Friday, October 9th 2026

Gears of War: E-Day Sold 168,000 Copies on Steam but Xbox Game Pass Players Generated 130% More Revenue

We recently reported that Gears of War: E-Day wasn't having the best launch week over on Steam, but according to Alinea Analytics's Rhys Elliott, Steam doesn't even account for half of the game's revenue or owner base. The analytics firm estimates that Gears of War: E-Day sold around 230,000 copies since its launch, with around 168,000 of those copies coming from Steam and 62,000 of them coming from Xbox. Despite this, though, Xbox players still accounted for almost three quarters of the game's $37 million in revenue.

The big differentiator here is that 1.7 million gamers played E-Day via an Xbox Game Pass subscription, and 722,000 subscribers paid an additional $30 for the Premium Edition Game Pass upgrade, which gave them early access to the game. The end result is that, even though few gamers actually bought Gears of War: E-Day, Xbox accounted for an estimated $26 million in revenue, where Steam only garnered $11 million.
Source: Rhys Elliott (Alinea Analytics) on X
Add your own comment

23 Comments on Gears of War: E-Day Sold 168,000 Copies on Steam but Xbox Game Pass Players Generated 130% More Revenue

#2
xorbe
Same numbers presented in a way that makes Steam look better: 168,000 Steam players but 1,700,000 Xbox players. So Xbox only generated 2.3x the revenue for 10.1x the players.
Posted on Reply
#3
Chane
This tells me stupid people paid 30 dollars for DLC while at the same time not owning the base game. Psst, your game pass should have included it at no extra cost.
Posted on Reply
#4
ir_cow
I am one of those xbox revunes. Paid $15 for a month of Game Pass PC and i'll be done with it before the 30 days is up :)
Posted on Reply
#5
c2DDragon
Morality : Modern players prefer to rent their videogames instead of buying them.

Doesn't look good to me but hey whatever.
Posted on Reply
#6
kiniku
Hilarious. The Coalition is done LOL
Posted on Reply
#7
TechLurker
Even if the budget was only 200M (the insider claims are closer to 400M though), that's practically a financial failure; moreso given that the majority of players were probably Gamepass users just trying it out for free as part of their subscription. They would somehow need to convince over 5X the current buyer count to spend enough just to break 200M and make back the development costs. If the budget is the rumored 400M, they would need to somehow convince 15X more than the stated buyer numbers. And that's just to reach net 0; recovering everything spent on development (who knows how much more they spent on marketing).

The numbers game they're trying to use is the same crap Ubisoft tried with AC Shadows, and ultimately they reportedly failed to make back what was spent on the game's development, leading to them selling part of themselves to Tencent.

Meanwhile, something like Ace Combat 8, with a modest budget of around 40M (which is lower than Bamco previously spent on past Ace Combat games), confirmed they SOLD over 1 million copies of the game; which would put its earnings at least around 70M based on its base game cost of 70 USD, give or take regional pricing differences, but probably earned more than that given that the Deluxe Edition cost 90 USD and a sizable number of people bought that too. They've already made back their investment and then some, and that's despite mainly targeting their existing audience and letting marketing sell it to new audiences.
Posted on Reply
#8
Bigshrimp
That's some small sales numbers for the budget used to make this game. They definitely have a bad business model if everything they make now doesn't even make its money back. I used to love the original Gears of War games, but the sequels got so stale over time, like most franchises.
Posted on Reply
#9
vlad.coolish
c2DDragonMorality : Modern players prefer to rent their videogames instead of buying them.

Doesn't look good to me but hey whatever.
You do not buy videogames :D
You do not own the videogames you paid for :cool:
Posted on Reply
#10
the54thvoid
Super Moderator
TechLurkerThe numbers game they're trying to use is the same crap Ubisoft tried with AC Shadows, and ultimately they reportedly failed to make back what was spent on the game's development, leading to them selling part of themselves to Tencent.
Completely misleading comment.

Tencent starting buying into Ubisoft in 2018, then purchasing substantially more in 2022. At that point they also held 49.9% of the founding company. This was all well before Shadows.

Shadows came out in March 2025.

Tencent bought (26% financial interest) into the offshoot that held rights to several leading Ubi franchises in Nov 2025.
Posted on Reply
#11
DAPUNISHER
vlad.coolishYou do not buy videogames :D
You do not own the videogames you paid for :cool:
You do if you buy them from GOG.

These revenue estimates are only initial numbers for the XBOX ecosystem. They do not tell you how many new subscriptions it will produce or how long each player will subscribe. Nor can they tell you how effective the title will be at increasing subscriber retention.
Posted on Reply
#12
Kohl Baas
vlad.coolishYou do not buy videogames :D
You do not own the videogames you paid for :cool:
You never did... :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#14
chrcoluk
BigshrimpThat's some small sales numbers for the budget used to make this game. They definitely have a bad business model if everything they make now doesn't even make its money back. I used to love the original Gears of War games, but the sequels got so stale over time, like most franchises.
They need to get development budgets down, stop allocating movie budgets to computer games.
Posted on Reply
#15
Vayra86
ir_cowI am one of those xbox revunes. Paid $15 for a month of Game Pass PC and i'll be done with it before the 30 days is up :)
Everyone with more sense than money will do it like this... gosh why doesnt Xbox turn a profit??? Hurr durr
Posted on Reply
#16
Onasi
I still don’t understand the 1000 IQ strategy of putting your giga-AAA fuck-off budget in-house games on a cheap subscription service day one. Like… I said it for years now, but this is not a workable business model. As @Vayra86 correctly points out, being surprised when this, uh, unconventional approach fails to meet reasonable profit goals is just downright silly.
Posted on Reply
#17
Red Hood
Crackong400 million cost btw.
Did they get scammed by some consultancy and marketing companies?
Posted on Reply
#18
Imouto
Red HoodDid they get scammed by some consultancy and marketing companies?
Same chaotic management as always. Xbox had The Coalition working on UE tech development and they had to hire People Can Fly to help developing Gears of War E-Day. My best guess is that hiring a high profile studio for years doesn't come cheap.

www.resetera.com/threads/people-can-fly-joined-gears-of-war-e-day-in-2023-announced-in-2023-under-codename-%E2%80%9Cproject-maverick%E2%80%9D.1092984/
Posted on Reply
#19
BoxCutter
c2DDragonMorality : Modern players prefer to rent their videogames instead of buying them.

Doesn't look good to me but hey whatever.
The morality is that modern games are so abysmal, no sane person is willing to fork the full price for this forgettable and disposable crap.
Red HoodDid they get scammed by some consultancy and marketing companies?
Self-inflicted scam.
Posted on Reply
#20
rojo
BoxCutterThe morality is that modern games are so abysmal, no sane person is willing to fork the full price for this forgettable and disposable crap.


Self-inflicted scam.
Sad but true.
Posted on Reply
#21
Hyrel
BigshrimpThat's some small sales numbers for the budget used to make this game. They definitely have a bad business model if everything they make now doesn't even make its money back.
The problem is not the business model, but that most of the games they make are just not good. The latest Forza was also on GamePass and yet it still sold loads on Steam surpassing 300k concurrent players.
Posted on Reply
#22
Vayra86
Kohl BaasYou never did... :laugh:
And yet, we always did anyway, and always will. I'm past this non issue tbh. If they make a game too hard to play, I simply won't play it and we'll see more of the articles like this one.

Publishers need to stow their arrogance because every single time they fall flat on their face. Microsoft seems adamant to keep doing that. Power to them...

In the real world, it seems like we can emulate almost every console on a dishwasher already and play every game from wherever we like, and if you have two brain cells and an internet connection, you could do all of that for free, too. Gaming continues and will further continue to become cheaper and cheaper, and ever simpler to access. Graphics progress has stalled for the last decade odd, and you can easily just skip the new sauce and have just as much fun. Nothing that won't run. I learned yesterday I could theoretically play WoW Classic on my phone... I mean... lol.
BoxCutterThe morality is that modern games are so abysmal, no sane person is willing to fork the full price for this forgettable and disposable crap.
Yeah its so strange, burning this level of cash on a product that is so basic. The only possible explanation is a completely incompetent management with completely mismanaged projects. I mean, how the fuck do you spend even 100 M on a single player game and come out with bog standard shooter fare based on an existing franchise. There is literally nothing new in GoWED. Just... how? The money can't possibly have gone into actual game dev budgets...
Posted on Reply
#23
Kohl Baas
Vayra86And yet, we always did anyway, and always will. I'm past this non issue tbh. If they make a game too hard to play, I simply won't play it and we'll see more of the articles like this one.

Publishers need to stow their arrogance because every single time they fall flat on their face. Microsoft seems adamant to keep doing that. Power to them...

In the real world, it seems like we can emulate almost every console on a dishwasher already and play every game from wherever we like, and if you have two brain cells and an internet connection, you could do all of that for free, too. Gaming continues and will further continue to become cheaper and cheaper, and ever simpler to access. Graphics progress has stalled for the last decade odd, and you can easily just skip the new sauce and have just as much fun. Nothing that won't run. I learned yesterday I could theoretically play WoW Classic on my phone... I mean... lol.


Yeah its so strange, burning this level of cash on a product that is so basic. The only possible explanation is a completely incompetent management with completely mismanaged projects. I mean, how the fuck do you spend even 100 M on a single player game and come out with bog standard shooter fare based on an existing franchise. There is literally nothing new in GoWED. Just... how? The money can't possibly have gone into actual game dev budgets...
I merely hinted the fact that you haven't ever bought the game itself, you bought a medium containing the game and the same license they can revoke now. I use to bash GOG fanatics occasionally with the fact that purely legally speaking, having a copy of the game does not mean they can not revoke your license to play it. They can. And you'll became the same pirate who haven't bought it at all. Legally spaking...
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 19th, 2026 16:02 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts