Friday, September 4th 2015
AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not
There won't be a Radeon R9 Nano review on TechPowerUp. AMD says that it has too few review samples for the press. When AMD first held up the Radeon R9 Nano at its "Fiji" GPU unveil, to us it came across as the most promising product based on the chip, even more than the R9 Fury series, its dual-GPU variant, and the food-processor-shaped SFF gaming desktop thing. The prospect of "faster than R9 290X at 175W" is what excited us the most, as that would disrupt NVIDIA's GM204 based products. Unfortunately, the most exciting product by AMD also has the least amount of excitement by AMD itself.
The first signs of that are, AMD making it prohibitively expensive at $650, and not putting it in the hands of the press, for a launch-day review. We're not getting one, and nor do some of our friends on either sides of the Atlantic. AMD is making some of its tallest claims with this product, and it's important (for AMD) that some of those claims are put to the test. A validated product could maybe even convince some to reach for their wallets, to pull out $650.Are we sourgraping? You tell us. We're one of the few sites that give you noise testing by some really expensive and broad-ranged noise-testing equipment, and more importantly, card-only power-draw. Our reviews also grill graphics cards through 22 real-world tests across four resolutions, each, and offer price-performance graphs. When NVIDIA didn't send us a GeForce GTX TITAN-Z sample, we didn't care. We didn't make an announcement like this. At $2,999, it was just a terrible product and we never wished it was part of our graphs. Its competing R9 295X2 could be had under $700, and so it continues to top our performance charts.
The R9 Nano, on the other hand, has the potential for greatness. Never mind the compact board design and its SFF credentials. Pull out this ASIC, put it on a normal 20-25 cm PCB, price it around $350, and dual-slot cooling that can turn its fans off in idle, and AMD could have had a GM204-killing product. Sadly, there's no way for us to test that, either. We can't emulate an R9 Nano on an R9 Fury X. The Nano appears to have a unique power/temperature based throttling algorithm that we can't copy.
"Fiji" is a good piece of technology, but apparently, very little effort is being made to put it into the hands of as many people as possible (and by that we mean consumers). This is an incoherence between what AMD CEO stated at the "Fiji" unveil, and what her company is doing. It's also great disservice to the people who probably stayed up many nights to get the interposer design right, or sailing through uncharted territory with HBM. Oh well.
The first signs of that are, AMD making it prohibitively expensive at $650, and not putting it in the hands of the press, for a launch-day review. We're not getting one, and nor do some of our friends on either sides of the Atlantic. AMD is making some of its tallest claims with this product, and it's important (for AMD) that some of those claims are put to the test. A validated product could maybe even convince some to reach for their wallets, to pull out $650.Are we sourgraping? You tell us. We're one of the few sites that give you noise testing by some really expensive and broad-ranged noise-testing equipment, and more importantly, card-only power-draw. Our reviews also grill graphics cards through 22 real-world tests across four resolutions, each, and offer price-performance graphs. When NVIDIA didn't send us a GeForce GTX TITAN-Z sample, we didn't care. We didn't make an announcement like this. At $2,999, it was just a terrible product and we never wished it was part of our graphs. Its competing R9 295X2 could be had under $700, and so it continues to top our performance charts.
The R9 Nano, on the other hand, has the potential for greatness. Never mind the compact board design and its SFF credentials. Pull out this ASIC, put it on a normal 20-25 cm PCB, price it around $350, and dual-slot cooling that can turn its fans off in idle, and AMD could have had a GM204-killing product. Sadly, there's no way for us to test that, either. We can't emulate an R9 Nano on an R9 Fury X. The Nano appears to have a unique power/temperature based throttling algorithm that we can't copy.
"Fiji" is a good piece of technology, but apparently, very little effort is being made to put it into the hands of as many people as possible (and by that we mean consumers). This is an incoherence between what AMD CEO stated at the "Fiji" unveil, and what her company is doing. It's also great disservice to the people who probably stayed up many nights to get the interposer design right, or sailing through uncharted territory with HBM. Oh well.

759 Comments on AMD Radeon R9 Nano Review by TPU...Not
Idk if it still goes on now but it was happening frequently, it got to the point admins asked him to tone it down...was still tolerated though. The thing was it was so obvious as to be funny...lol
Why and by what standards AMD is choosing its reviewers, is speculation at this point. Perhaps give AMD the opportunity to comment? I am sure the decisions are not made lightly.
Calling for the removal of Dr. Lisa Su also seems absurd, she hasn't even been CEO for 1 year (1 year this October). Unreasonable expectations that she could do a complete turn around of a company in 11 months when development cycles can take in excess of 5 years. My 2 cents anyway.
Shame as there are a lot of very nice members on the site.....if it was irl I'd call them my friends. :)
Many users here have shitloads of money to blow. When a nano is bought they will post benches regardless.
So why worry...
I could sit at my desk and read an entire thread without going to the forum This means a lot of the members don't show up as traffic.
On a good day there are about 100 members on the forum 700 guests and 4500 for the site... TPU is great but the forum is def not as busy as Guru's forum, I don't know about the main site though.
Not trying to argue, just putting things into perspective. :) TBh Hilbert said the forum only just broke even....wasn't really a priority for him afaik..... Maybe it's the same for wiz?
Why worry? Fuck ups like this is more proof AMD is going in the crapper and that's not what anyone needs.
The nano was the only interesting card based off Fiji, at the price of a 980ti it was dead on arrival in my eyes anyway.
At this point it seems console chips are the only thing keeping AMD from bankruptcy, their CPU's haven't competed with anything since the core series launched and the only GPU's they have worth buying are 3 year old cards that can deliver acceptable performance for their price 7970/7950
By the time DX12 becomes relevant Nvidia will have new cards out that will walk all over AMD like they currently do in DX11.
Sincerely, an AMD fanboy.
Fury X: $550
Fury: $450
R9 Nano: $400
imo
NVIDIA just waiting when will AMD again come in such big problems when they can easily bought this knowledge. Some developers will jump to another ship and AMD has developed new technology for NVIDIA without gratitude but for breadcrumbs. NVIDIA to the largest customer behave disrespectful and sells scrap cutout processor as best gameing product, and many do not even know it. Horror
Either way, we are neck-and-neck often. And I'm talking using Amazon's metrics, not our own, which may be far different.
if amds marketing team continues with tactics like this, they will be no different from the nvidia marketing team moves
very fishy moves, shiet will hit the fan if there is something wrong with the cards, and people will find out, sooner or later, this kind of moves only delay the blow
At the same time, AMD doesn't sell cards directly... their board partners do. SO the idea that AMD doesn't have stock makes a lot of sense, since all ASICs are going to meet orders by those board partners... probably direct from whomever is assembling the packages. AMD probably doesn't get any dies themselves other than what they already had on-hand.
The sites they have chosen to give cards to, who cares? The point of the news post is educational... you guys want our review, but we will not have one. So on launch day, please go look at other sites for reviews. No big deal, and this saves us having to deal with all of this on launch day.
Why not TPU? How about our lack of a social media presence, and lack of youtube presence? That's enough reason...
I would expect them to do the same as HardOCP, but that does not mean they will. They don't have to. So I asked the question hoping for a confirmation.
The content of the reviews are good, but the TPU rating system and such is often crap. If a product has a major issue, it should reflect greatly in the score and also not garner a recommendation.
That being said, it really shows how desperate they are to try to make any money they possible can. They had to launch as early as possible and sell of anything they could to try to generate some cash.