Monday, April 7th 2025
Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
Following last week's jam-packed Switch 2 presentation, Nintendo staffers engaged in conversation with media outlets. To the surprise of many, a high level member of the incoming console's design team was quite comfortable with his name-dropping of NVIDIA graphics technologies. Meanwhile, Team Green was tasked with the disclosing of Switch 2's "internal" workings. Attention has turned to the much anticipated-hybrid console's bundled-in detachable Joy-Cons—in the lead up to official unveilings, online debates swirled around potential next-gen controllers being upgraded with Hall Effect joystick modules. Many owners of first-gen Switch systems have expressed frustration regarding faulty Joy-Cons—eventually, Nintendo was coerced into offering free repairs for customers affected by dreaded "stick drift" issues. Unfortunately, it seems that the House of Mario has not opted to outfit its Gen 2.0 Joy-Cons with popular "anti-drift" tech.
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.
Sources:
Nintendo Life, The Verge (image source), VGC, Nintendo Life (full interview)
As reported by Nintendo Life, Nate Bihldorff—senior vice president of product development and publishing at Nintendo of America—"outright confirmed the exclusion" of Hall Effect. Up until the publication of Nintendo Life's sit down interview, other company representatives have opined that Switch 2's default control system features very "durable feeling" sticks. When asked about the reason behind "new-gen modules (feeling) so different to the original Switch's analog stick," Bihldorff responded with: "well, the Joy-Con 2's controllers have been designed from the ground up. They're not Hall Effect sticks, but they feel really good. Did you experience both the Joy-Con and the Pro Controller?" The interviewer confirmed that they had prior experience with both new models. In response, Bihldorff continued: "so, I like both, but that Pro Controller, for some reason the first time I grabbed it, I was like, 'this feels like a GameCube controller.' I was a GameCube guy. Something about it felt so familiar, but the stick on that especially. I tried to spend a lot of time making sure that it was quiet. I don't know if you tried really whacking the stick around, but it really is (quiet)...(The Switch 2 Pro Controller) is one of the quietest controllers I've ever played." Nintendo will likely not discuss the "ins and outs" of its proprietary stick design, but inevitable independent teardowns of commercial hardware could verify the provenance of underlying mechanisms. Nowadays, hardcore game controller snobs prefer third-party solutions that sport Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) joysticks.



122 Comments on Nintendo Confirms That Switch 2 Joy-Cons Will Not Utilize Hall Effect Stick Technology
"You, like others in this discussion, are fixated on a problem that no longer exists, hasn't existed for a number of years and will not come about again because it's been engineered out."
It's almost like your statement is that their delivery is fine. Nintendo is fine. You wallow in your ignorance about it, but that's fine. It's almost like my wording is that I recognize that because you are willfully ignorant I see how you might interpret reality wrong. Of course, quoting out of context is a symptom of that. I can see how willfully ignorant works....but that's not acceptance. It's acknowledgement that you cannot fix willfully ignorant. You'll note that I cited data against your point, then responded how someone could reasonably come to your point. It's almost like instead of being a raging opinion I can understand multiple points.
So...maybe instead of being a raging opinionated fool, who has to win, you can get some education and understand why people might have another opinion. That is the heart of discourse. I shared links with you, because I expect you to at least engage with reading them...so maybe you can be better. The discourse back is that edge of the rules insulting that I could argue is a violation of the terms of service assuming I had paper instead of skin...but that's because I'd prefer somebody have the right to call me an ass than be bullied into not hurting my feelings by a TOS. Ironically, like Nintendo loves to do...which is why I feel reasonable in linking all of this back to the Switch 2 deciding to use variable resistance rather than a proper hall effect sensor...while charging a premium price for their new 1920x1080 focused console in 2025.
Let's discuss why that matters, because it does. The PS4 launched in 2013 with 1920x1080. The Xbox one also launched in 2013. The Nintendo WiiU came out in 2012...and theoretically was 1080p...while in practice it came with component video output. It's library is tiny, like all Nintendo consoles barring the Gameboy/DS. People often remember the best stuff like Mario and Zelda games. They conveniently forget that the PS2 had over 4000 games released for it...while the N64 had 388. They claim that Nintendo releases only bangers...while forgetting that the shovelware actually outmatches the good games like on all of the consoles...meaning that 2% of 4000 games is the same as 20% of 400. As such, the "Nintendo is better" argument dies by lack of support from anything but first and second party software.
It's really easy to be entirely ignorant of all of this, because you're just too lazy to do the basic research...because you just want to play the games. I'd even agree with you, if this wasn't about the Switch 2 which is priced as a premium good. It's making the argument that $90 for a game is acceptable. It's making the argument that literal pennies more in production are an acceptable compromise to get a controller that is basically impervious to degrading. From where I sit, that's Nintendo being big kings of crap mountain. I...would suggest that they go sit and spin if they want to charge me the premium price they are suggesting without having the core works being bullet proof...and the lack of halls effect sensing is just the poisoned cherry atop the pile of decaying carcasses that Nintendo wants to pretend is the immaculate "Ice Cream Sunday" that they've gifted the consumer with the opportunity to purchase.
Closing the last loop hole in discussions...the "important thing" is not implying anything about the Switch 2 as important. It's important to think critically about what you are saying, isolate your own biases, and think about what the other opinion will present. I do that, and it's how I know the Switch 2 will still move plenty of consoles. $450 is a silly high price tag...but people will always claim buying a Nintendo console will mean at least 6 bangers. Mario, Mario Cart, Super Smash, Zelda, Mario Party, and Pokemon. They'll claim that $90 isn't so bad, because we already spend that with one DLC pack, or skins, or a premium battle pass, or something else. They'll claim that it's like having a PC and a Steam deck. All of these will be people who cannot think critically justifying that whatever decision they made was fine...and some of it will be bouyed by the obvious love Nintendo has cultivated while hiding their true nature for years.
Now that I've said all of that...I hope it's obvious that I actually detest willful ignorance, so what I'm telling you is in fact "I understand you, and reject the core of ignorance which powers you decisions. Despite understanding you, I believe you to be making a stupid decision via cancerous stupidity. That is...not something to respect, and therefore your ignorance needs to be rectified. I hope you learn something, but given this is the internet the truth is I think you're going to respond by braying back at me with your opinions wielded as though your faith in them makes them facts...and I'll get to listen to another rant about me try to tip-toe around just calling me something because they don't like my opinion or, god forbid, having to read to understand a more complex opinion than 'suck it.'"
Do stop, you're not helping yourself.
Wow. If you change nothing then nothing changes. Except, Nintendo has jacked that price up. The problem with all sensing based off of surfaces that wear is that they wear. Resistance changes, readings drift, old stuff is bad.
This is why using the hall effect, or voltage induced by magnetism, is great. Your moving parts can wear, and there's no impact. Your sensing parts have no contact, so no loss. This would be different if it was 10 years ago when these sensors sucked, were insanely expensive, and generally lacked anything substantive. Now they want to charge what they want to charge, and will gladly save a few pennies instead of designing things that will last for decades. Whatever, there's a slavering legion of fanboys who will be back complaining in 2-3 years, along with children who can get their parents to buy them anything to just shut them up. Nintendo has already won, and their prize may well be to have everyone remember them as the next Atari of crashing gaming.
Fast forward to today. I speak for the US experience...so yours may vary. Today, those kids who grew up with the Madcatz controller are looking at a $50 joycon, or potentially at a third party option that uses halls effects sensors and will be another 20-30 dollars. They know Nintendo consoles work the way they work...so they know that a 50% increase in initial price to not have to buy two new controllers over the lifespan of the ~7-10 years their console is viable is a no-brainer. Nintendo now loses out on a $50 sale. It loses out, and they theoretically could have charged $60 and sold that improvement back to the consumer, who knows that it's a few cents of electronics but would likely absorb that cost as simply part of what it takes.
So...as a person who hates Madcatz, has spent more than $150 on a keyboard because it felt better to use, and has put down some money on mice that are definitely not rewriting performance standards but do focus on use, I'm looking at Nintendo and seeing that it's helmed by the kind of idiots who don't understand what motivates people. They don't see that people don't resell games, they see captured markets that they can largely set pricing on because of their reputation. A reputation built on a Nintendo whose executives took pay cuts rather than firing people, and that one example is more than enough to show you why Bowser making the decisions at Nintendo is...poetic and ironic justice.
But there is a track record of similar sticks in different devices. The Switch was a very poor performer. I think you're right about bell curve and there is merit in the idea iterative improvements/refinements have caused this. But that also immediately confirms there is no 'cure-all' fix for the Switch. Sometimes the whole design is just limited in what can be done. I also wouldn't dismiss the influence of the internet and attention span hype - it creates bell curves for anything really.
Perhaps the Switch 2 will fare better. Perhaps it will do worse. Its not out for long enough to know. Its certainly too early and no more than a guesstimate that their sticks are now on the level of, say, a Playstation 3 dualshock (which I still use.... without drift... while I also have a non dualshock PS3 Sixaxis that has drift). The fact is, there have been generations of controller hardware that barely have drift, or where it is in such low % or after such intensive use, that its totally acceptable. With these dualshocks I'm wondering when and if they ever go bad... its crazy how many hours I've used them. Its very clear the Switch sticks are nowhere near that level of quality.Duh. Nintendo has a market niche on lockdown. They have no inspiration to improve other than high service expenses. And even if they did... everything is done to save pennies. We speak of a marketplace that is full of RROD's, plastic laser lenses for a blu ray player (PS3), etc etc etc.
They're cheap toys for mass markets but when they command decent hardware-level prices while STILL locking you into an ecosystem... we really can and should expect more.Bingo.
This is exactly why I can't stand the naive unproven nonsense coming from people like @lexluthermiester . We need more reality in commerce and less inflated marketing bullshit. As I pointed out above... its all about track record. And the track record inspires in every possible way that we approach commerce with extreme levels of due diligence in 2025.
The only solution to regain some of my freedom, from software to hardware, was to adopt the PC as my gaming platform. Here, I'm the boss. I use the hardware I want the way I want, I play the games I want the way I want, on my terms. If I want to play on an NES controller or the latest, most advanced controller with programmable macros, Hall effect sticks and linear resonant actuator rumble motors - I can do it. It's never been a better time to own a PC, and if you're in need of mobility? Grab a ROG Ally instead. We live in the golden age of the handheld, after all.I agree, but have to let this rant out... I utterly despise console gaming, but even it is eventually going to reach a crossroads through natural progression: will these devices continue to be treated as toys, sold in toy retail chains like in the 1980s and 1990s, chastised as infantile entertainment devices designed for children, subject to heavy software censorship and strict controls on "authorized" hardware, inevitably marching towards the next video game crash thanks to corporate constantly overstepping into every aspect of the experience, or will they loosen up on these subjects at the cost of losing control and giving up on some immediate profits? All indicates that the former is the most likely to occur, and perhaps the Nintendo Switch champions this problem by aggressively marketing towards tourists and these problem audiences while, in fact, we need to head towards some gatekeeping instead.
For the last time people: Hall effect sensors are NOT immune to calibration problems, they are not the only answer nor are they essential for good controller engineering. There are many excellent technologies that can and are utilized for control sticks. Anyone who argues against this factual logic needs to pull their head out from the sand, or their bum. Perhaps both.
What I've said is that the halls effect sensor is a very cheap way to add huge amounts of endurance, and that you could get consumers who already know that their console is going to last for 7-10 years to pay for that upgrade and then some. You come back at me and want to then make this both an argument about Nintendo wanting to cheap out on components because they know you'll buy more, and then that there's a calculation of some sort. So...what is it? Planned obsolescence, or betting that their testing lifespan is such that the usage bell curve will cover the cost on spread and damage to reputation?
I'll wait for a second...and in that time I'll -Edit-try explain why that distinction matters enough to be considered -Edit end-. Things that are well controlled generally exist on a bell curve. If we are talking a sensor, 5% fail in under 100 hours, 50% in 120 hours, and 95% is 140 hours. You have to either spec so that your failures will be outliers (rating the sensor at 20 hours before failure as an example), or that the cost of those failures will not impact your bottom line. IE, a product sold with 50% GP can have one fail for every success and still largely be profitable.
Likewise, there is a curve for users. Some people play their consoles for hundreds of hours, others dozens. The people who have a console for a dozen hours are going to experience less failures necessarily than those that play for hundreds. If you want that in action, look up the "special" controllers debate with super smash tournaments.
In practice, the overlaps in these curves are where failures exist. The 12 hour user with a 36 hour sensor doesn't see the failure, but the 100 hour user with the 24 hour failure sees at least one (and 4 if they get similar sensors). -Edit- My point here being that Nintendo is rolling the dice on the sensors not failing rather than replacing them with a technology that does not fail. In risk assessment this would be like deciding that an RPN of 120 shouldn't be addressed and turned into 60 because of the three cents it'd cost...while people are begging to pay you $10 for the improvement. IE, concentrated nepotism or laziness in design to feed measurable failure rates. Either way, disrespecting the investment customers make in your product. -Edit end-
That almost seems like Nintendo didn't decide this based upon a cost of ownership case. What they did was look at old source, get quote, and decide that whatever was already implemented was fine. That's not a sourcing decision, so much as someone avoiding the cost of development or testing by pressing ctrl+c and ctrl+v on the data from the last stuff, and calling it a win because it saved them some money in the development cycle. It's like how Madcatz always undercut the quality of first party, and always cost less...but were utterly despised because they were shit.
So...I've obviously setup a conclusion here. What's yours? My conclusion is that Nintendo is shoveling crap because they refuse to make anything better, because at the end of the day they do not have to. If you think that's fine and acceptable...then I can't really do anything for you. -EDIT-If you aren't frustrated with their refusal to update demonstrably bad technology, -Edit end- you'll accept this slop, and you should be happy to do it -Edit-(because it's your choice to buy it)-Edit end- . If instead you are what you portray, and have moved to the PC gaming side because you don't tolerate half arsed, then you should be calling for Nintendo to be better...which would mean not tolerating their slop. I...have a soft spot for the big N...and I'd like to see them give us an $80 dollar game that is worth $80...on a $450 console that is worth $450. Unfortunately, I see them giving us more fees, lesser quality, and justifying it all as the price of doing business...which gets my goat.
-Edit-
So we are clear...because it seems like this was not how it was read...the "you" here is not me talking about a person specifically. It's me talking about someone who is fine with letting this happen.
I don't really care about motivation here. If it's because you think I'm being unreasonable, fine. If it's because you never had a problem, fine. If it's because you believe it doesn't influence you, also fine. I cannot influence you to care, and thus cannot do anything to or for you. All I can do is express my personal distaste that Nintendo is offering a premium priced console with bargain tier sensing technology...and that's silly.
-Edit end-
Voting with my wallet is all I can really do, after all. ;)
Discuss the topic and not each other.
Stop personal attacks and insults.
If you read through the EULA for your console, you'll find that Nintendo can remotely deactivate your console. That sounds like paranoia...but one of the specific clauses which is cited is:
"
- Reasons for Deactivation:
"Violations like using unauthorized software, modifying the console, or using unlicensed accessories could lead to remote deactivation.
I want you to journey along with me, and look at an Apple product. They have a very easy to replace (with regards to anything Apple) fingerprint scanner. What happens when you damage it? You have to go to the genious bar, ask a nerd to fix the thing, and discover that the fingerprint scanner costs damn near as much to replace as an entire phone. Should you do it on your own....then physically replacing it results in complete bricking. Here's the link to an explanation: Apple - home button bricking
The exact same clause is what Nintendo introduced with the new EULA for the Switch 2. Imagine one day Nintendo decides that the replacement halls effect sensor is in fact a cheat...so the next software rollout bricks your console because you decided to replace the crappy sensors you replaced yourself...all because Nintendo decided the cheaper old stuff was fine. That's not imagination...and Apple has demonstrated it technically very feasible...so while DIY is a solution it's also one that carries huge risks given how Nintendo has decided to exercise their legal rights for the console itself.
I can absolutely see why Nintendo made every decision they made. The EULA is about stopping homebrew and piracy. The sensor is theoretically about delivering the consumer the lowest possible price...if you ignore the actual price of the console...because a cheaper solution that yields 80% of the result from 50% of the cost is easy to justify on paper. Just ignore that 50% of 4 cents is 2 cents, and the console is 50000 cents, so the 2 cent difference is 0.004% of the overall cost. I can also see the people who buy a Nintendo console for 8 games a generation don't really care, because the extra $40 a year in expenditures is less than a tank of gasoline. That said, I believe this is a line that we need to draw in the sand, to stop it from getting worse everywhere. 2 cent halls effect sensors today might be $5 of VRAM tomorrow... You make up your own analogy.
Anyhow, the remote bricking by Nintendo so they can "protect their IP" is unlikely to hold in court in most countries in the world, not to mention it's a "BWE situation" (I presume you've watched Louis Rossmann's channel lately, and if not, it's where I'll point you for context).
I could have also chosen any one of a dozen other Apple things...but you are missing the point. The point was to demonstrate that the ability to brick your crap based upon modifications was not a theoretical threat. This isn't the magical vans that detected TV vans from Britain that "proved" you needed to pay a fee for their OTA TV service. They are not me being paranoid, the ability is something we already have proven. It's also why I think that we are not diverting from the Nintendo conversation, despite talking Apple, assuming we don't use it as anything but a proof of concept.
Now...protecting their IP is...funny. If we think about this, then we're looking at what could just be a simple lock from access online. There are parallels to this with the Xbox, where hacked consoles were not allowed to participate in online services. That's the "optimistic" end of the assumptions. You are now buying games from Nintendo that require a download. Yes, that $80 cart might not have the game, and might just be a code to go online and download the rest of the thing day one. Now, think about how that will impact your experience...because you installed a halls effect joystick you can now no longer use your $80 game because the downloading service won't let you actually go online because it locked you out. That...well, that sucks.
Why be so hyperbolic? Well, I started with the Apple example to prove that I wasn't just tripping. I also wanted to demonstrate that a black screen wasn't the only brick that would stop us...because simply forcing no downloading in an environment where you own nothing after paying $80 for a plastic sleeve is a...not sugar coating here, really shitty situation. So...yeah. Nintendo has constructed a console future that can go suck lemons. That said, here we are. People still think this is about just a joystick, because seeing the entire picture makes you think the big N had gone from Mario to Bowser in a single generation. The silliest thing is that if Nintendo had put forward even a minimum effort we'd be discussing other things, but their refusal to make competent choices has become emblematic of their general decline, so there's just no joy in that joystick.
Banning modified consoles from participating in their online network is understandable, as some form of anti-cheat, even. That's fair enough, I reckon. Bricking the device and rendering it unusable, though? Not acceptable in the slightest. Third-party/modded joycons shouldn't interfere with that, though - no console manufacturer has been known to ban for third party controllers.
All they're interested on, at least for the time being, is their aggro DRM for regional lockout enforcement and making sure you can only use your device the way they've authorized you to, including all software that they generously "granted you the "license" to use, on their terms". Makes me wanna puke, and I'm not exactly a GNU-totin' freetard type of guy,