the kid was psyched! Unbeknownst to the dad, Target had implemented 2 packs of cards (any type of card, be it Magic, Pokemon, baseball, football, etc) per sale. I don't know why, must have been some run on stupid Pokemon cards or something to help limit how many go out at once, but it was applied to all trading cards. The guy was only allowed to buy 2 packs of cards for his kid, he had to relinquish the other two.
Posted on Reply
#25
TheGeekn°72
aktpuPS5 isn't region locked and you can easily buy plenty of title on a physical media today for it?
physical media was effectively region locked because companies didn't see the point to sell to places like south america or africa for example
aktpuOn other hand we Europeans had to wait days for ME3 when it was launched even on pc
yeah well, blame american exceptionalism, there was a few console launches long ago where we had to wait after the americans had their fun first too
case in point, most recent example were the test runs for marathon being US exclusive...
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 11:26 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts