Friday, September 4th 2015

AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not

There won't be a Radeon R9 Nano review on TechPowerUp. AMD says that it has too few review samples for the press. When AMD first held up the Radeon R9 Nano at its "Fiji" GPU unveil, to us it came across as the most promising product based on the chip, even more than the R9 Fury series, its dual-GPU variant, and the food-processor-shaped SFF gaming desktop thing. The prospect of "faster than R9 290X at 175W" is what excited us the most, as that would disrupt NVIDIA's GM204 based products. Unfortunately, the most exciting product by AMD also has the least amount of excitement by AMD itself.

The first signs of that are, AMD making it prohibitively expensive at $650, and not putting it in the hands of the press, for a launch-day review. We're not getting one, and nor do some of our friends on either sides of the Atlantic. AMD is making some of its tallest claims with this product, and it's important (for AMD) that some of those claims are put to the test. A validated product could maybe even convince some to reach for their wallets, to pull out $650.
Are we sourgraping? You tell us. We're one of the few sites that give you noise testing by some really expensive and broad-ranged noise-testing equipment, and more importantly, card-only power-draw. Our reviews also grill graphics cards through 22 real-world tests across four resolutions, each, and offer price-performance graphs. When NVIDIA didn't send us a GeForce GTX TITAN-Z sample, we didn't care. We didn't make an announcement like this. At $2,999, it was just a terrible product and we never wished it was part of our graphs. Its competing R9 295X2 could be had under $700, and so it continues to top our performance charts.

The R9 Nano, on the other hand, has the potential for greatness. Never mind the compact board design and its SFF credentials. Pull out this ASIC, put it on a normal 20-25 cm PCB, price it around $350, and dual-slot cooling that can turn its fans off in idle, and AMD could have had a GM204-killing product. Sadly, there's no way for us to test that, either. We can't emulate an R9 Nano on an R9 Fury X. The Nano appears to have a unique power/temperature based throttling algorithm that we can't copy.

"Fiji" is a good piece of technology, but apparently, very little effort is being made to put it into the hands of as many people as possible (and by that we mean consumers). This is an incoherence between what AMD CEO stated at the "Fiji" unveil, and what her company is doing. It's also great disservice to the people who probably stayed up many nights to get the interposer design right, or sailing through uncharted territory with HBM. Oh well.
Add your own comment

759 Comments on AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not

#251
dorsetknob
"YOUR RMA REQUEST IS CON-REFUSED"
Sony Xperia SYou know that after doing the review, you need probably to return the card to her respective owners ? :p
Ha Ha
what happens if they go chapter 11 between sending the card for review and the review being done ( or bankrupt )

you never answered my question fan boy did you get a card to fan-review
Posted on Reply
#252
rtwjunkie
PC Gaming Enthusiast
john_OK, the AMD part is so negative that I have to ask if the video was made after learning that you will not get a Nano.
No, it wasnt. It was released on another thread several days ago, so I would imagine zithe recorded at least a week ago.
Posted on Reply
#253
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
john_OK, the AMD part is so negative that I have to ask if the video was made after learning that you will not get a Nano.
It was made before, but that's irrelevant. It's a test video.
Posted on Reply
#254
remixedcat
I'd do YT reviews if it wasn't for my chronic bronchitis getting in the way and my constant coughing and stuff :(
Posted on Reply
#255
Sony Xperia S
dorsetknobyou never answered my question fan boy did you get a card to fan-review
Calling me "a fan boy" won't get you any answer.
Posted on Reply
#256
abundantcores
john_OK, the AMD part is so negative that I have to ask if the video was made after learning that you will not get a Nano.
I think that is an unfortunate mistake, it doesn't look like anything mollitious to me but rather an attempt to inject humour, which is a good thing but how it was done IMO was unwise.

They are right that GPU is a re-brand of a re-brand and the potential to make a wisecrack of it is there, with a different kind of thought process about how that would look to someone watching: it comes across as a bit derogatory toward the cards vendor (AMD) already the viewer gets the impression AMD are the but of jokes. that can be devastating for AMD.

The information is valid and should be included, but its no joke and perhaps a coment on whether or not the product is actually any good despite it being a re-brand, does the fact that it is a re-brand really matter? this is information that is important to the viewer.
Posted on Reply
#257
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
Sony Xperia SCalling me "a fan boy" won't get you any answer.
Sorry, but we can't have your kind of posters on TPU. I gave you a long rope.
Posted on Reply
#258
Cloudfire
AMD is afraid of the truth. Very afraid.

Notice power from these two cards. GTX 970 ITX pictured below is overclocked too :roll:







Unfortunately for AMD the truth will come out with or without TPU review anyway. Worst case is that TPU borrow the card from someone within the industry. Everyone knows TPU is well known and respected among everyone.
Posted on Reply
#259
dorsetknob
"YOUR RMA REQUEST IS CON-REFUSED"
Sony Xperia SCalling me "a fan boy" won't get you any answer.
calling you anything on this subject is a waste of e ink its pointless your so fan boy you put everyone else on the site to shame
Posted on Reply
#260
Cloudfire
newtekie1The question I have is why did JayztwoCents get one over the other review sites? I like his videos and all, but his GPU reviews are terrible compared to the others, especially TPU. It makes no sense.
Jayz is a system builder with great experience with case building and customization.
He might have cooked up a special rig for the Nano to showcase it. If he haven`t, he is still very good at explaining how it all fits together
Size is mostly the only selling point AMD have of this card, so they try to market it like that.
Too bad GTX 970 ITX is there to ruin the show :p
Posted on Reply
#261
Aquinus
Resident Wat-man
btarunrSorry, but we can't have your kind of posters on TPU. I gave you a long rope.
Not to digress but, does that mean a permanent vacation?
Posted on Reply
#262
ZoneDymo
btarunrSorry, but we can't have your kind of posters on TPU. I gave you a long rope.
The kind who gets called a fanboy? man...way to victim blame...
Posted on Reply
#263
Aquinus
Resident Wat-man
ZoneDymoThe kind who gets called a fanboy? man...way to victim blame...
Victim blaming? Clearly you haven't read enough of Sony's posts which speak for themselves.
Sony Xperia SWhy am I not surprised at all by this too ?

Nvidia is so dirty like pigs in the mud.

I keep telling you that this company is not good but how many listen to me ?
The world will become a better place when we get rid of nvidia.

Monopoly of AMD (with good hearts) will be better than monopoly of nvidia (who only look how to screw technological progress).
Posted on Reply
#264
Furunomoe
Dear Intel,

Please start making graphics card again. Something like a 576 EU Gen 9 graphics might be pretty interesting.
Posted on Reply
#265
rtwjunkie
PC Gaming Enthusiast
ZoneDymoThe kind who gets called a fanboy? man...way to victim blame...
WTH?! Clearly you have not seen the constant disruption of this site that Sony has committed on a daily basis. Try searching out their posts for the last 6 months, and then decide if you still want to ask that question.
Posted on Reply
#266
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
FurunomoeDear Intel,

Please start making graphics card again. Something like a 576 EU Gen 9 graphics might be pretty interesting.
Intel EUs are very big. I reckon a 576 EU discrete GPU would be about 750 mm2 die area on 14 nm.
Posted on Reply
#267
Furunomoe
btarunrIntel EUs are very big. I reckon a 576 EU discrete GPU would be about 750 mm2 die area on 14 nm.
I reckon it will be pretty big too. Perhaps a 432 EU flagship, 288/360 EU mainstream, and 144/216 EU entry level would sort of make sense. Now, will they ever make their re-entry to the consumer discrete graphics market?

Or perhaps something else. Maybe PowerVR?
Posted on Reply
#268
Ruru
Trepie
"You tell us. We're one of the few sites that give you noise testing by some really expensive and broad-ranged noise-testing equipment, and more importantly, card-only power-draw. Our reviews also grill graphics cards through 22 real-world tests across four resolutions, each, and offer price-performance graphs"

And that is why I think TPU's GPU review are the best! :toast:
Posted on Reply
#269
Aquinus
Resident Wat-man
btarunrIntel EUs are very big. I reckon a 576 EU discrete GPU would be about 750 mm2 die area on 14 nm.
If it scales linearly. That would be one huge die as well, I can't imagine yields would be very good.
Posted on Reply
#270
alucasa
The catism is strong in this thread.

... Whatever that means.
Posted on Reply
#272
Tsukiyomi91
Up to 1GHz core speed... no Boost profile whatsoever. When it barely reaches thermal limits, it'll bog down to even slower speed to "reduce temperature". That is a no go marketing campaign for a vendor that wants to make fast cards... unless the chip is an old one with little or no improvements over the HD7xxx release that's unveiled a few years ago... which it is...
Posted on Reply
#273
cuneytcam
Just checked the preliminary TPU youtube video. As an AMD product user (not that it affects my opinion). i can sense you guys seem to be a bit upset about not getting r9 nano review sample and i can understand that. You guys should have gotten one to review. However, with all my honest feelings that video seems to be an excuse to target AMD for not getting one to review and not in subtle way but in a noticable way.

I have been a long stalker of TPU, but if you are going to use your media power for some weird agenda i highly doubt it will help you in the long run. For example rebranding comes with its own losses that would show up in results graphs no matter what your funny comments are. I dont want to listen a review editor bashing in a way for something that has no addition for a review. They could rebrand ATI 9500 PRO for 2016 lineup. Bash it for low performance, bash it for high P. consumption. Until then it seems to me like "OMG REBRAND LOL". R9 390 is an appealing product for me aswell as GTX970. (I will do my best to not to buy nvidia products just because they should not be confident about fecking customers over and get away with it.)

For rebranding I would rather like to hear possible downsides. Like;

-Still old Tech and not a new silicon which would hurt the user in the long run and might have shortcomings sooner than users could guess.
-They may be rebrands but prices have gone up more than 4GB memory addition so it has lower bang for buck ratio than original brand.
Posted on Reply
#274
Tatty_Two
Gone Fishing
cuneytcamJust checked the preliminary TPU youtube video. As an AMD product user (not that it affects my opinion). i can sense you guys seem to be a bit upset about not getting r9 nano review sample and i can understand that. You guys should have gotten one to review. However, with all my honest feelings that video seems to be an excuse to target AMD for not getting one to review and not in subtle way but in a noticable way.

I have been a long stalker of TPU, but if you are going to use your media power for some weird agenda i highly doubt it will help you in the long run. For example rebranding comes with its own losses that would show up in results graphs no matter what your funny comments are. I dont want to listen a review editor bashing in a way for something that has no addition for a review. They could rebrand ATI 9500 PRO for 2016 lineup. Bash it for low performance, bash it for high P. consumption. Until then it seems to me like "OMG REBRAND LOL". R9 390 is an appealing product for me aswell as GTX970. (I will do my best to not to buy nvidia products just because they should not be confident about fecking customers over and get away with it.)

For rebranding I would rather like to hear possible downsides. Like;

-Still old Tech and not a new silicon which would hurt the user in the long run and might have shortcomings sooner than users could guess.
-They may be rebrands but prices have gone up more than 4GB memory addition so it has lower bang for buck ratio than original brand.
It has been said earlier that the Video test was run before the news about Nano/review.
Posted on Reply
#275
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
cuneytcamJust checked the preliminary TPU youtube video. As an AMD product user (not that it affects my opinion). i can sense you guys seem to be a bit upset about not getting r9 nano review sample and i can understand that. You guys should have gotten one to review. However, with all my honest feelings that video seems to be an excuse to target AMD for not getting one to review and not in subtle way but in a noticable way.
Video was made last week, we learned we're not getting a sample yesterday.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 17th, 2026 18:15 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts