Friday, July 4th 2025
Stop Killing Games Petition Passes 1 Million-Signature Milestone—Now One Step Closer to EU Parliament
The Stop Killing Games movement aims to preserve the ownership of video games by requiring game publishers to leave their games in a "playable state" when they eventually discontinue support. "Stop Killing Games is a consumer movement started to challenge the legality of publishers destroying video games they have sold to customers. An increasing number of video games are sold effectively as goods - with no stated expiration date - but designed to be completely unplayable as soon as support from the publisher ends." One commonly cited example of this is The Crew, which was shut down by Ubisoft earlier this year, after 10 years on the market. The initiative, started and fronted by Joe Scott of the Accursed Farms YouTube channel, just announced that it has officially passed 1,000,000 signatures on its European Citizen's Initiative petition, which effectively means that it is one step closer to being granted a hearing in the EU parliament, which could potentially result in new consumer protection laws in support of the movement's goal of protecting game ownership and preserving video games.
According to Scott in a new YouTube video addressing the million-signature milestone, the movement and its EU petition aren't yet at the finish line. For one, there is a strong likelihood that the petition hasn't actually received a million distinct signatures, due to issues like invalid signatures caused by errors and signature spoofing by well-intentioned people outside the EU trying to add their signature to the pile. As a result of these issues, Scott is asking viewers to continue pushing the initiative so that it can continue gaining steam. Ideally, he says, the petition would reach 140% of the required signatures before the July 31 deadline. According to the Stop Killing Games Tracker site, which is not officially affiliated with the initiative, the EU petition has received nearly 500,000 signatures in the last week alone, suggesting that it may reach the 1,4 million-signature threshold before the July 31 deadline if things continue at the current rate.
Sources:
European Commission, Stop Killing Games, Stop Killing Games Tracker
According to Scott in a new YouTube video addressing the million-signature milestone, the movement and its EU petition aren't yet at the finish line. For one, there is a strong likelihood that the petition hasn't actually received a million distinct signatures, due to issues like invalid signatures caused by errors and signature spoofing by well-intentioned people outside the EU trying to add their signature to the pile. As a result of these issues, Scott is asking viewers to continue pushing the initiative so that it can continue gaining steam. Ideally, he says, the petition would reach 140% of the required signatures before the July 31 deadline. According to the Stop Killing Games Tracker site, which is not officially affiliated with the initiative, the EU petition has received nearly 500,000 signatures in the last week alone, suggesting that it may reach the 1,4 million-signature threshold before the July 31 deadline if things continue at the current rate.
Scott also mentioned that petition to the UK government has also surpassed 100,000 signatures, which could also result in the matter being brought before the UK parliament.
UK citizens and residents can sign a petition where, if it passes 100,000 signatures, new law will be considered to be brought before Parliament for debate to prohibit publishers from destroying video games that customers have already paid for.However, Scott is not particularly hopeful that this will be enough to get a law passed in the UK, since the matter has already been dismissed by the Department of Culture, Media, and Sport, with the body declining to amend or create any laws. Instead, the DCMS said that companies selling games in the UK must abide by existing consumer protections laws. Being able to go directly to the UK parliament means that the petition would effectively go around that department.

61 Comments on Stop Killing Games Petition Passes 1 Million-Signature Milestone—Now One Step Closer to EU Parliament
Developers can't afford to exclude UK and EU for gaming.
These are digital goods, making such a distinction is easy, there is no hardware, no fabrication to limit what you can do.
There are plenty of games and open source games which show that such bloatware is not needed. It is for advertising. People bought steam for 25 years. People should live with all that bloatware.
I want a paper box, paper handbook and very high quality kingston or similar usb pen drive which is larger as the game with the full game files. a digital download option for a while, e.g. 10 year should be additional avaiable. I do not see where the issue is when games costs now 120€ per game, sometimes around 60€.
Buster wolfHow does Steam even relate to the point of the movement? In fact, bloatware or not, Steam actually actively helps game preservation by the fact that any unlisted game is still available for download from their CDN without issue. And Valve themselves have consistently offered LAN and self hosted dedicated servers for all their releases. They are literally the opposite of the problem the petition is aimed at.It's an issue people want to have addressed by the EU. How it gets addressed and how the sausage is made etc is an argument for later.
Yes I know its not technically orphaned, but damn close to it.
Its a completely different playing field, that of distribution. So as a distributor, they're doing a fine job. But they ain't preserving games for anyone.
The FOSS model isn't going to work for everyone, because it's often stale, and more often than not geared towards people who care so much about software that they aren't representative of the needs of the many. People just like stuff that makes their life easy, that's why steam became such a hit in the first place.
You seem to have the impression that game are rising in cost because they are increasing their margins, when the reality is that they have to increase the price to keep up with their expense and still make a benefit. Second, that USB stick would probably come with a DRM that would require the stick to be plugged to prove that bought the game. No way in hell that publishers would just distribute defensless game files across the world like that. That device would probably be a USB security key for the game distributed on it.
I'm not praising anybody. But, on the other hand, more of such people are needed.... if there were more of responsible and determined people, the gaming intustry, heck, the world wouldn't happen in such deep sh*t, it is at right now. It would never happen.Transfered, or... dumped. There are tons of great games, that came before the live service/always onlyne requirement became a thing. However, if that game by a big publisher was popular, and coincidentally still is, due to community support, the chances that it is going to to be recovered, or let alone officially revived, are miserable.
Just a bad example BF2, that was so popular and widespread. It was published at so manyways. It was even available at Steam... It is still being supported by community, and had many iterations of conversion mods, many people play it every day.
But... what was and is the stance of EA? They have sent the cease and desist, to all communty modders, including both BF2 and BF2142. Justifying it as time to move on, to the new and interesting games, to new endeavours.
Heck EA won't listen, and evaluate the data, the preferences, calls of players and community. They will rather fall, digging their faces into the ground. They already have been slammed by reviews of 2042, but they just ignore the reality, and keep pushing their cr*p to everyone throat. Yes, the game might finally aquired the playable shape. But it still if far from what Battlefield. And EA surely, wont re-release the BF2, 2142, 3, or 4 for sure. Because then, their MTX and live service riddled garbage, would plummet in sales, imediately.
And this is the same fate for all EA and Ubisoft, and many other big publishers games.
Don't get me wrong. I don't like, or play BF games. But it's still an example.Yeah! So many games, so many modders and communities have emerged and gone, while waiting until the tools and code to be released. But alas! The work of hundred, in not thousands of incredibly talented and enthusiastic people, community modders/developers have drowned in vain. So many projects went nowhere. People were fixing games for decades, because the original developers left the games half way, in half-wrecked state. Heck, so many games, that community told to publishers, that they would gladly carry the burden of maintenace of the said games for free. But no publishers rather destroy the IP, than let it be successful. Let alone, be shared/distributed for free, by someone, who values it.
I don't even mention the games that are not salvagable, because of GFWL code being injected and intertwisted with the game/engine cores. Now that service is long gone, so are so many great games, that been unfortunate to implement that disease.The preservation depends a lot on the will of publishers, to share their IP. Something tells me, these folks won't do any right move, even if they would be under the gun, let alone being legally pressured. They don't fear it. They know, they will find ways to circuimvent any court decision, and continue to do what they doing, and did for decades.
Many remasters are complete garbage. They either do not implement any innovations, fixes, or even degrade in features and quality, becoming the demasters. The sole existance of these remasters, are the evidence that they've been released, because they suit the publisher's will, and not to favor the player-base.
But I agree. The people were telling companies, what games they like, and for what features, qualities. The data is there, it's on forums, communities, discords, reddit, and other social platforms etc, it's all in public access. The statistic, of game playabiltiy, is everywhere. The companies don't give a dang. They bend the market, like the river beds.
So yeah, the publisher know very well, which games are in favor, and that they could get piles of money, by redistributing old games again, without even a single change. But the won't. Because as I've said before, this means that the publishers would have to accept, that their current ideas, concepts is DOA, it's an utter garbage. The projects, that have been fed millions into, and which brought billions in return.
I strongly doubt, that EU, even if they will do everything correct, will be able, to push the law upon the game maker companies heads.
A lot of the "illegal downloading" are mainly the result of horrible services, and always of bad accessibility. Yes, the free content will be always be in favor, because it is accessible.
Surely, many people woul keep downloading illegaly, even if they will have money to buy legaly. But many do so, due to the absence of enough money, which is financial accessibility. Be it available with e.g. adjusted price, according to the income in the particular country, there would be more sells.
Music industry has a bit better situation, because there is enough of streaming services, and the coverage is a lot bigger. Also, the "illegal" downloads, eventually benefit both publishers and the musicians, as it solves one of its issues issues- distribution, and popularizing. A lot of artists become renown, because of "illegal" spread.
On the other hand, there is the service unavailability. A lot of people, in a lot of countries, could "bite the bullet", and buy the stuff, to support the devs, for legal reasons, and to avoid the malware. So far, the game services, (outside the Steam, and maybe GoG, as the biggest among accessible storefronts) are not available everywhere. The purchaseability beyond the NA and EU is significantly lower, due to wealth difference. But it is there, nonetheless.
And more and more of publishing companies, are pushing their greedy will, and make the price region-indifferent. So the gamer in third-world country, pays the same, as the one in higher-income country, is primary market (thus sets the price).
This is opposite to bein accessible. This leads to isolation of gamers with bigger wealth, making it their only hobby, dertroying the playerbase, and unity, communications, between the players. This is against the whole point of the games- to get together people across the world, to remove the wealth, age, gender and other barriers and differences. So everyone could find a joy from both, gaming itself, and the communication.
Jacking the game prices, even retroactively, makes the games unatractive, or even inaccessible altogether, for many people. It's like the game publishers don't want for their games to be poular, or sold at all. The GPU prices put the nails into the game intustry eventual coffin.
Also, the game makers, movie makers, and copyright overall, like to use "piracy" for their bad services, and erroneous decisions. They use it as the reason, for not widen and easening the distribution. And then, the regions, where the product availability is poor they us that as a shield, to bash consumers for the raise of piracy, and untrustworthiness.Even a simple petition is powerful enough, if... there is a willingness to accept and exceute it. Once, THQ (as much as Clifford B and MS/Epic) was preaching, that PC users are the bane, and they are the source of piracy, and that Space Marine would never happen on this platform. One an a half decades later, the visually astonishing successor title, was released, as much as SEGA trying to beat the dead horse, and try to resell the same old game (that wasn't even developed by them) for the second time. And this esists only, because back in 2010, THQ was forced to meet the demand and execute the petition, they themselves thought is unachievable.
Having said that it would be nice to have games that don't require to have online accounts to function and launchers collect your data when they really don't need them.
It would also be nice if Sony got on the emulation bandwagon and provided backward compatibility for their consoles but fat chance that ever happening. RIP PS3 it was fun while it lasted.
If it fails I might file such a petition in the Brazilian system (if one doesn't exist already, I definitely must look), but it's probably too weak for any global scale game dev to care. (Yep,someone made one. With a single signature in support.)