Wednesday, March 11th 2026

Valve Issues Scathing Public Response to New York Attorney General's Loot Box Lawsuit

The New York state attorney general, Letitia James, recently announced that she was taking Valve to court over what she called "quintessential gambling" via loot boxes in games like Counter-Strike, Team Fortress, and Dota, stating that these loot boxes target children and adolescents, and that they put children at risk of becoming addicted to gambling when they reach adulthood. On March 11, Valve published a response to this lawsuit in a dedicated Steam Support page, stating that it does not believe the mystery boxes violate any New York state laws, defending its loot box economy by likening it to real-world blind boxes, and criticizing the attorney general for taking Valve to court while turning a blind eye to the aforementioned real-world examples.

Valve says that it had previously met with the attorney general and explained that these mystery box systems are widely used "not just in video games but in the tangible world as well," likening loot boxes to real-world products like baseball cards, Magic: The Gathering cards, Pokémon cards, and even Labubus. Valve adds that "players don't have to open mystery boxes to play Valve games," and it insists that most gamers never do. According to the gaming giant, it has been cooperating with the NY attorney general's investigation and has shut down a number of accounts found to be using loot box cosmetics on gambling sites, citing that it has closed over a million accounts for this reason. Building on its example of baseball cards, Valve criticizes the NY attorney general taking issue with the fact that the in-game items are tradable and transferrable, suggesting that if trading physical goods, like baseball cards, isn't prohibited, neither should trading in-game cosmetics be.
Apparently Valve was offered the opportunity to make a deal, but it felt as though the "type of commitments the NYAG demanded from Valve went far beyond what existing New York law requires and even beyond New York itself," adding that "it may have been easier and cheaper for Valve to make a deal with the NYAG, but we believed the type of deal that would satisfy the NYAG would have been bad for users and other game developers, and impacted our ability to innovate in game design." Valve goes on to clarify that it will comply with whatever laws are passed in New York regarding loot boxes, but mentions that none have yet been passed, despite the issue having been raised before. It also takes issue with some of the anti-gaming rhetoric and comments made by the attorney general, calling them "a mischaracterization we've all heard before," and mentioning that studies have proven that there is no link between media and real-world violence.

Valve's full statement reads as follows:
Dear New York customers of Counter-Strike 2, Dota 2, and Team Fortress 2:

You may have seen the New York Attorney General recently filed a lawsuit against Valve claiming mystery boxes (like crates, cases, and chests) in some of our games violate New York gambling laws. We don't believe that they do, and were disappointed to see the NYAG make that claim after working to educate them about our virtual items and mystery boxes since they first reached out to us in early 2023. We rarely talk about litigation, but we felt we should explain the situation to you.

We shared with the NYAG that these types of boxes in our games are widely used, not just in video games but in the tangible world as well, where generations have grown up opening baseball card packs and blind boxes and bags, and then trading and selling the items they receive. On the physical side, popular products used in this way include baseball cards, Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, and Labubu. In the game space, digital packs similar to our boxes date back to 2004 and are in widespread use. Players don't have to open mystery boxes to play Valve games. In fact, most of you don't open any boxes at all and just play the games—because the items in the boxes are purely cosmetic, there is no disadvantage to a player not spending money.

In the process of cooperating with the NYAG's investigation, we shared with them our efforts over many years to shut down accounts found to be using Valve game items on gambling sites in violation of the Steam Subscriber Agreement. We also shared with them our efforts to combat fraud and theft of users' items and our extraordinary measures to stop gambling sites from taking advantage of Steam accounts and Valve game items. Valve does not cooperate with gambling sites. To date we've locked over one million Steam accounts that were being misused by third parties in connection with gambling, fraud, and theft. We've also shipped features (like trade reversal and trade cooldown) to discourage gambling sites' ability to operate and protect Steam users from fraud. And we forbid any gambling-related business to participate in or sponsor tournaments for our games.

We have serious concerns with many of the alterations the NYAG claims are necessary to make to our games. First, the NYAG seems to believe boxes and their contents should not be transferable. They appear to assume digital mystery boxes and items in our games are different from tangible items like baseball card packs (which contain random cards), and to take issue with the fact that users have the ability to transfer the items they receive through Steam Trading or user-to-user sales on the Community Market. We think the transferability of a digital game item is good for consumers—it gives a user the ability to sell or trade an old or unwanted item for something else, in the same way an owner can sell or trade a tangible item like a Pokemon or baseball card. NYAG proposes to take away users' ability to transfer their digital items from Valve games. Transferability is a right we believe should not be taken away, and we refuse to do that.

The NYAG also proposed to gather additional information (beyond what we normally collect in the course of processing payments) about each game user on the off-chance someone in New York was anonymizing their location to appear outside of New York, such as by using a VPN. This would have involved implementing invasive technologies for every user worldwide. Similarly, the NYAG demanded that Valve collect more personal data about our users to do additional age verification—even though most payment methods used by New York Steam users already have age verification built-in. Valve knows our users care about the security of their personal information, and we believe it's in our and their interest to only collect the information necessary to operate the business and comply with law.

We respect New York's right to determine the laws governing behavior in the state. We will of course comply if the New York legislature passes laws governing mystery boxes—something it has not done despite considering the issue a few times. Such laws would be the result of a public process, presumably with input from the industry and New York gamers. The type of commitments the NYAG demanded from Valve went far beyond what existing New York law requires and even beyond New York itself. It may have been easier and cheaper for Valve to make a deal with the NYAG, but we believed the type of deal that would satisfy the NYAG would have been bad for users and other game developers, and impacted our ability to innovate in game design.

In addition, although this case is about mystery boxes, we feel the need to address comments made by the NYAG about games, real world violence, and children. Those extraneous comments are a distraction and a mischaracterization we've all heard before. Numerous studies throughout the years have concluded there is no link between media (movies, TV, books, comics, music, and games) and real world violence. Indeed, many studies highlight the beneficial impact of games to users.

Ultimately, a court will decide whose position—ours or NYAG's—is correct. In the meantime, we wanted to make sure you were aware of the potential impact to users in New York and elsewhere.
Source: Valve
Add your own comment

35 Comments on Valve Issues Scathing Public Response to New York Attorney General's Loot Box Lawsuit

#26
DeltaHawk001
aktpuI hope Valve gets a full body slam from NY. It's about damn time
What did Valve do to you?
Posted on Reply
#27
lexluthermiester
AusWolfApparently it's not unlawful, just like physical trading cards aren't.
Gambling is unlawful as a commercial business in the state of New York and most other states in the USA.That is what loot boxes are, gambling as a business model. It is very clearly definable and is not open for rationalization.
PixelTechGo Valve go!
No. Valve needs to yield and do away with the practice as a whole.
Posted on Reply
#28
evernessince
cinemawareA store that killed off physical PC gaming with their ever-present DRM and takes mafia-like 30% cut from the devs is totally likeable, eh ;) Not a great surprise that one of the most prominent anti-corpo, etc, warriors on this forum has double standards.

But at least you do condemn the indefensible loot box thing. The mental gymnastics from others here trying to somehow pretend that "this is fine" are a sight to behold.
It's not a double standard to imply that steam on the whole has been a positive while acknowledging the bad things it's done.

You are implying that digital is worse than physical inherently but it isn't. Physical games sucked. First, physical did still have DRM and many were region locked (especially Japanese titles). Having to maintain the media, the physical space they took up, having to insert it into the drive, install, ect. All worse than digital. People look at these things through rose tinted glasses but I cannot imaging having to sort through my steam library of hundreds of games IRL, let alone keeping all those physically. Nevermind moving with all those games. I have 8TB drives the length of my thumb and flat like a wafer that enables instant access to every game.

Can we really pin DRM and the move to digital entirely on steam or would that have happened naturally in the market regardless?

Don't like steam's DRM, fine. Buy the game on GOG. Not every steam game has DRM though, I have a good amount that run without the client. It's a choice by the devs. You are presenting industry choices as if they are steam's doing solely.

Perhaps people don't remember what PC gaming was like before steam or even during the xbox 360 console gen, it is worlds better today.
neatfeatguySurprisingly I did see a dad buying some baseball card packs for his kid a few months back when I was checking out at Target. It was 4 packs and the kid was psyched! Unbeknownst to the dad, Target had implemented 2 packs of cards (any type of card, be it Magic, Pokemon, baseball, football, etc) per sale. I don't know why, must have been some run on stupid Pokemon cards or something to help limit how many go out at once, but it was applied to all trading cards. The guy was only allowed to buy 2 packs of cards for his kid, he had to relinquish the other two.
Definitely due to scalpers. There are short videos of people checking out with carts full of them.
Posted on Reply
#29
lexluthermiester
evernessinceBuy the game on GOG.
This what I do. DRM and stupid crap like the subject of this article are the reasons I avoid Steam for the most part.
Posted on Reply
#30
neatfeatguy
evernessinceIt's not a double standard to imply that steam on the whole has been a positive while acknowledging the bad things it's done.

You are implying that digital is worse than physical inherently but it isn't. Physical games sucked. First, physical did still have DRM and many were region locked (especially Japanese titles). Having to maintain the media, the physical space they took up, having to insert it into the drive, install, ect. All worse than digital. People look at these things through rose tinted glasses but I cannot imaging having to sort through my steam library of hundreds of games IRL, let alone keeping all those physically. Nevermind moving with all those games. I have 8TB drives the length of my thumb and flat like a wafer that enables instant access to every game.

Can we really pin DRM and the move to digital entirely on steam or would that have happened naturally in the market regardless?

Don't like steam's DRM, fine. Buy the game on GOG. Not every steam game has DRM though, I have a good amount that run without the client. It's a choice by the devs. You are presenting industry choices as if they are steam's doing solely.

Perhaps people don't remember what PC gaming was like before steam or even during the xbox 360 console gen, it is worlds better today.



Definitely due to scalpers. There are short videos of people checking out with carts full of them.
Just remember that Steam itself is the DRM. Any game that comes off steam is required to be installed through Steam and while you may have some games that can run without Steam being active, you still don't have the game install files. Without the actual use of Steam you cannot install the game and you certainly are not allowed to download the install files to your side.

GoG you can copy the install files to your side and you never have to deal with GoG's servers again. You don't need their servers to install the game, you don't need to link the game to their Galaxy interface and you're not hindered by any kind of DRM to stop you from installing and playing the game when you want.

I actually prefer the physical media days. I've been going through and replaying a lot of my old physical games; some games I've had for up to 20+ years. I've also been making digital copies of the discs for my own personal use. I'm sitting on 80-100 (been a while since I counted how many exactly) physical games PC games still. I've put about 4 dozen of them on my computer, got them all running without the need for a disc. The biggest thing for the physical media DRM was when Windows stopped supporting it over time. I've got a few games that just won't install on any OS version newer than Vista and that's irritating. There are ways around it to get the game going, but that's for a discussion not for TPU forms. I miss the amazing artwork, stories, knickknacks and so on that would come with physical games. To each their own.
Posted on Reply
#31
AusWolf
lexluthermiesterGambling is unlawful as a commercial business in the state of New York and most other states in the USA.That is what loot boxes are, gambling as a business model. It is very clearly definable and is not open for rationalization.
Then why did they bring up trading cards as a precedent? If it was as black and white as you're saying it is, then no big corporation like Valve would even just think about doing it.
Posted on Reply
#32
lexluthermiester
AusWolfThen why did they bring up trading cards as a precedent?
A vapid legal ploy. It will not stand up to merit.
Posted on Reply
#33
AusWolf
lexluthermiesterA vapid legal ploy. It will not stand up to merit.
I'm not so sure about that, but let's agree to disagree.
Posted on Reply
#34
HOkay
We think the transferability of a digital game item is good for consumers—it gives a user the ability to sell or trade an old or unwanted item for something else
But being able to resell your games to others is absolutely not good for consumers I guess huh. Whilst I agree with them on this stance on in-game items, the hypocrisy is palpable.
Posted on Reply
#35
Inferna
To people saying that steam add DRM or is the DRM itself, you should know that almost any game released on steam without Denuvo is 2 clicks away to be completely free of DRM or having to use steam to launch the game.

And that includes online games, let say that the most played game on steam for the last 12 years is Spacewar, the majority of users are not developers.

Valve knows and never tried to counter any of that, we could even say that they enable piracy.

Don't crack games it's illegal of course!
(And don't do crack, kids. Your parents might ignore it entirely, but rest assured, governments will soon hold 100% responsibility for you.)
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 11:18 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts