Friday, September 4th 2015

AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not

There won't be a Radeon R9 Nano review on TechPowerUp. AMD says that it has too few review samples for the press. When AMD first held up the Radeon R9 Nano at its "Fiji" GPU unveil, to us it came across as the most promising product based on the chip, even more than the R9 Fury series, its dual-GPU variant, and the food-processor-shaped SFF gaming desktop thing. The prospect of "faster than R9 290X at 175W" is what excited us the most, as that would disrupt NVIDIA's GM204 based products. Unfortunately, the most exciting product by AMD also has the least amount of excitement by AMD itself.

The first signs of that are, AMD making it prohibitively expensive at $650, and not putting it in the hands of the press, for a launch-day review. We're not getting one, and nor do some of our friends on either sides of the Atlantic. AMD is making some of its tallest claims with this product, and it's important (for AMD) that some of those claims are put to the test. A validated product could maybe even convince some to reach for their wallets, to pull out $650.
Are we sourgraping? You tell us. We're one of the few sites that give you noise testing by some really expensive and broad-ranged noise-testing equipment, and more importantly, card-only power-draw. Our reviews also grill graphics cards through 22 real-world tests across four resolutions, each, and offer price-performance graphs. When NVIDIA didn't send us a GeForce GTX TITAN-Z sample, we didn't care. We didn't make an announcement like this. At $2,999, it was just a terrible product and we never wished it was part of our graphs. Its competing R9 295X2 could be had under $700, and so it continues to top our performance charts.

The R9 Nano, on the other hand, has the potential for greatness. Never mind the compact board design and its SFF credentials. Pull out this ASIC, put it on a normal 20-25 cm PCB, price it around $350, and dual-slot cooling that can turn its fans off in idle, and AMD could have had a GM204-killing product. Sadly, there's no way for us to test that, either. We can't emulate an R9 Nano on an R9 Fury X. The Nano appears to have a unique power/temperature based throttling algorithm that we can't copy.

"Fiji" is a good piece of technology, but apparently, very little effort is being made to put it into the hands of as many people as possible (and by that we mean consumers). This is an incoherence between what AMD CEO stated at the "Fiji" unveil, and what her company is doing. It's also great disservice to the people who probably stayed up many nights to get the interposer design right, or sailing through uncharted territory with HBM. Oh well.
Add your own comment

759 Comments on AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not

#727
the54thvoid
Super Moderator
W1zzard
Back :)

AMD is sending a card on Monday, and I also bought a Sapphire retail card for €699, which will be sent off on Monday too.
Wow - crazy meat mouse and wooden mouse mat combo - must be German designed.
Posted on Reply
#728
Aquinus
Resident Wat-man
W1zzardAMD is sending a card on Monday
I see that 30 pages later AMD finally came to their senses. :laugh:
W1zzardI also bought a Sapphire retail card for €699, which will be sent off on Monday too.
Ohhhh, so we can even find out if they cherry picked the review samples too, right. ;)

I think I speak for most of the people here when I say, thank you (and everyone else at TPU,) for everything you all do. :lovetpu:
Posted on Reply
#729
nem
W1zzard
Back :)

AMD is sending a card on Monday, and I also bought a Sapphire retail card for €699, which will be sent off on Monday too.
come on wizzard dont be too much hard with nano , micro$hit is aproachin to buy AMD this time the rummosr looks very real.. :/
Posted on Reply
#730
john_
W1zzardAMD is sending a card on Monday, and I also bought a Sapphire retail card for €699, which will be sent off on Monday too.
Did you just said "CrossFire"?
Posted on Reply
#732
HumanSmoke
the54thvoidWow - crazy meat mouse and wooden mouse mat combo - must be German designed.
:laugh:

The chef in me is impressed that W1zz uses J.A. Henckels knives - as do I
Posted on Reply
#733
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
Is the blue speckle surface the island in your kitchen? That counter top is different. Since AMD didnt send us a sample lets talk about interior design now.
Posted on Reply
#734
remixedcat
what about interior crocodile alligators? and chevorlet movie theaters?

Posted on Reply
#735
Recus
Roy deleted his Twitter acc (amd_roy). lol
Posted on Reply
#736
remixedcat
RecusRoy deleted his Twitter acc (amd_roy). lol


amd prolly fired his sorry ass and I hope they did
Posted on Reply
#737
Aquinus
Resident Wat-man
remixedcat
remixedcatamd prolly fired his sorry ass and I hope they did
You know better than to double post. I know you know where the edit button it. :)

On topic: I suspect he has been sullying AMD's reputation in the last couple of weeks so badly that Lisa probably told him to leave the PR to the PR department.

Needless to say, his douche-baggery was uncalled for and he should be fired as a result or, at the very least, demoted. He hasn't exactly been helping AMD lately... that's for sure.
Posted on Reply
#738
john_
RecusRoy deleted his Twitter acc (amd_roy). lol
I believe Lisa Su deleted his Twitter account.

PS I also wonder if they forced him to pay for the card w1z is getting.
Posted on Reply
#739
remixedcat
AquinusYou know better than to double post. I know you know where the edit button it. :)

On topic: I suspect he has been sullying AMD's reputation in the last couple of weeks so badly that Lisa probably told him to leave the PR to the PR department.

Needless to say, his douche-baggery was uncalled for and he should be fired as a result or, at the very least, demoted. He hasn't exactly been helping AMD lately... that's for sure.
I was on my tablet sorrry yo!! hahahaha
Posted on Reply
#740
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
AquinusOhhhh, so we can even find out if they cherry picked the review samples too, right. ;)
Also CrossFire review (which will be interesting because I expect dual-Fiji card to have chips of the same power-tuning as the one on Nano).
Posted on Reply
#741
Tsukiyomi91
wow... that Roy guy deleted his Twitter profile... really smart move from a whack job like him... I don't think the CEO delete his account unless it's handled by the company OR his password is just way too easy to crack.
Posted on Reply
#742
alucasa
The dude said one thing right tho.

"Reviews need to be fair."

Except, well, ... you know where this is going, so I will leave this at that.
Posted on Reply
#743
qubit
Overclocked quantum bit
@btarunr Now the review is actually up, I suggest either updating the article with the review link and a few words to explain how it came about, or deleting the whole thread, otherwise it's contradictory and looks silly remaining here.
Posted on Reply
#744
Xzibit
A contest should be held to hand out awards

Best over reaction post

Best supporting over reaction post

Most dramatic post

Most personaly effected post

Best IDK WTH he just typed post

Best off-topic post

Etc...
Posted on Reply
#745
remixedcat
no, keep the post for historical preservation.... to show how the company turned itself around....
Posted on Reply
#746
HumanSmoke
XzibitA contest should be held to hand out awards

Best over reaction post

Best supporting over reaction post

Most dramatic post

Most personaly effected post

Best IDK WTH he just typed post

Best off-topic post

Etc...
It's a pity you added the last category, or Roy Taylor would be in line for a clean sweep.
/no jk
Posted on Reply
#747
qubit
Overclocked quantum bit
XzibitA contest should be held to hand out awards

Best over reaction post

Best supporting over reaction post

Most dramatic post

Most personaly effected post

Best IDK WTH he just typed post

Best off-topic post

Etc...
rofl I love it! :roll:
Posted on Reply
#748
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
qubit@btarunr Now the review is actually up, I suggest either updating the article with the review link and a few words to explain how it came about, or deleting the whole thread, otherwise it's contradictory and looks silly remaining here.
No, this thread is a monument to AMD's mishandling of the situation. It has the full sanction of TPU, so it stays.

Fun fact though: The letter informing us that a sample is en route roughly coincided with a top AMD exec deleting his Twitter account.
Posted on Reply
#749
qubit
Overclocked quantum bit
btarunrNo, this thread is a monument to AMD's mishandling of the situation. It has the full sanction of TPU, so it stays.

Fun fact though: The letter informing us that a sample is en route roughly coincided with a top AMD exec deleting his Twitter account.
OK, I can see why you want to keep the article up and I don't have an issue with that.

In that case, it just seems prudent to me to put a short update to say you got the card in the end (with a review link) and perhaps a little background on how this came about.

Just my 2 cents. :)
Posted on Reply
#750
rtwjunkie
PC Gaming Enthusiast
qubitOK, I can see why you want to keep the article up and I don't have an issue with that.

In that case, it just seems prudent to me to put a short update to say you got the card in the end (with a review link) and perhaps a little background on how this came about.

Just my 2 cents. :)
I think this is a very good idea! This keeps it historical, and also would point to the review link for people arriving from a search at this article.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 17th, 2026 18:15 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts