Monday, April 7th 2025
Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
Following last week's jam-packed Switch 2 presentation, Nintendo staffers engaged in conversation with media outlets. To the surprise of many, a high level member of the incoming console's design team was quite comfortable with his name-dropping of NVIDIA graphics technologies. Meanwhile, Team Green was tasked with the disclosing of Switch 2's "internal" workings. Attention has turned to the much anticipated-hybrid console's bundled-in detachable Joy-Cons—in the lead up to official unveilings, online debates swirled around potential next-gen controllers being upgraded with Hall Effect joystick modules. Many owners of first-gen Switch systems have expressed frustration regarding faulty Joy-Cons—eventually, Nintendo was coerced into offering free repairs for customers affected by dreaded "stick drift" issues. Unfortunately, it seems that the House of Mario has not opted to outfit its Gen 2.0 Joy-Cons with popular "anti-drift" tech.
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.
Sources:
Nintendo Life, The Verge (image source), VGC, Nintendo Life (full interview)
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.



122 Comments on Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
From what I understand of the SOC, and Nintendo's penchant for underclocking, I expect it to be a bit more powerful than a Steam Deck in docked mode, and probably a bit less in handheld mode.
But either way, docked won't come close to a 4x performance boost over either the Steam Deck or handheld mode.
I'm curious about the CPU performance too. The Switch 1 was fairly GPU heavy, the CPU was terrible. I'm hoping the CPU is more evenly matched this time.
The Steam Deck CPU is more balanced relative to the GPU, given it's an actual AMD desktop class processor. The CPU is capable enough (just about) even in most modern games.
Furthermore, assuming that repairs/replacement parts will be somehow 'easier to come by' in volume/price and more importantly easier to install is preposterous. Valve has an official partnership with iFixit for parts replacements, not to mention the SD's massive third-party parts market. Entire shells, replacement screens, replacement buttons/joysticks, all with different features, and with easy-to-follow guides. NS2 parts will be gutted from donor devices and require either a lot of personal confidence or a professional to install.I'm tired of hearing this. Individual ergonomics are subjective. Ergonomics as a design principle are not. There are very empirical ways to make an object comfortable to handle for a given range of people. This is true of any device, tool, appliance, etc. The Steam Deck is a master class in making something comfortable to handle for a wide range of people, so much so to the point that I haven't heard a single unfavorable opinion about how it feels in the hand.
Sometimes I wonder if people just abuse the shit out of their [cheap ass plastic save a penny where you can] hardware and then are shocked when it stops working after rough treatment.
I've known more than a few people in my 40 years on Earth who just cannot manage to keep their shit from breaking, and after spending some time with them I immediately understand why...
The Ally X is a whopping £799, twice the price, and that doesn't even have an OLED.Very good point, I often wonder the same thing. I take great care of my stuff, and lo and behold, it lasts for ages and I haven't problems with any analog sticks ;)
As for the Steam deck, I haven't heard of any failures with the joysticks on it, although the SD has easily replaceable joysticks. Also despite the SD or Ally being more expensive they are also both full PC's in a handheld form factor, IMO you get much better value out of them if you want to play anything besides Nintendo games.
First of all - yes, that Resdit thread contains a shitton of link with context of the situation. Including ones to journalistic outlets you might or might not consider “worthy” of your attention. I don’t know exactly what your standards are. Just go through the thread. Or don’t. But then how about you actually provide any proof of what YOU said? Any actual proof that Nintendo fixed the Joycons? Besides them SAYING they did, of course. Maybe some independent testing and teardowns?
Secondly - I do have something else, actually. An OG Switch that is on its fourth (that’s 4th) pair of cons. The third one, previous, was one with a manufacturer date AFTER the big N assured everyone of a “fix”. It still developed drift. Again, their “it was just a defect” position was nonsense. The way the potentiometer they use works is inherently drift-prone. There is no magic that really can alleviate that. The current one is about a year in its life and is working fine, but, granted, has seen little use. I actually still have the old ones somewhere in a box, might disassemble them myself to make sure they’re the same construction-wise. Which they will be.
tl:dr - HE stick modules are cheap as chips nowadays, there is absolutely no reason no to use them, Nintendo are just being arrogant cunts, as they usually are. Switch 2 will have the same Joycon issues and they will just pretend like there are none.
You not getting it doesn't mean it doesn't happen, or that it's the users fault they use dirt cheap potentiometers. I have 25+ year old controllers that work fine after many thousands of hours of use, and I had it on the PS5 pad after maybe 50 hours of use.
giving same price for switch2 ($349), then make no reason for people to buy switch1, then they got tons of unsold left over
i personally think they should go with $379~399 though
i read one article said switch OLED only cost $10 more to produce, while retail price different between OG switch and oled is $50
Please let us know.
This type of gaslighting actually has a tendency to piss me off, because I don't know why someone would choose to side with a company versus all their customers asking for a simple fix known to work.
Maybe XB controllers are much more durable, but I'm just sayin', it ain't (usually) me. I have dropped them small distances, but unless you consider pressing the stick to run controller abuse, it's quality issues.
And I don't think most that have these issues consistently (at least w/ the Dual Shock/Senses and Nintendo pads) is their fault. Hell, my Switch pad has the right/down buttons kinda-sorta connected.
And I have barely used it (I like to think of my Switch as a 'display piece' given it's about as useful as a pocket calculator). There's awful quality control issues with all this stuff, and it's very well documented.
I think, in-fact, most (1st-party) controllers are poorly made so they will need to be replaced if used often (because if you use it often you will buy another one). The obvious answer is the right one.
Given how cheap HE is, there is literally no reason not to use it. In-fact, Sony USED to use it (iirc, at least it was something better)) and switched many consoles ago, because they didn't sell enough replacements.
Think about that. That's fucked up. Now they sell a $200 controller that doesn't use HE, but they will let you replace the shitty sticks with more shitty sticks; minimizing the intended transaction.
Sometimes people do misdirect their own problems towards companies, but this time you're really doing the opposite imho. This is truly rightful criticism, but glad yours have held up well.
If I didn't absolutely abhor the XB controller layout, which I like to blame on being left-handed, I would buy one. It appears most people (at least in this thread) have had very good luck with them.
I'm also SOL for buying a pad other than Sony, as they won't license half the features (including rumble). Someday I'll buy a modded one or something, but the prices are nuts just for asking it not to break.Yeah...Truth. I'm sorry...I just couldn't handle playing TotK at <720p and 15fps like I did BotW. And that's kind of how I feel about the S2. The controller thing is real, but you said the REAL real.
Don't get me wrong though, I wish it had an OLED. I would much rather have an OLED, than an HDR LCD screen.
As far as value, that's subjective. I have a Steam Deck and I really like it. Dual boots Windows and SteamOS. But as I have a desktop and a good laptop to work on, the desktop functionality is more of a fun novelty than anything else. And that would obviously be the case for any other Windows handheld.
But as for the Switch 2, seeing as it's the only machine that can play new Nintendo exclusives, it's much better value to me than a Windows handheld.
I can't wait for the 100s and 1000s of pages of community content on fixing, modifying, and replacing the sticks. :laugh:
Nintendo Proprietary Joystick Technology = N64 Joystick, in my mind.
Regarding N64 pads, I know I'm in the minority, but I love the N64 pad. They are fragile, but I kind of baby'd mine and they lasted for years. It was hilarious going round people's houses that mistreated them though, they were always a weird mix of stiff and floppy, crunchy, with loads of dusty residue in the analog stick housing :D
But yeah, I really like the stick, it has a certain precision to it that worked great with Mario 64. I even find it comfortable to hold, and like that it has 6 face buttons for fighting games.
One of those secrets you almost don't want to tell, in case I ever have to do it again (get something on launch without a pre-order). But it was pretty funny. Looking back I kinda just wanted to know if I could.
And I did. Lots of people didn't, because nobody ever thinks about Target. Except me. And that one rando guy, apparently. Good job rando guy. Together we beat the system.
I very much enjoyed your descriptive analysis of N64 sticks, please never do that again. :roll:
Over the years I've heard all kinds of stuff about the N64 pads; fragile; the crap travel; etc. I mean, looking back on it I suppose that's true, but at the time I didn't really think about it and thought it was great.
I never had one problem with it. I actually bought mine *before* launch day (from a very nice and/or stupid KMART employee) on that one, and everyone came over to my pad (or I brought it to theirs).
So maybe *I* was the one with the crunchy sticks (and nobody told me)! I don't know. Like I say, mine still work fine AFAIK, and I agree, it actually worked pretty well for MK3U etc. Obviously Mario felt tight.
I'm sure if I went back to it I would notice it's flaws compared to common designs now, but I seriously only have fond memories of playing Stack/Golden Gun and it feeling great with that ol' Cougar Magnum.
In fact the Cougar formed my playstyle for many years, until I realized at some point the correct answer in most games is (almost) always an SMG. You may think it's something else, but it's always an SMG; bc math.
The Cougar, in the long-run, did me dirty. But at least it wasn't aKlobb (which perhaps explains why I didn't catch on to the RPM/DMG ratio of SMGs in games until later; because of the weird damage lag in GE).
Looking-back at my own little corner of memories, there's a lot that I'd consider 'sub-standard' today, that I adored 'back then'.
Heck, (probably) more than half of what I know about computers, comes from fixing problems with hardware and software, just trying to play vidya gaems :rolleyes:"At the time"
Relative to what was on the market, and what consumers had seen (IIRC, DualShock wasn't even a rumor yet @ N64 release), N64 was shockingly revolutionary.
I hold no 'hate' for that console or its fans, but... IMO, if you weren't there, the N64 (as a package) was unimpressive and severely flawed (as most consumer products appear, with hindsight)
Once PlayStation/PSX/PSone introduced Dual Analog Joystick DualShock, the N64 controller made absolutely no sense.
As the years piled on, the very-proprietary N64 Jstick has aged terribly on most examples (by any modern standard).
I hold 0 trust for what Nintendo thinks is best; especially, when it comes to HIDs.
Credit due on the GameCube's controller, though -and, at least they're actively advertising keyboard and mouse support w/ the Switch2
TBQH, there's enough esoteria wrapped-up in Games and Game Consoles / -marketing, I get confused as to what's attached with what :roll: