Monday, April 7th 2025
Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
Following last week's jam-packed Switch 2 presentation, Nintendo staffers engaged in conversation with media outlets. To the surprise of many, a high level member of the incoming console's design team was quite comfortable with his name-dropping of NVIDIA graphics technologies. Meanwhile, Team Green was tasked with the disclosing of Switch 2's "internal" workings. Attention has turned to the much anticipated-hybrid console's bundled-in detachable Joy-Cons—in the lead up to official unveilings, online debates swirled around potential next-gen controllers being upgraded with Hall Effect joystick modules. Many owners of first-gen Switch systems have expressed frustration regarding faulty Joy-Cons—eventually, Nintendo was coerced into offering free repairs for customers affected by dreaded "stick drift" issues. Unfortunately, it seems that the House of Mario has not opted to outfit its Gen 2.0 Joy-Cons with popular "anti-drift" tech.
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.
Sources:
Nintendo Life, The Verge (image source), VGC, Nintendo Life (full interview)
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.



122 Comments on Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
I never realized the goatse thing (and to be honest, have never looked up the origin of Bungie; it's just something most people likely myself are vaguely aware is not named for the strap), but that is funny.
And The Duke, well the The Duke is just The Duke; just thought that lined up well.
I think it's named that simply because
It's freaking enormous.....(*Reads actual wiki article*)....apparently because it was the Project Manager's son's name....But I do think it helped popularize dual analogue the way we use it today (especially in console FPS bc of Halo). Obviously it wasn't the first, though.
(IMO)
N64 helped popularize and 'prompt' the standard for analog stick(s) on game controllers.
PS1's Analog DualShock dual-stick design became the DeFacto standard for late-PSX (and PS2->) era games.
Sega Dreamcast attempted to branch out on what N64 established.
XBOX OG took what Sega and Sony had brought to market, and created a 'concurrent standard' layout [Sony-PlayStation DualShock and MSFT-XBOX layouts]
I don't know if I ever had a DS1; think I just had a standard. I had to have though...no way I played RE without sticks...I don't think? Hmm. Now I'm going to have to go dig through my attic bc it will bug me. :p
All I know is my PS1 probably still has the spring to in it to fool the loader so I could swap cd-r's. If I had to guess, it's probably in a box with one of my old Plextor drives. How's that for nostalgia?
Are you done complaining about something that doesn't and will not matter?OOooo, clever.... not.Not here. There were so many things wrong with the N64, the controller was one of them. Sure, it was comfortable, but it was also cumbersome, unsymmetrical and just looked goofy. It was as bad as the Genesis/Megadrive/Saturn controllers.
Both of those problems are entirely more concerning and yet they're whining about controller drift, a problem that was not as widespread as many think & solved years ago and screen type, which isn't a problem at all. If they want to be taken seriously, they need to complain about real problems instead of whining like overgrown tantrum throwers.
The screen with switch is an add-on feature that you can play it as a handheld but that does not mean I have to do it no matter what. It is an option you can play as a handheld which is convenience. That does not diminish the fact, it looks better on a TV and OLED screen is pointless in my opinion because of it's flaws, you will have to play on a TV at some point with no other option.
For me, the handheld option is a bonus. For my kids, they dont care as long as they can play. They don't care if it is an OLED screen or whatever screen.So basically, you dont own the game but rather you can download it with the key you have purchased. Hmm, not sure what to think about it, maybe it is a measure for the copy rights. If you have the full game files you can crack it and use emulator later on. If you have only game files when you download, it wont be that easy?
Nintendo knows the absence of HE isn't going to stop any potential Switch buyers.
Nintendo knows HE lasts far longer.
You don't need to be a spreadsheet hero to figure out the potential for profit here. Are they really that nasty? Of course they are, wake the F up! This is business 101There is a term for this
Whataboutism
Beyond that, you don't get to decide what problems are relevant and which are not. Its clear as day why Nintendo is pushing inferior joycons. So they can sell more. No need to sugar coat this with nonsense either way. If you buy this device, you now also know that it comes with subpar sticks that might fail and prompt either a return under warranty or replacement on your own expense. Those are the facts. Everything else, is emotion - both your misplaced trust when there are clearly better alternatives (and the resulting conclusion 'it is just fine', is just as misplaced as a result); as well as the crocodile tears of those that say it should come with HE sticks, while they are still going to buy the console. They're just hypocrites that accept a bad deal while they want something better - the end result ain't gonna be that you get what you want, obviously, because you're funding the polar opposite ;)
And yes, purposefully creating more E-waste by shortening the life cycle of products and prompting more replacements is definitely nasty. The fact we consider it normal only goes to show how detached we are from any rational thought, because of how blind we are/choose to be as consumers.Pot, meet kettle... :toast:
My points of argument have tangible consequences to the end user.Not at all. Effective is what works, by definition. I when in exactly the correct direction.You, like others in this discussion, are fixated on a problem that no longer exists, hasn't existed for a number of years and will not come about again because it's been engineered out.You're absolutely right. Including a screen with a known defect will result in E-waste when people start throwing their systems with burned in screens in the rubbish bin. So Nintendo did right on that choice.
It amounts to a lot of hand waving at nothing and crying over spilled milk than has long since been cleaned up and washed away.
A lot of people do care about the sticks, but Nintendo knows they can save a few cents to keep profit margins higher and the fans will still defend them for it. HE joysticks are dirt cheap, there is no reason for them not to use more durable sticks on the Switch 2.That isn't saying much with how slow the first Switch was.The Steam Deck is a PC, and it's cheaper than a Switch 2.Discussing a real problem isn't whining, but anyone who disagrees with you must be a "Nintendo hater".
What is the Nintendo's MSRP, how did the MSRP's look like for previous Nintendo products over a decade and how the current release's MSRP stacks against current consoles MSRPs?
That is what I want to hear exactly and argumentatively explained. Not just simple the price is too high for what it offers.
Shame, really, the way you try so desperately to be right that its clear as day you haven't got anything.
I wasn't talking about the problem, I was asking about you knowing its no longer a problem. What did you base that on? A design change. So where is it? Since you know, you know... Now you're just underlining you don't know anything at all, its just coming straight out of your ass.
As for it supposedly not being something that exists, okay, here you go
nl.ifixit.com/Guide/How+to+Fix+Joy-Con+Drift+Without+Disassembly/147338
Joy-Con drift may occur as you use the Joy-Cons over time from dust and debris building up. You do not need to disassemble the Joy-Con for this repair. In addition, this guide will not corrode any parts of your Joy-Con controller.
www.wikihow.com/Fix-Joy-Con-Drift
www.lifewire.com/fix-joy-con-drift-on-nintendo-switch-and-switch-lite-5074901
www.reviewed.com/gaming/features/how-fix-joy-con-drift-nintendo-switch
Need more, Mr EveryoneElseIsWrongImRight?
The NS2 does not need HE sensors, nor does it need OLED to be a quality machine. In this area Nintendo chose wisely.