Friday, June 7th 2019
MSI CEO: AMD Plans to Stop Being the Value Alternative, X570 Motherboards to be Expensive
MSI's CEO Charles Chiang, quoted by Tom's Hardware at COMPUTEX 2019, laid out what we were already seeing with motherboard designs from all vendors of AMD's X570-based motherboards: pricing is likely increasing across the board, and AMD's market positioning won't be of the alternative, lower-value brand.
As quoted, Chiang said that ""Lots of people ask me, what do you think about today's AMD? I say today's AMD is completely different company compared to two, three, five years ago. They have nice technology and they are there to put the higher spec with the reasonable pricing. But right now they say, "Hey Charles, let's push to marketing to the higher [end]. So let's sell higher-pricing motherboards, higher-spec motherboards, and let's see what will happen in the market. So I don't think that AMD is the company that wants to sell low cost here, low cost there." Which does make sense: AMD isn't in the position of the underdog anymore -at least technology and product-portfolio wise when it comes to consumer CPUs. With better products, comes a desire for higher margins, and a change in direction for a company that was basically forced to almost cut itself out of the market in terms of profits with its previous, non-competitive CPU designs.Efforts to survive on AMD's part have been immense, with the company severely tightening its belt in all fields, including R&D, in the times leading to the launch of their previous-gen architecture, Bulldozer. And with the way that one architecture panned out in the market, AMD didn't really find a way to dig itself out of the trenches. No like it has with Zen: a lithe, small, highly efficient design that allowed the company to not only make up lost ground on technology and CPU performance but also on profits. That the company wants to price its products in higher segments, alongside their performance improvements and competitiveness against Intel's slow-moving lineup, makes all sorts of sense from a business perspective.Charles Chiang said that there a multitude of factors contributing to the higher pricing of X570 motherboards: that AMD is planning to charge more for each chipset (compared to the ASMedia-designed X470), but also because of the integration of PCIe 4.0. PCIe 4.0 support has meant a higher-TDp chipset (which has required a throwback to the days of old with active cooling over AMD's chipset, which has increased its TDp up to 10 W compared to the previous gen's X470's 3 W); and because PCIe switches are another best entirely in terms of complexity and power delivery capabilities. All of these add cost, and this cost will end up being passed on to end users (at least partially): as it always is.
Source:
Tom's Hardware
As quoted, Chiang said that ""Lots of people ask me, what do you think about today's AMD? I say today's AMD is completely different company compared to two, three, five years ago. They have nice technology and they are there to put the higher spec with the reasonable pricing. But right now they say, "Hey Charles, let's push to marketing to the higher [end]. So let's sell higher-pricing motherboards, higher-spec motherboards, and let's see what will happen in the market. So I don't think that AMD is the company that wants to sell low cost here, low cost there." Which does make sense: AMD isn't in the position of the underdog anymore -at least technology and product-portfolio wise when it comes to consumer CPUs. With better products, comes a desire for higher margins, and a change in direction for a company that was basically forced to almost cut itself out of the market in terms of profits with its previous, non-competitive CPU designs.Efforts to survive on AMD's part have been immense, with the company severely tightening its belt in all fields, including R&D, in the times leading to the launch of their previous-gen architecture, Bulldozer. And with the way that one architecture panned out in the market, AMD didn't really find a way to dig itself out of the trenches. No like it has with Zen: a lithe, small, highly efficient design that allowed the company to not only make up lost ground on technology and CPU performance but also on profits. That the company wants to price its products in higher segments, alongside their performance improvements and competitiveness against Intel's slow-moving lineup, makes all sorts of sense from a business perspective.Charles Chiang said that there a multitude of factors contributing to the higher pricing of X570 motherboards: that AMD is planning to charge more for each chipset (compared to the ASMedia-designed X470), but also because of the integration of PCIe 4.0. PCIe 4.0 support has meant a higher-TDp chipset (which has required a throwback to the days of old with active cooling over AMD's chipset, which has increased its TDp up to 10 W compared to the previous gen's X470's 3 W); and because PCIe switches are another best entirely in terms of complexity and power delivery capabilities. All of these add cost, and this cost will end up being passed on to end users (at least partially): as it always is.






151 Comments on MSI CEO: AMD Plans to Stop Being the Value Alternative, X570 Motherboards to be Expensive
But, at least I'm pretty sure that these X570 motherboard fans aren't as noisy as ~15 years ago.Paid 119eur from my MSI X470 board, though this was from Christmas sale. But my point is, you can grab a cheap good board with some luck and good timing.Exactly. I had a P6T SE (flashed to P6T) which doesn't have even that much of a beefy cooling like the Deluxe seems to have, and I didn't have any problems running i7-920 @ 4.2GHz without any extra chipset/VRM cooling.
it's not just about longevity,2500k wasn't especially outstandings as far as longevity goes.
it's more about what performance it offered at the price point it was released.
but when it lanuched it could handle high end gpus flawlessly,to the point there was just no real need for i7.
now you want to max out a 2080Ti on a 165hz display you need a friggin 9900K.
I think not. It will be in a few Xeon SKUs to start with and that's it.
As an aside, I see a few posts asking "how good is the X570 chipset for overclocking?" - I don't think the chipset has ANY bearing on this, it's the quality of the board and UEFI that determines that, the chipset is just a fancy peripheral hub with integrated PCIe switch, it's no different than plugging a card in a slot, it just takes 4 lanes from the CPU and connects "a bunch of stuff" to it. It doesn't actually do anything to the CPU settings/clocks etc.
I think is pretty clear the winner here, 4 cores 8 threads in 2008 and at $284.
But I hope that AMD will keep it's value alternatives with the B550 (or whatever they call the B450 replacement) with cheap price and keeping the overclocking feature available for the mass unlike Intel.
www.anandtech.com/show/14490/gigabyte-unveils-its-x570-aorus-pro-with-or-without-wi-fi-6
I guess b450 at $50 will be the only choice, saving around $200 to buy a better cpu.
NewEgg are taking the piss I think?
www.overclockers.co.uk/asrock-x470-taichi-amd-x470-socket-am4-ddr4-atx-motherboard-mb-167-ak.html
www.overclockers.co.uk/asrock-x470-taichi-ultimate-amd-x470-socket-am4-ddr4-atx-motherboard-mb-168-ak.html
£40 difference.
Also notice the price drops? Making room for X570 stock?
They also posted "Ideal for gen 3 Ryzen" for their 4500MHz RAM kit ....
www.overclockers.co.uk/team-group-xtreem-8pack-edition-16gb-2x8gb-ddr4-pc4-36000c18-4500mhz-dual-channel-kit-black-my-09a-tg.html
Interesting times. :)
Did you read down to the CPU compatibility ? No AMD mentioned there ;) We can always hope.
This really shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone. PCIe 4.0 requires higher PCB quality (likely through more layers) than 3.0 to ensure signal integrity, as well as redrivers driving up the BOM. Same goes for RAM traces if motherboard makers want to compete in the >4000MT/s RAM space. Then there's the cost of a large-die chipset that includes a PCIe 4.0 switch. X570 will be more expensive than previous AM4 X*70 series across the board - and that's fine, as it brings a lot to the table.
Hopefully when B550 launches it's a selectively stripped-down option that allows for cheaper boards - ideally maintaining rough feature parity but moving down to a PCIe 3.0 switch - even with less lanes that would still be useful, and a lot cheaper to produce. You'd still get PCIe 4.0 through the PCIe_x16_0 slot and the first m.2 slot (unless motherboard makers screw up the traces entirely), but cut pretty much every other element driving up prices of X570 boards.I see forward compatibility as the main reason to go X570. Even if I am - despite my best intentions when buying my 1600X - planning to upgrade to an X570 setup a scant two years after my last go around, most people buying a motherboard+CPU combo today ought to plan to keep it for 4 years at the very least (heck, I kept my last setup for 8!). (Also, part of the reason I'm upgrading again is that last time around had me quite budget-limited, and this time around I can go balls-to-the-wall, which will be great for longevity.) AMD has given CPU performance a surprise jolt these past few years, but performance increases are going to flatten out very soon. In 3-4 years, PCIe 4.0 SSDs will be ubiquitous, as will GPUs, and a 3700X (or even a 3600!) is still going to be a good CPU. The main gain of X570 isn't necessarily per-device bandwidth, but total bandwidth and thus the total amount of connectable high-speed devices. It's rather obvious that we'll start seeing PCIe 4.0 x2 SSDs in the coming years, likely at prices somewhere in between current x2 and x4 drives (if not lower as flash prices keep dropping). That makes them a no-brainer for adding storage over time - no real performance sacrifice, but cheaper than x4 drives, and hopefully you'll be able to connect more.There, fixed it for you. Only the increase in PCB layers is universal. 10GbE is definitely staying a premium option given that controller chips alone are $50 or more. Those VRM layouts are flagship boards only. And there have been quite a few boards shown off without WiFi.11W was the number consistently given by both AMD and partner reps at the AMD event - though sources like that are rarely specifically named and sure don't leave a paper trail. It seems somewhat unclear whether this is average power or max TDP - some have stated one, some the other (with 15W being named the max in the cases where 11W is said to be average). In any case, the TDP is supposed to be slightly lower than the EPYC version of the chipset, but not much, and reportedly it won't throttle down significantly when not in use.Server and datacenter only. Likely only the >3000-pin socket designs to begin with too (Xeon Scalable, if I understand their naming correctly), with it possibly trickling down to lower-end Xeon (>2000-pin sockets), HEDT and consumers over the coming years - but there's little reason to expect that to be a quick process. If PCIe 4.0 is driving up motherboard costs, 5.0 will be an utter nightmare.m.2 WiFi cards are usually in the $20 range, pretty much regardless of the standard and performance. PCIe AICs are much more expensive, simply because that's seen as a retail part and is thus sold at "consumer-facing" prices, while the m.2 cards do the same job (arguably more, as PCIe AICs usually don't have bluetooth) but at off-brand/replacement part prices.
What I find interesting is that they're all calling it Intel AX200, when the AX200 is a CNVi part that only works on Intel's newest chipsets - AFAIK, the regular m.2 PCIe version is called the AX201 (at least according to various regulatory agencies) but has yet to be officially launched. I suppose they might have stealth launched it and ditched the differentiated naming - it's pretty much the same product, after all.
And I dont like to pay to Dollar for board in 2019 which dont have Type-C front header.
AMD's gross margins are at 40%.
Intel/Nvidia's at 60%, on top of having times bigger market shares.
AMD must earn more, to be viable long term. R&D isn't free.
It could have the slots moved around a bit and the colour scheme is definitely "not ideal".
I think you are reading too much into the way people phrase things.