Friday, March 28th 2025
SMIC Reportedly On Track to Finalize 5 nm Process in 2025, Projected to Cost 40-50% More Than TSMC Equivalent
According to a report produced by semiconductor industry analysts at Kiwoom Securities—a South Korean financial services firm—Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC) is expected to complete the development of a 5 nm process at some point in 2025. Jukanlosreve summarized this projection in a recent social media post. SMIC is often considered to be China's flagship foundry business; the partially state-owned organization seems to heavily involved in the production of (rumored) next-gen Huawei Ascend 910 AI accelerators. SMIC foundry employees have reportedly struggled to break beyond a 7 nm manufacturing barrier, due to lack of readily accessible cutting-edge EUV equipment. As covered on TechPowerUp last month, leading lights within China's semiconductor industry are (allegedly) developing lithography solutions for cutting-edge 5 nm and 3 nm wafer production.
Huawei is reportedly evaluating an in-house developed laser-induced discharge plasma (LDP)-based machine, but finalized equipment will not be ready until 2026—at least for mass production purposes. Jukanlosreve's short interpretation of Kiwoom's report reads as follows: (SMIC) achieved mass production of the 7 nm (N+2) process without EUV and completed the development of the 5 nm process to support the mass production of the Huawei Ascend 910C. The cost of SMIC's 5 nm process is 40-50% higher than TSMC's, and its yield is roughly one-third." The nation's foundries are reliant on older ASML equipment, thus are unable to produce products that can compete with the advanced (volume and quality) output of "global" TSMC and Samsung chip manufacturing facilities. The fresh unveiling of SiCarrier's Color Mountain series has signalled a promising new era for China's foundry industry.
Sources:
Jukanlosreve Tweet, Wccftech, TrendForce, DigiTimes Asia, TechWire Asia (image source)
Huawei is reportedly evaluating an in-house developed laser-induced discharge plasma (LDP)-based machine, but finalized equipment will not be ready until 2026—at least for mass production purposes. Jukanlosreve's short interpretation of Kiwoom's report reads as follows: (SMIC) achieved mass production of the 7 nm (N+2) process without EUV and completed the development of the 5 nm process to support the mass production of the Huawei Ascend 910C. The cost of SMIC's 5 nm process is 40-50% higher than TSMC's, and its yield is roughly one-third." The nation's foundries are reliant on older ASML equipment, thus are unable to produce products that can compete with the advanced (volume and quality) output of "global" TSMC and Samsung chip manufacturing facilities. The fresh unveiling of SiCarrier's Color Mountain series has signalled a promising new era for China's foundry industry.



14 Comments on SMIC Reportedly On Track to Finalize 5 nm Process in 2025, Projected to Cost 40-50% More Than TSMC Equivalent
i wonder if the dutch government in the best Mob Boss voice says to the US ” forget about Greenland, or no ASML machines…“ or ” say hello to my little friend, tariffs! Big wonderful 25% tariffs! lol”
China cannot get an export license from the dutch for ASML machines, due to trade sanctions. Thats why they have invested so much in SMIC.
As a reminder, 2 years ago everyone said they'd never manage 28nm tech. now they are doing 5nm. Where do you think they are going next?
We secretly create a deal we benefit from, and then turn around and tell everyone how hard life is and everyone should talk about it a bit more, while in the meantime, most parties get something they want.
We're creating steel the US can't do without. We create machines the US can't do without. At the same time, we depend on them to take our steel and machines. Mutual dependancies Trump thinks he can just waltz right over and erase.
Good luck with that. So far he's achieved nothing, except trust erosion, which ultimately backfires on the US.
The China situation is different. You're looking at a country that has no freedom of speech here. I'm sure they have a fantastic 5nm process. Economically though, its dead in the water, if gov stops funding it, it doesn't exist, and on any global market, similarly, it exists as long as it gets heavily subsidized. You can't run an economy on that. The Chinese are winning in other areas because they can actually produce cheaper. This is not the case for semiconductors.Prestige and 'look, we can do this ourselves FU' positioning. Its the same backwards imperial thought process as what you're seeing Trump copycat now. And it can actually work for quite a while. Until the empire inevitably falls.
Knowing that the politics is a diversion from the rest of this, let's focus on the actual OP topic. China rolls out a new 5nm process using something that isn't EUV. Cool. On paper, sounds great. That is, until you know that the yields are garbage, and despite the hugely cheaper labor costs you are still working at 40% higher costs. That scream to me that how they did the math is...potentially damning. If the yields are 1/3, and the cost is 40% higher, you have a 67% loss and a 40% price increase. Taken separate, it's 40% increase in cost per unit. Taken together, it's 3.0*1.4 = 420% = a 320% increase in net price per unit of silicon. It's relatively easy to see this being the case with multiple passes of DUV, a practice that the west does not do because of the degraded yields...but it has the benefits of not requiring EUV.
Mix that with a political fluff piece on new technologies that are not viable, and you have an excellent little article that seems like China is amazing, while mathematically demonstrating that they are dying without the ability to steal technology. That's...a lot less rosy of a picture than the CCP would like to share...but if you mask it is East vs. West, and a century of shame rhetoric, it goes down much smoother.
The west, and by that I mean anyone who chose protected capitalism like Taiwan, instead respects laws. The US develops technology. It farms out production of said tech to the Dutch. The Dutch pay for access to the technology, and create machines. Machines are sold to manufacturers. Manufacturers produce goods...often based on patented designs also from the US. The money that was used to research the technology is respected by the Dutch, so the US and Netherlands both walk out of the deal better off. They respect each other's patents, which are legal monopolies, so that everyone gets to profit. Since both countries respect each other's laws, there's no issue.
You then get China. They break exclusivity contracts. They steal technology. They replicate things without understanding them, then use their advantages to compete on the world stage by simply undercutting everyone on price...including their own countrymen by producing even worse versions of everything. I...respect only that China is uniquely capable of driving out everything that costs anything from a process....often at the expense of producing dangerous or otherwise damaging goods. Consider that it was the Chinese who discovered you could fake the protein levels in formula by adding melamine...never mind that pesky kidney issues and death.
So...I believe China has a 5 nm process. I believe that it's so wasteful that it'll never produce commercially viable products. I believe most of China's failures are exactly because of this...they put perceived value well in advance of materials value and durability. I have heard jokes that US cars suck, because they produce so few horsepower per engine displacement. I have also seen them start at -40 (F and C agree at this point), up to 140 F. I've watched a eurotrash automobile that absolutely curb stomps the US version's horsepower be unable to take heavy rain...something that I qualify as rain so thick that you cannot see more than 200' ahead of you on the highway...and the high powered little eurobox basically couldn't take the downpour. I have also watched Chinese electric vehicles with dashboard size monitors and screens, that the teen crowd adore, basically decide to crap out because it was snowing. I've watched the same little Chinese vehicles basically disappear into a cloud of powdered iron oxide because after 3 years without galvanization and proper rust protection they are simply rusted from the core out...while a crapbox blazer from 1998 lasted into 2021 before the thing was totaled. Said crapbox ran between -40 to 120 degrees, rain, snow, sleet, and it protected the idiot who destroyed it by absorbing a 45 mph impact into a tree. Something that I wouldn't wish on my enemies in a new Chinese EV....because it'd be like wishing them dead. Sometimes, running the cost out of everything by building without cost and by stealing technology isn't the way to do it...but that's not how the CCP rolls.
It would serve all politicians well to start telling also the inconvenient truth, including the fact some issues are perhaps not entirely fixable, or take a long term investment. In a way this makes the above remarkably on topic. China's deep into a similar alternate reality that they hope materializes as long as they try hard enough and scream loud enough.
On the subject of China's inner workings... we agree entirely - something's gonna give. A fact that applies to everything that is based on bullshit.
All of this is beside the final point. It's an industry that China is using in their political games. If you understand anything about the history between opium, the west, and China you'd see that this is....something they may secretly be enjoying. The Opium wars was Great Britain being immensely crappy to China, and for those who cannot forgive history it has to be interesting to see the people "who wronged you" being wronged in the same ways. This is why they also "have 5nm processes." If they can fake it, even in a losing process, then they can theoretically outlast the west until they can steal it. Ideally, they might even make it rather than steal it...but that's not necessary. Just as long as they can extend their power, and have the west pretending that the rhetoric about being at war with them is "a joke," progress can be made.
Back to the topic of 5nm, I think you're also right about that indeed. Its a political instrument more than anything else.