Wednesday, November 18th 2026
Sony Defeats UK PlayStation Store Lawsuit With Help From Physical Discs
London's Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) unanimously dismissed the £1.97 billion ($2.6 billion) class action lawsuit against Sony on November 17, according to The Game Business. As a result, 12.2 million UK PlayStation users won't receive a payout. The claim was filed by consumer rights advocate Alex Neill in August 2022, accusing Sony of abusing a near-monopoly over digital PlayStation games and add-ons. He added that Sony funnels every purchase through the PlayStation Store, where it takes a 30% commission. The case went to trial back in March, and it covered everyone who bought digital PlayStation content in the UK between August 2016 and February 2026. Sony, however, came out on top on every issue.
The tribunal rejected the argument that PlayStation owners are trapped in a market of their own. It argued that Sony competes in a "systems market" with other players like Xbox, Nintendo, and PC, with physical games also acting as a real alternative to the PlayStation Store. That last bit is quite interesting, to say the least, since Sony is actively phasing out physical disc production by 2028, moving to an all-digital future. It is ironic that the very medium that Sony is moving away from has helped it win a class-action lawsuit. The tribunal found that Sony wasn't dominant in any relevant market, and Neill couldn't show that Sony's margins were excessive, since console makers often sell their hardware at thin margins and rely on software sales to earn it back.Sony will also not be forced to let any rival storefronts onto its consoles, since the tribunal ruled it a security risk and noted that competition law places no such obligation on Sony. Although Sony won this round, this isn't the only class-action lawsuit against it. It still faces several similar class actions in Australia, the Netherlands, and Portugal, though those are at earlier stages. Alex Neill is also reportedly considering an appeal.
Sources:
The Game Business, via Insider Gaming
The tribunal rejected the argument that PlayStation owners are trapped in a market of their own. It argued that Sony competes in a "systems market" with other players like Xbox, Nintendo, and PC, with physical games also acting as a real alternative to the PlayStation Store. That last bit is quite interesting, to say the least, since Sony is actively phasing out physical disc production by 2028, moving to an all-digital future. It is ironic that the very medium that Sony is moving away from has helped it win a class-action lawsuit. The tribunal found that Sony wasn't dominant in any relevant market, and Neill couldn't show that Sony's margins were excessive, since console makers often sell their hardware at thin margins and rely on software sales to earn it back.Sony will also not be forced to let any rival storefronts onto its consoles, since the tribunal ruled it a security risk and noted that competition law places no such obligation on Sony. Although Sony won this round, this isn't the only class-action lawsuit against it. It still faces several similar class actions in Australia, the Netherlands, and Portugal, though those are at earlier stages. Alex Neill is also reportedly considering an appeal.


1 Comment on Sony Defeats UK PlayStation Store Lawsuit With Help From Physical Discs